News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by derefr on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:13AM (#6332817)
What do they think doing this serves, in their opinion? In the US, there's at least the excuse that there's this big block of neoconservative religious-fundamentalists to win the votes of. Does Australia have those too?
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by westicle on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:42AM (#6332898)
I don't think this is a vote-winner; this policy has been as well-hidden as it possibly could be. 99% of voters will not even know about it.

More likely some back-room deal has been done with vested interests and the implementation of this policy somehow benefits them (financially or politically).

It is likely a combination of: rightsholder companies who will eventually twist the filters to block internet-based competition, large IT contracting companies who will get lucrative contracts for implementing it, and (tin-foil hat time) the Catholic church.

There are some VERY skeezy links between the federal opposition and the Australian Catholic church which see the church hold significant lobbying power over LNP policies. See: marriage equality, abortion rights, royal commission into child sexual abuse etc.

As a small, uncontroversial example, the current government handed over regulation of charities (including churches) to an independent regulator last year. The Catholic Church in particular hates being under the thumb of a regulator it doesn't have in its own back pocket. Conveniently the LNP plans to scrap the regulator if they win the election. Even mainstream newspapers are reporting that this is at the behest of Cardinal George Pell:

http://www.smh.com.au/business/bad-liberal-policy-will-damag...

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by westicle on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:47AM (#6332914)
Sorry, this link probably outlines the relationship much better than the above:

http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/federal-election-2013...

"The answer, in part at least, may be the lobbying power of church conservatives, the Catholic Church in particular, and the office of Sydney Cardinal George Pell, more particularly still."

"And the Victorian and Tasmanian-based Churches of Christ Community Care has begun an online petition to save the commission, warning that the Coalition alternative would be ''an advisory body with no teeth''. That, say critics, appears to be the point."

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by TheZenPsycho on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:38AM (#6333057)
It's worth noting that when the Labour party attempted an internet filter, they insisted INSISTED that the only sites on the black list would be pedophilia sites. Wikileaks ended up on the black list.
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by nl on Thursday September 05, 2013 @06:54AM (#6333330)
Reference requested. I don't believe that is true.
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by jacques_chester on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:04AM (#6333568)
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by nl on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:10AM (#6333594)
The blacklist contains one url from Wikileaks, which (judging form the URL) is yet another (non-Australian) leaked blacklist of banned sites.

I'm not defending censorship (one look at the list shows what a STUPID idea it is) but I think implying that it was used to "block Wikileaks" overstates what happened.

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by jacques_chester on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:15AM (#6333614)
It overstates the case for that point in time. But it doesn't overstate that they were prepared to do it.

Remember: this is a secret list that Australians cannot legally see.

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by derefr on Thursday September 05, 2013 @11:14AM (#6334658)
That does sort of make sense, though. Publishing the list of blocked URLs would be like publishing a list of the addresses of people under Witness Protection: useless to anyone except those who want to go to them. And not just those who want to look at one site in particular--you can know whether a particular site is on the list by just testing it, after all. Instead, the only use of having the entire list would be to look at sites just because they're on the list; in est, to get suggestions for new sites related to your interests.
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by TheZenPsycho on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:35PM (#6338074)
How do you know the difference between a blocked site and a site with a networking issue without uh... subverting the block and using a proxy or a vpn?
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by cabalamat on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:14AM (#6333400)
I don't know whether it is true, but similar things have happened in the UK, Germany and Finland, so it could well be.
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by Wingman4l7 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:06AM (#6332971)
> the current government handed over regulation of charities (including churches) to an independent regulator last year

That's pretty awesome that that was even done, though. I cannot imagine something like that happening in the US. I am so sick of seeing religious institutions abuse their tax-free status to play Real Estate Tycoon.

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by westicle on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:20AM (#6333017)
For what it's worth most of the sector (including religious charities) strongly support the regulator.

We had some issues in the past with some very high-profile sports people setting up "charitable funds" which undertook a lot of fundraising and tax deductible activities without actually doing any philanthropy. That undermines trust in organisations who actually help people (Salvation Army, World Vision etc).

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by jacques_chester on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:05AM (#6333572)
Labor's NSW Right faction is a bit of a Sunday mass too. And they're the most powerful single bloc in the ALP.
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by RWeaver on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:59AM (#6332945)
The leader of the opposition is a devout Catholic. As the minister for health he tried to block abortion treatments until overruled by his party, and nearly became a priest before settling for lifetime politician.

He became the leader of the opposition by one vote (internal votes) after a debate between him and the previous leader over climate change (which he successfully argued to his party wasn't occurring, later changing his mind to satisfy the polls)

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by shirro on Thursday September 05, 2013 @06:27AM (#6333235)
The leaders of the three biggest parties, ALP, Liberal and Greens are all Catholic or in the case of Rudd a Catholic turned Anglican. Catholics are the second biggest cult after the Protestants in Australia and just ahead of the non-believers by a whisker. Catholics are possibly over-represented due to private school networking in the case of the Abbott and Pyne types and a concern with social justice issues in the case of a Rudd or Milne type. It really isn't about the religion though.

It is all about power, money and special interests corrupting democracy. Abbott for all his Catholicism will have signed his soul over to big carbon polluters, the tobacco lobby, Rupert Murdoch and lots more to take the election.

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by jacques_chester on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:07AM (#6333579)
Abbott has demonstrated that he is prepared to distinguish between his private beliefs and his public policy. He has no choice: trying to introduce the Catholic wishlist would see him voted down like an obese person on reality TV.
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by elnate on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:18AM (#6332833)
Different, but effectively yes.
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by pavs on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:36AM (#6332879)
I was under the impression that Australia is much much more conservative in general compare to USA.
Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by vacri on Thursday September 05, 2013 @05:06AM (#6332970)
Both of of the US's major political parties are more conservative than the Australian major conservative party. Particularly when it comes to fighting crime (when our police started fucking up with SWAT tactics, they were stopped in short order) and waging war.

Outside of politics, it really depends on what you look at. There's certainly a strong urge to conform in mainstream anglo America (clipped lawns, identical houses, visible laundry is unsightly, etc) that doesn't really have a parallel here, but on the other hand, Americans are a bit more socially outgoing than Australians.

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by Wingman4l7 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @11:30PM (#6338529)
AU political party names were very confusing for me; the Liberal party is politically conservative, and both parties are more liberal than the US. =P

AU successfully managed to de-militarize its police force? The US needs to use you guys as a case study! However, I suspect that you were only able to do that because of your very low tolerance for firearms violence, as evidenced by the near-complete disarmament of your civilian population via that massive buyback program & subsequent legislation after the Port Arthur massacre. I wouldn't be surprised if US citizens like the idea of a militarized police, ready to respond with overwhelming force to whatever movie-plot terrorists happen to pop up.

Re:Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter b... by derefr on Thursday September 05, 2013 @04:42AM (#6332901)
("Conservative" doesn't necessarily mean "socially paternalistic along Old-Testament Christian lines" in most countries, though; thus the question.)