News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by citricsquid on Monday September 02, 2013 @04:29AM (#6314076)
The biggest problem with Hacker News comments -- actually, make that all comments -- is fundamental: the sort of people that leave comments are (more often than not) people that want something, ANYTHING, to say, not people that have something to say.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by Too on Monday September 02, 2013 @05:31AM (#6314290)
I think the karma system can also be a contributor to this. Any comment you make has the chance to get a few upvotes, regardless of how little it contributes to the conversation. So people just spam comments to get a few points here and there.

This phenomena can be seen in forums without karma also but i think in places with karma it is usually worse, worst offenders being digg and reddit where everybody tries to make a silly joke as those are easy points.

A better algotithm calculating the karma as an average over all your comments maybe could help..

Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by bcj on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:02AM (#6315180)
I have mixed feelings about karma. It's nice to have filters that bring (mostly) better comments to the top, but I think it results in more silenced voices than it does posts-for-karma's-sake.

It's validating to get a few upvotes, but more than that it's disheartening to spend time on a comment and recieve no feedback whatsoever.

I'm an outgoing person, but I find myself shying away from commenting on HN for that reason. Admittedly, I don't usually have some brilliant insight, but it does make it harder to feel like part of the community.

Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by raphman on Monday September 02, 2013 @08:59AM (#6314927)
It might also be interesting to rate-limit commenters (perhaps based on their previous upvotes per comment). If you are new to HN, you may only post one comment per week. The "better" (as measured by karma) your comments are, the more comments per week you may post. This might make commenters consider whether their comment is really so important that they sacrifice another opportunity to comment in the future.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by lmm on Monday September 02, 2013 @12:58PM (#6315970)
The "average" (on your user page, seemingly over your last few comments) seems to matter more for how high your posts appear. I've found myself deliberately not replying when someone makes an interesting reply to a comment of mine a few days afterwards, because posting that reply brings my average down. Which is definitely a bug.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by hollerith on Monday September 02, 2013 @08:14AM (#6314776)
>A better algotithm calculating the karma as an average over all your comments maybe could help

The metric I would most like to know is how many votes my comments got divided by the total number of words in my comments.

Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by jacques_chester on Monday September 02, 2013 @08:56AM (#6314914)
Wouldn't this favour the short smartarsery that's one of the not-done things hereabouts?
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by polymatter on Monday September 02, 2013 @09:17AM (#6314988)
It would also favour the short and succinct over the long and rambling. Which sounds like a good thing, if you believe that useful information can be distilled losslessly.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by jacques_chester on Monday September 02, 2013 @09:46AM (#6315099)
Pithy wisdom only really works when it lands in a mind on the edge of understanding it.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by crevadi on Monday September 02, 2013 @05:35AM (#6314297)
Yes you are correct. Most people just add comments to get points and karma. Especially when they are new to HN like me.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by coherentpony on Monday September 02, 2013 @10:54AM (#6315412)
Don't know why you're getting down-voted, you're absolutely right.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by Tichy on Monday September 02, 2013 @05:02AM (#6314191)
If that were the case, the solution would be simple: just skip reading comments.

On the contrary I often learn useful things from HN comments. Sometimes I even submit stuff to HN because I am curious about the opinion of HN commentators.

Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by kybernetyk on Monday September 02, 2013 @04:55AM (#6314165)
a) the internet (and HN) can't get full

b) there are downvote arrows

To me it's OK if people just leave anything as a comment here because it will be modded down if it's irrelevant to the discussion.

Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by dredmorbius on Monday September 02, 2013 @07:02AM (#6314543)
the internet (and HN) can't get full

My reading buffer most certainly can.

If the s/n dips sufficiently, I'm out.

It's the Yogi Berra Restaurant Syndrome, or the Evaporative Cooling Effect:

http://blog.bumblebeelabs.com/social-software-sundays-2-the-...

Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by DanBC on Monday September 02, 2013 @05:49AM (#6314341)
> it's OK if people just leave anything as a comment here because it will be modded down if it's irrelevant to the discussion.

It would be great if down voting was more prevalent. Many people don't down vote for anything but the absolute worst comment. Some people downvote for disagreement and not poor comment.

Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by namenotrequired on Monday September 02, 2013 @07:26AM (#6314611)
Most people can't downvote.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by mikeash on Monday September 02, 2013 @11:46AM (#6315653)
The problem comes when there's enough people leaving dumb comments who start upvoting each other and overcome the people saying interesting stuff.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by sker on Monday September 02, 2013 @04:47AM (#6314136)
I don't think that's a problem. I think that's by design. Internet forums are similar to bars where people gather to hang out and talk about common interests. There are other outlets where the people that have something to say can say it.
Re:Hacker News comments I'm tired of seeing by RBerenguel on Monday September 02, 2013 @04:39AM (#6314107)
Somehow I think your comment applies to TV, radio and writers. The signal-to-noise ratio is getting worse and worse I think (as a side note, I thing signal-to-noise is also one of the frequent HN comments :D)