News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Effective Scala by obilgic on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:01AM (#6333837)
The question i have been struggling to answer for few months now: Scala or Go?
Re:Effective Scala by trailfox on Thursday September 05, 2013 @10:51AM (#6334544)
Pick Scala if:

  -You think a fusion of OO and functional programming is the way of the future
  -Runtime tooling and advanced instrumentation support matter to you
  -You like having first-class IDE support
  -You want to work for the likes of Twitter/Foursquare/LinkedIn/Amazon
  -Having tons of mature Java libraries available matters to you.
  -You don't mind investing time to learn the language
Pick Go if:

  -Memory footprint matter to you (and you don't want to pick C)
  -Startup time matters to you (and you don't want to pick C)
  -You don't want to spend much time learning the language
  -You like C-style error handling and aren't expecting something as expressive as a python or a ruby.
  -You don't mind limited IDE support
  -You want every post of yours to be voted up on HN regardless of content
Re:Effective Scala by Refefer on Thursday September 05, 2013 @11:48AM (#6334869)
I would add a few more:

Pick Scala if:

    -You find value in strong static assurances.
    -You find value in generics.
    -You want to learn functional programming, not 'functional' programming (and you should).
    -You value succinctness.
Pick Go if:

    -Compile times matter (of course it does).
    -You find value in easier deployments (at the cost of potentially more deployments).
    -You don't want to learn D ;)
Re:Effective Scala by saosebastiao on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:16PM (#6335026)
Ha...love the last line. If I were in the market for something that solves the problems that Go attempts to solve, I would learn D. I just wish DMD was fully open source...it is awesome when you go to try a new language and all you have to do is "sudo apt-get ...".
Re:Effective Scala by asdasf on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:37PM (#6335136)
I believe that very small sounding issue has played a huge role in D being as uncommonly used as it is. It seems like a trivial thing, but the ability to just pkg_add languageX is incredibly important for adoption.
Re:Effective Scala by narwally on Friday September 06, 2013 @02:12PM (#6341791)
I don't think this is a small issue at all. I love reading through an interesting tutorial, and being able to apt-get install the language or libraries I need to work along with it. But if you make me jump through a bunch of hoops just to work through a tutorial, forgetaboutit!
Re:Effective Scala by dustingetz on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:07PM (#6336594)
Pick Go if: your only other option is C

Pick Scala if: all other things

Re:Effective Scala by crypto5 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:23PM (#6338032)
> -Memory footprint matter to you (and you don't want to pick C)

Is there any clear evidence of better memory management in Go comparing to JVM?

Re:Effective Scala by programminggeek on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:55PM (#6338260)
Re:Effective Scala by crypto5 on Friday September 06, 2013 @01:51AM (#6338902)
For memory intensive tests the score is 2-3 there.
Re:Effective Scala by fnl on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:20AM (#6333955)
I had been asking myself the same question over the last few months, maybe even longer. The final selling point for me was lines of code, caused by the feature-richness of Scala. While implementing a few generic data collections and algorithms I need for my project, I realized that in Go this resulted in much more code than in Scala, or I would have had to sacrifice type safety by declaring everything an interface{} (sort of Go's version of a "void pointer" for C guys). I now have solved this by using Go as my favorite "scripting-like" language because it is so easy to bootstrap something there, and it is nice to quickly build efficient binaries and even wrap a C library. But to manage huge code bases and projects, for me the choice in the end became rather obvious. Particularly, with respect to all the magnificent capabilities starting from generics (~ C++ Templates), to higher kinds, the coming macros, etc. that help to create succinct DSLs and the general benefit "FP && OO", over "FP || OO", in the end made this decision obvious to me. And I have not even touched the issue of the gigantic collection of Java libraries and frameworks you automatically get by choosing Scala...
Re:Effective Scala by MrBuddyCasino on Thursday September 05, 2013 @10:02AM (#6334218)
Well, if you already use the JVM, its Scala of course.

