News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by DanBC on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:17PM (#6335032)
This is good news, and research to help prevent, treat, or cure Down's Syndrome is probably a good thing.

But I'm gently squeamish about it. I know many people who have Down's Syndrome (and other learning disabilities) and me welcoming this research feels a bit like me saying those people should not exist.

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by presidentender on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:39PM (#6335152)
I have a cousin with Down's syndrome, and he is a delight.

Nobody here is saying that people with Down's shouldn't exist. We're saying that their lives would be easier and more productive if they didn't have impaired cognitive function.

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by MichaelSalib on Thursday September 05, 2013 @03:20PM (#6336288)
My brother has DS. I don't think we should fetishize neurological disorders. It is a heartbreaking disease: watching him lose the ability to communicate effectively with the world and withdraw inward has been the hardest thing I've had to see. DS cuts people off from the world and isolates them; no one should have that kind of loneliness and alienation forced on them.

Also, let's be clear about this: people with DS have a very high incidence of early dementia and Parkinson's disease. If we had a neurotypical group of people that had a mutation that caused a similarly high incidence of early dementia and Parkinson's, there'd be zero hesitation about treating them at birth so that they wouldn't have to suffer from dementia at age 35.

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by skunkednoH2O2 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:52PM (#6338253)
Autism is labeled as a "neurological disorder", do you like to apply these opinions to autistic people who want to keep their selves that have thus far developed? You "cure autism" and you remove all of the interactions that person's brain had with the world around them and the perspectives their neurology causes [?].
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by GeneralMayhem on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:02PM (#6335321)
Down's Syndrome IS a bad thing. It's a disability that inhibits their ability to function in society, and affects their physical health as well.

I can't imagine that anyone could possibly be worse off for having their case of Down's cured. That's not incompatible with accepting them for who they are with the disease.

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by gcr on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:22PM (#6335469)
Here's a thought experiment for you: Suppose your son, a DS patient, rejects the treatment on the grounds that they like having DS. As their caretaker, you have two choices.

- You can force them to submit to treatment, reasoning that their cognitive deficiency keeps them from understanding the implications of rejecting the treatment; or

- You can allow them to forego treatment and thus bear the (in your view) increased burden of taking care of them.

I ask out of curiousity rather than judgment. Which would you choose and why?

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by GeneralMayhem on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:05PM (#6336978)
Well, I'm not a parent, but I think I would choose the former. I think they're probably unable to understand the implications, particularly if it's a treatment that has to be done at birth, and I think my judgement is better than my young child's in any case. And it even helps my selfish side, because, as you point out, it makes it much easier to take care of him.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by hrkristian on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:50PM (#6335659)
There is a third side to this: Increased self-awareness. This treatment only caused the brain to develop normally, which would mean that in the case of humans with Downs the other downsides to the disease would remain (until another cure/treatment was found for those as well, of course.)

Would a person with DS who gains normal brain function really be better off afterwards? Would a large segment of the patients fall into depression? I have a brain damaged uncle and know just how much verbal/passive abuse these groups get in their day-to-day life, luckily in his condition it doesn't really get to him like it does a normal person.

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by icoder on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:50PM (#6338111)
This is a very good point. I remember watching a documentary a long time ago in wich people with DS but only moderate mental retardation became fairly frustrated with the fact that they looked/were different and wanting that to change.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by skunkednoH2O2 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:46PM (#6338227)
Ask this about autism and see what kind of "caregivers" are out there. Or, if you as a parent could not get services for your DS or autistic child, would you get a lighter sentence for the all-too-common DS and autistic murders out there? [The press treats caregiver originated murders gingerly too.] Autistic rights groups follow these developments painstakingly, often in dread of what the wider public incorrectly assumes from these very basic studies.[I hate science sensationalism with a passion.]
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by e12e on Friday September 06, 2013 @02:09AM (#6338945)
The book: "The Speed of Dark" by Elizabeth Moon has a similar theme to your question (but deals with autism, not downs syndrome).
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by rfrey on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:33PM (#6335120)
No, it's saying that you'd be happy if those people didn't have Down's Syndrome, and all the difficulties and health problems that go with it.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by VMG on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:55PM (#6335270)
I have a friend that has chronic pain. I'm all for treating the chronic pain, yet I don't feel like the friend should not exist.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by cortesoft on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:44PM (#6335182)
They would still exist, just without Down syndrome.

Are you worried about cures for cancer because it would be saying people without cancer shouldn't exist?

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by skunkednoH2O2 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:56PM (#6338263)
Are all neurological disorders like cancer? How do you apply this to autistics? Is our perspective on the world and our specific neurology a feared disease, should it be? DS people ask very similar questions.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by darkarmani on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:17PM (#6335420)
> I know many people who have Down's Syndrome (and other learning disabilities) and me welcoming this research feels a bit like me saying those people should not exist.

I was waiting for this sentiment to appear. I think if you carry that to it's logically extreme you'd also be against teaching them life skills and training to make them more independent because that would change who they are.

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by jff on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:30PM (#6335100)
That's an extremely odd attitude.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by mentat on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:26PM (#6335501)
Actually there's a similar attitude in the culturally Deaf. Their identity as it relates to their Deafness means that they even look down on those who try to make accommodations with having any hearing, the worst being a cochlear implant.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaf_culture

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by Jtsummers on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:10PM (#6335383)
It relates a bit to some of the discontinuities that have occurred between deaf communities and researchers working to correct the issues. Cochlear implants were not seen as a positive development by some (many?) deaf people.

The same attitude will have to be dealt with, to some extent, with anything that significantly alters a persons sensory or cognitive ability when a culture has developed around those limitations.

Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by TallGuyShort on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:54PM (#6335265)
It's like the "cure" for the mutant gene in X-men. Saying it needs to be cured can be interpreted as saying "it's bad that you have Down's Syndrome". Giving someone enhanced mental capacity would certainly help them, but I think for someone who's used to accepting and loving others for who they are, it isn't necessarily odd to have an uncomfortable reaction to the idea of "curing" them - even if, objectively, it's helping them.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by Jare on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:14PM (#6335404)
If you were advocating for killing them then yeah that feeling would make sense. As it is, you are saying you would like their disability to not exist, which I hope is the case.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by leoc on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:51PM (#6335668)
To be blunt, it's better than crushing their skulls and ripping them apart limb from limb, which is the preferred approach to dealing with people with Down's Syndrome in many countries at present, including the US.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by manicbovine on Thursday September 05, 2013 @02:41PM (#6336000)
What? Can you elaborate?
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by freehunter on Thursday September 05, 2013 @03:05PM (#6336176)
I think he's using colorful language to describe the process of abortion.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by R_Edward on Thursday September 05, 2013 @03:10PM (#6336209)
I think it's a reference to abortion.
Re:Down syndrome reversed in newborn mice with single injection by faddotio on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:57PM (#6338270)
People with Down's Syndrome don't live very long. It's more than just a mental disability.