News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by teach on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:28PM (#6335519)
This is an interesting story but the writing style is so poor I can't make it through. Prose this disjointed would probably make a decent screenplay but it's a bad fit for an essay.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by ChuckMcM on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:36PM (#6335569)
I would definitely consider it a candidate for bad writing sample of the year. And as overly flowery and obfuscated as the writing is, it can't really dress up a pretty mundane story.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by finnh on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:33PM (#6335555)
No joke. I kept scrolling, looking for the paragraph when he quits the "trying to be funny for the intro" style and switches to a normal, readable mode.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by contingencies on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:49PM (#6335648)
It's perhaps part of the Australian culture to jovially dig at serious issues in life through stories and then cast them aside as incomplete potential tangents. You know, inflate the size of a crocodile over here, casually pull half a million a day back here, ethical about-turn over there. We call it "havin' a yarn". I'm not sure if the writer was Australian, but the style and the story sure are! So what makes you a literary critic anyway, mate? Get off ya high horse and crack a tinny will ya! Tell ya what, I've got an esky full of champpers back 'ere somewhere!
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by jessaustin on Thursday September 05, 2013 @02:51PM (#6336061)
The style of writing is suited to its purpose. This isn't a news report; it isn't vital to impart maximum information in minimum space. Rather, the writer was conveying the feeling of the situation in which he found himself. "Dave" is ridiculous and disjointed, so it is fitting that prose devoted to him would be as well.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by jonnathanson on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:22PM (#6338027)
Visceral description has its place, but it needs to be used sparingly. This guy's prose runs so purple it verges on eggplant (or, as he'd probably say, aubergine). And the various slips in and out of Aussie vernacular are jarring. I understand the intended effect, but it's like salt on your scrambled eggs: a little bit goes a long way. Too much, and the salt's all you can taste.

He can turn a clever phrase, but he tends to indulge himself. When he does, he gets way too cute. He's got the descriptive power to be a great writer, but he needs to be a better self editor.

Reading this story reminded me of my endurance-slog through the first few chapters of A Game of Thrones. George R. R. Martin is a fantastic storyteller, but he's also a serial adjective abuser. Same thing here. The story almost gets lost in the words. What we gain in postcard moments, we lose in pacing and flow.

Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by Terretta on Thursday September 05, 2013 @11:12PM (#6338477)
Stephen King recently rewrote the Gunslinger (first dark tower book) by mostly deleting the florid "serial adjective abuse". He goes into it in detail in the forward. The result isn't Hemingway, but it is more readable, and actually feels richer as more is left for your brain to fill in.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by cpncrunch on Thursday September 05, 2013 @02:54PM (#6336083)
Perhaps the problem is that hackers don't do much reading apart from man pages. Literature...does not compute.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by andolanra on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:04PM (#6336576)
But the article submitted is in no way literature. It'd be one thing if the disjointed, rambling style served the content... but in this context, such a writing style is unnecessary at best and distracting at worst. Rhyming couplets in dactylic hexameter are similarly beautiful and 'literary', but that doesn't make them an appropriate vehicle for long-form essays, as well.

And frankly, the style isn't very good to begin with. It feels inflated and cloying, like a freshman essay in strong need of an editor. But even if it were an exemplar of its style, I'd still hold it to be unnecessary here.

Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by cpncrunch on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:30PM (#6337190)
I'm confused as to why you think a "disjointed, rambling style" is out of context when that is precisely how Dave's personality would be described.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by andolanra on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:47PM (#6337898)
The subheading of the article tells us, "This Man Moved to a Desert Island in Order to Vanish. Here's What Happened." Assuming that the point of the article is to tell us what happened, then the writing style is extraneous, regardless of whether the man in question acts similarly. If the article said, "Here's what it's like to talk to Dave," then the writing style would be more appropriate. As it is, it gets in the way of finding out "what happened." Note that, say, A Beautiful Mind was not written in the form of a schizophrenic's paranoid ramblings, no matter how much that would reflect John Nash's personality during segments of the book.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by wambotron on Thursday September 05, 2013 @03:55PM (#6336528)
I barely read man pages and read a ton of literature. It's written poorly and couldn't keep my interest. It's funny, because the idea of a desert island is really interesting to me. Somehow this guy made it dull and annoying.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by JabavuAdams on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:16PM (#6337068)
Please. The writing is sophomoric ... I mean the writing is purple, like the sun setting behind a gauze of pacific clouds.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by sxcurry on Thursday September 05, 2013 @03:55PM (#6336527)
I've read literature and New Republic this isn't literature!
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by baddox on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:50PM (#6337913)
Or perhaps people don't like being annoyed by things they read, regardless of what the reason may be for the annoyance.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by nickthemagicman on Thursday September 05, 2013 @02:04PM (#6335750)
"After a dozen cathartic strokes, he looked up, and there was Dave, his logorrheic caddy, yippy-yapping about: trickle-down economics and the importance of job creators (There being nothing wrong with making money!)."