But ask yourself this: do you work in a team or alone? One of the first sentences is:

"While highly effective, Scala is also a large language, and our experiences have taught us to practice great care in its application."

And thats the biggest issue - Scala is a bit like the JVMs C++, you need capable programmers in order to not fuck it up, because it contains every paradigm ever invented.

Go on the other hand is much simpler, and I like it for that - there is great value in simplicity.

Re:Effective Scala by bad_user on Thursday September 05, 2013 @02:11PM (#6335798)
I've been working with Scala for the last 2 years, and I also worked with C++. People claiming that Scala resembles in any way with C++ haven't worked with neither of them.

Also, when speaking of simplicity, I like languages with conceptual elegance. Scheme is simple too and that's a rather interesting example. You see, Scheme is homoiconic and has macros and continuations, a combination so powerful that you can easily build on top and efficiently use any pattern or paradigm under the sun. Also, being a Lisp, most builtins can be reimplemented in Scheme.

Now that's simple. What you're describing is actually easyness which is a very different notion. The main difference is that easiness is relative and depends on someone's own biases or limitations. The problem of course is that easy can overnight turn into hard.

Ever tried doing FP in Go? Ever thought about implementing your own data-structures? Try it.

Re:Effective Scala by yohanatan on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:39PM (#6337252)
"Haven't worked with neither" is a double negative. Also, 'resembles with' is redundant--'resembles' is sufficient.

I have written both Scala and C++ at my day jobs and I would say that Scala certainly does generally remind me of C++ and specifically in its proliferation of language features. I also know of several others with similar experience and opinion on this matter.

Re:Effective Scala by ericssmith on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:56PM (#6337937)
I've worked with C++ going back to the mid 90s, and program Scala full-time in addition to managing a team of programmers. Such a comparison has never occurred to me. Scala is arguably a simple language in its core design. It enables quite feature-rich libraries, and you could argue those make the language seem complex in practice. But to me, it just shows the language is powerful.
Re:Effective Scala by pivo on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:02PM (#6338129)
I really do like Scala, however I also find it to be similar to C++ in the sense that lots of the Scala code I've read seems to be written by people who trade simplicity of implementation for being able to use every single feature of the language all at once. In other words, people unable to resist the urge to be too clever.

Sometimes the result is Scala source files that almost appear to be written in different languages, or lots of little libraries each with their own wacky DSLs that require a major investment of time to comprehend just to accomplish something that should be trivial.

These sorts of abuses you really don't see in Clojure even though it's just as possible in that language. Of course this is all based just on my experience, YMMV.

Re:Effective Scala by ericssmith on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:30AM (#6340054)
I think DSLs, heavy use of operators, and Unicode characters as identifiers isn't abuse. It's unfamiliar. In Haskell, for instance, syntax is taken much more seriously than in other languages, which tend to just copy previous languages in the name of familiarity. And it takes a while to become use to the basic syntax of Haskell, let alone the various libraries that extend on its ideas. But the syntax choices are not arbitrary.

But even Clojure is syntactically heavy compared to Racket or CL. But with good reason.

A powerful and expressive language takes effort, possibly even years, to become expert in. I'm not sure that making trivial things trivial is part of the plan. There are more appropriate languages for that.

Re:Effective Scala by narwally on Friday September 06, 2013 @02:32PM (#6341906)
I really appreciate Clojure's syntactic heaviness when compared to other LISPs. Just by using braces for associative data structures, and brackets for array's makes scanning through Clojure code much nicer because of the added visual cues.
Re:Effective Scala by yohanatan on Saturday September 07, 2013 @02:09PM (#6345893)
You don't need proliferation of features to achieve expressiveness though (see Scheme or lambda calculus).

Most of the cruft in Scala is due to its support of O-O and its attempt to modernize it. Similarly, C++ is a superset of C rather than a complete break from it (and often, in the field, you find people using it as if it were 'C with classes').

