The feeling of whether or not this is "fair" depends upon whether you're a new user or an existing user. With the upgrade-pricing model, new users are confronted with a much lower price point, which is unavailable to them. This can be a significant psychological barrier to purchase execution. However, existing users are more likely to feel appreciated and stick with the product because they receive favorable pricing.
With the flat-cost model, you have the inverse. New users no longer feel marginalized, but existing users may consider alternatives at each time-of-purchase for upgrades.
Apple's vision of flat-cost pricing dictates that the price point should be held as low as possible, increasing accessibility from a broader market. With software, there are no incremental costs, so your price point is a matter of supply/demand tuning. There are countless blog articles on this subject.
While there isn't consensus on which model (flat-cost vs upgrade-pricing) is the most successful, each has its pros and cons for consumers. I don't think either could be characterized as fair or unfair.
That said, developing for Apple limits the scope of your freedom as a developer, just as leasing an apartment limits the scope of what you can do in your home.
In other words, your becoming more like a tenant in the Apple ecosystem vs. owning some piece of it. The problem with being a tenant is that you can only trust your landlord to the extent that your contact allows. No less, no more.
Omni makes good products that are (IMHO) worth $80, and paying full price for an upgrade is unfair whether that's an $80 app or a $3.99 app.
The problem isn't that software costs $80, it's that giving up freedom to use AppStore ends up hurting users and developers.