[1] http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/additional/D...
There are charities who take in millions of dollars, keep some, and spend the rest to send bibles to Africa. By every measure, they're "killing it": they have a well-paid staff, a happy donation base, and they send out a heckuva lot of bibles. It's an easy business model to copy, and an almost-guaranteed smash-hit in terms of getting returns on investment. But, here's the rub--do you think there's any evidence that sending people bibles increases their quality-of-life?
Basically, I'm hoping here that PG is getting into the nonprofit sector because he wants to help people--not just to become (more) rich by looking like he's helping people.
Caveat: Givewell tends to focus attention on nonprofits with well-validated, very-high-probability, easily-quantifiable effects which is not where one would expect the greatest expected value from daring new attempts to be located. Nonetheless I would expect that talking to Givewell would be very epistemically profitable if you are just venturing out into the nonprofit space.
Evergreen funding source/s is (arguably) the definition of success, for any organization, profit or otherwhise, at least empirically. Competition for scarce resources is thus a key part of the game.
The CEO of MOMA (non-profit) has a salary approaching $2MM/yr. This is rationally viewed as a sales comission ($2mm/ on $XXmm in fundraising prowess) by the trustees. There is no other measure of 'productivity' at that order of magnitude for a "non-profit" organization (10x the statuatory salary of POTUS). Similarly, at non-profit universities. Both in the administration and elsewhere (multi-million dollar salaries for NCAA D1 sports linked with television contracts). Comparably, also the Clinton Foundation, per this recent note from the NY Times:
Worried that the foundation’s operating revenues depend too heavily on Mr. Clinton’s nonstop fund-raising, the three Clintons are embarking on a drive to raise an endowment of as much as $250 million, with events already scheduled in the Hamptons and London.
But they happen to also be the CEO, formally in charge of the whole operation, and further tend to set the tone for that operation. Then you have the fundraising tail wagging the mission dog. As a result, some nonprofits (and universities) start to look more like weird corporations that exist to perpetuate themselves and their top staff, with some kind of mumbo jumbo relating to public service being an official goal but nowhere near the top of the priority list. An organization that exists primarily to perpetuate itself and pay its staff well is perfectly fine, but then it doesn't really have any business claiming to be a charity...
Education: http://www.dartblog.com/images/CHE%20Salaries%20Ivies%20Comp...
ART/culture: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2010/04/26/arts/salaries....
Sports/NCAA: http://www.philsteele.com/blogs/2012/Mar12/DBMar15.html
Charities/Misc: http://www.charitywatch.org/hottopics/Top25.html
______
sample: Robert J. Mazzuca, Past Chief Scout Executive Boy Scouts of America - N.O. $987,412
This is a bit naive. As someone who has worked a bit with non-profits, neglecting sales (and the whole "how do we get money in the door" part) of nonprofits is often what causes them to fail.
PG, assuming that you're as connected in the business world as I assume you are, I would recommend reaching out to John Wood, author of "Leaving Microsoft to Change the World" - http://www.leavingmicrosoftbook.com/ His book fundamentally changed my view on how successful nonprofits are built.
Also, I find the "how do you make money" question still the most important. Sure a non-profit shouldn't focus on making money, but the more money it can pull in, the bigger its impact is and the higher the likelihood for success.
For Profit - https://gist.github.com/e1ven/6467215
Non Profit- https://gist.github.com/e1ven/6467309
Overall, it seems like they've replaced 'company' with 'organization', and dropped a number of questions relating to making money.
Interestingly, many of the questions have been dropped without replacement, even when I would imagine the answer would be very interesting to YC!
For instance, 'Who are your competitors' has been dropped entirely. Nonprofit companies can certainly compete with one another.. But they also often compete with for-profit companies.
Take for example Wikipedia - They're a 501(c)(3) but they've certainly competed with Encyclopedia Britannica, Grolier, Encarta, etc. It might be helpful to keep the questions, but to ask them in a modified way. For instance, "Who is this going to disrupt?"
Similarly they dropped "How do or will you make money?", without replacing it with "How do you plan to you raise money?"
"How will you get users", and "Was any of your code written by someone who is not one of your founders?" were also dropped.
They also haven't (yet) added questions relating to non-profits, such as "Why do you think you will be able to get a 501c(3) classification?"
It's a really interesting idea, and it'll be interesting to see where they grow with it.
It really reminds me of the first few years of YC where they were making it up as they went along, before they started the current cycle of continuous improvements through validated learning.
Watsi was the MVP, now they're ready for Beta ;)