Also, the O-O side of Scheme is certainly more powerful than F#'s O-O side; however, overall F# is at least as powerful of a language (and yet it's also much cleaner/internally consistent).

[Also, it takes only one counter-example to disprove 'all those who say that Scala resembles C++ have never worked with either' (which was my original intent here)].

Re:Effective Scala by bad_user on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:47PM (#6337310)
English is not my native language. I actually appreciate corrections.
Re:Effective Scala by yohanatan on Thursday September 05, 2013 @06:08PM (#6337432)
I figured as much. I just threw them out there in case anyone could benefit (including you). :-)

Also, I completely agree with the rest of your original post (the parts RE: Scheme, Go, & simplicity).

Re:Effective Scala by ericssmith on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:42PM (#6337876)
"you need capable programmers in order to not fuck it up, because it contains every paradigm ever invented."

My team has just the opposite experience. Scala offers a lot of structure and discipline that you can take advantage of without being an expert, and it is a short time to ramp up to idiomatic usage relative to other languages. In fact, this is one of its benefits. By following some fairly simple guidelines, you can avoid making a mess. This has not been my observation with imperative programmers picking up a new imperative language.

Because of the easy-to-achieve discipline, Scala is ideal for teams in my opinion.

Re:Effective Scala by auggierose on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:04AM (#6333858)
If you would consider writing your program in C, then you should probably also consider Go. Otherwise, go with Scala ;-)

I think Scala.js is going to be huge. Just alone for that I would choose Scala over Go.

Re:Effective Scala by fnl on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:33AM (#6334030)
Like the C vs. C++/Java bridge - certainly more succinct answer than my reasoning... :)

But I certainly do not believe that Scala.js has a reasonable chance of having an impact alike GWT or such; maybe it can get close to (ruby) Opal or consorts, though. The main selling point of Scala still is Akka, and, at least in the web-dev world, the Play framework, I guess.

Re:Effective Scala by auggierose on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:50AM (#6334137)
I like your explanation, actually, although you seem to contradict it with this comment here.

I am not using Akka, I am not using Play, I only use Scala because it is currently the language I can express my thoughts in the most elegant way, together with its industrial strength ecco system AND BECAUSE IT COMPILES TO JAVASCRIPT, TOO!!!

GWT never convinced me, Java is less productive than Javascript, so what is the point (except for legacy Java programmers ...).

Re:Effective Scala by SkyMarshal on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:40PM (#6335591)
Fwiw, Scala has several good web frameworks besides Play -

Scalatra - Scala's Sinatra

Blue Eyes - appears defunct but good example of pure asynchronous framework

Lift - strong built-in security, Netty integration wip.

Probably a couple more I'm forgetting.

Re:Effective Scala by zackangelo on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:03PM (#6337965)
Spray
Re:Effective Scala by candybar on Thursday September 05, 2013 @12:17PM (#6335033)
For people with zero knowledge of either, I think the following analogy is somewhat (but obviously not completely) apt:

Scala is to Ruby what Go is to Python.

Re:Effective Scala by SkyMarshal on Thursday September 05, 2013 @01:32PM (#6335547)
Interesting, but might want to elaborate a bit more. It's not completely clear what you mean. For example, another that comes to mind regarding prototyping vs production:

Python:C++::Go:Scala

Re:Effective Scala by candybar on Thursday September 05, 2013 @02:26PM (#6335905)
Ruby and Scala are both feature-rich languages that give programmers every chance to abstract away any common logic that they can find anywhere, while remaining elegant at core. Python and Go are both minimalistic languages that provide basic abstraction facilities, but are designed to keep the programming language and source code simple and readable, even it comes at the expense of expressive power. Scala differentiates from Ruby with static typing, faster performance and better support for concurrency. Go differentiates from Python with static typing, faster performance and better support for concurrency.