Nobody here is saying that people with Down's shouldn't exist. We're saying that their lives would be easier and more productive if they didn't have impaired cognitive function.
Also, let's be clear about this: people with DS have a very high incidence of early dementia and Parkinson's disease. If we had a neurotypical group of people that had a mutation that caused a similarly high incidence of early dementia and Parkinson's, there'd be zero hesitation about treating them at birth so that they wouldn't have to suffer from dementia at age 35.
I can't imagine that anyone could possibly be worse off for having their case of Down's cured. That's not incompatible with accepting them for who they are with the disease.
- You can force them to submit to treatment, reasoning that their cognitive deficiency keeps them from understanding the implications of rejecting the treatment; or
- You can allow them to forego treatment and thus bear the (in your view) increased burden of taking care of them.
I ask out of curiousity rather than judgment. Which would you choose and why?
Would a person with DS who gains normal brain function really be better off afterwards? Would a large segment of the patients fall into depression? I have a brain damaged uncle and know just how much verbal/passive abuse these groups get in their day-to-day life, luckily in his condition it doesn't really get to him like it does a normal person.
Are you worried about cures for cancer because it would be saying people without cancer shouldn't exist?
I was waiting for this sentiment to appear. I think if you carry that to it's logically extreme you'd also be against teaching them life skills and training to make them more independent because that would change who they are.
The same attitude will have to be dealt with, to some extent, with anything that significantly alters a persons sensory or cognitive ability when a culture has developed around those limitations.
But I'm gently squeamish about it. I know many people who have Down's Syndrome (and other learning disabilities) and me welcoming this research feels a bit like me saying those people should not exist.