Is that even a sentence?

Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by cpncrunch on Thursday September 05, 2013 @02:45PM (#6336028)
It's written as if Dave is talking. Seemed pretty obvious to me, and it works well in my opinion.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by freehunter on Thursday September 05, 2013 @03:40PM (#6336426)
There were too many words that I did not know that seemed to be made up. Possibly they are just Australian English words, but it frustrated me in the way that reading a book in a foreign language I only partially understand frustrates me. More time is spent trying to guess the meaning of the word than is spent enjoying the reading.

"logorrheic caddy, yippy-yapping about" or "the crash led to them having some pretty heavy ding-dongs" - this may as well be French from as well as I understand what is trying to be said.

Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by cpncrunch on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:39PM (#6336779)
Yes, I think they are all Australian colloquilisms. A few I didn't know, but it didn't bother me. I thought "ding dong" and "yip yapping" were fairly obvious anyway, and words like "Sheila" would be known to you if you know a tiny bit about Australian culture.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by nickthemagicman on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:20AM (#6339274)
Yeah but IS THAT A SENTENCE.

Hint:(nope)

Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by cpncrunch on Friday September 06, 2013 @10:46AM (#6340691)
I just read it again, and it seems a perfectly valid sentence with all the usual bits in the correct places. What part in particular were you wondering about? caddy is a noun, logorrheic is an adjective, yippy-yapping a verb, etc.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by ripter on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:46PM (#6335628)
I read your comment and thought, It can't be that bad. I've seen some really terrible writing before, but something on hackernews can't be that bad.

It is. I struggled to make it through two paragraphs.

Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by cpeterso on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:20PM (#6338021)
The most impenetrable book I remember reading was A Tour of the Calculus by David Berlinski. Here's a representative sentence:

  Unlike Euclidean geometry, arithmetic rises directly from the wayward 
  human heart, the lub-dub under the physician's stethoscope or the lover's 
  ear (sounding very much like the words "so soon, it ends"), impossible to 
  hear without a mournful mental echo: 1, 2, 3, 4, ..., the doubled sounds, 
  that beating heart, those numerical echoes, cohering perfectly for as long 
  as any of us can count.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by zwischenzug on Thursday September 05, 2013 @03:34PM (#6336393)
I gave up trying to follow it. It sounded like it might be interesting, I just couldn't follow the thread and maintain any interest. There seemed to be no structure to the narrative.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by jlees on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:37PM (#6336763)
Isn't that the point? The author does more than just describe Dave's rambling brand of monologue; he translates that experience perfectly in the writing style.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by floobynewb on Thursday September 05, 2013 @06:24PM (#6337510)
Despite its disjointed nature I found that some interesting notions and feelings made their way out of the text and into my brain. I might even say that it was good. Definitely worth the effort for me.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by malandrew on Thursday September 05, 2013 @02:43PM (#6336015)
Same exact thing happened to me. This writing style is impenetrable.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by Hansi on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:06PM (#6336990)
I clicked the link without reading the comments and had the same thought straight away. Couldn't make it past the fifth paragraph despite trying my best.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by ZoF on Thursday September 05, 2013 @10:09PM (#6338302)
Haha it seems a lot of people here did... Validating in an odd sort of way.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by goshx on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:58PM (#6337383)
phew, now I feel better. Being a non native English speaker, I was wondering if the problem was my understanding of the language or the writing style.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by goshx on Thursday September 05, 2013 @06:07PM (#6337427)
probably both :)
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by tluyben2 on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:54AM (#6340152)
I was wondering why it took me so much effort to read this. I am interested in the story, but it's very tiring to get through it.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by sxcurry on Thursday September 05, 2013 @03:53PM (#6336511)
I tried to read the article while eating lunch, and had to stop (reading and eating). Does the word "florid" apply here?
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by teach on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:06PM (#6336987)
It does. Probably 'purple prose' as well.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by tomrod on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:19PM (#6338018)
It's bad design for mobile on top of poor prose. I can barely scroll to read it.
Re:This Man Moved to a Desert Island to Disappear. Here's Wh... by ScottBurson on Friday September 06, 2013 @12:58AM (#6338746)
I enjoyed it! To each their own, I guess.