News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Need a Basic Income Guarantee by yummyfajitas on Sunday September 01, 2013 @04:50PM (#6312099)
Your arguments for a BIG apply equally well to a BJG, if not more so.

If the basic jobs include socially beneficial activities, BJG provides an even greater incentive for those activities than a BIG.

A BJG is also a cash transfer, but with a single qualification process. Show up, do work, get paid. This reduces waste because you gain the product of people's work. With a BIG, Waste = transfers + admin overhead + disincentivized work. With BJG, Waste = transfers + admin overhead + disincentivized work - product of basic jobs.

Similarly, the BJG would eliminate poverty and ensure a life-long minimum earning level.

As for your hypothetical future where human labor is unnecessary, we'll switch to a BIG when we get there.

The preference for a Basic Income over a Basic Job is a moral one - most of the proponents of Basic Income believe people should be able to subsist on the fruits of other's labor if they choose not to work.

Re:We Need a Basic Income Guarantee by ihateloggingin on Monday September 02, 2013 @05:01AM (#6314184)
They don't, actually.

"socially beneficial activities that are not compensated" -- doesn't apply equally well.

"most efficiently delivered through a direct cash transfer, rather than through a means-tested or other qualification-based process" -- doesn't apply equally well.

"no minimum wage would be necessary to reduce poverty" -- doesn't apply equally well.

"ensuring a life-long minimum earnings level for individuals" -- doesn't apply equally well.

"the economy itself will not be able to adapt in creating new labor opportunities" -- doesn't apply equally well.

Amazingly, that's each and every point. Not a single one applies equally well.

Re:We Need a Basic Income Guarantee by olalonde on Monday September 02, 2013 @05:38AM (#6314309)
I think your assumption that government can provide guaranteed (productive) jobs to everyone at any time is dead wrong. This sounds much more like a communist nightmare then BIG does as it would almost certainly introduce a massive dysfunctional bureaucracy to manage all those jobs.
Re:We Need a Basic Income Guarantee by yummyfajitas on Monday September 02, 2013 @07:38AM (#6314643)
I don't expect all the jobs to be productive. Some will, some won't. The productive jobs will generate returns, while the unproductive ones (e.g., digging and refilling holes) will merely serve as a disincentive for people to use the BJG.

The disincentive is important - the goal of the BJG is that ideally, no one will use it. Unlike a BIG, laziness is no longer an option.

Re:We Need a Basic Income Guarantee by vasilipupkin on Sunday September 01, 2013 @07:07PM (#6312578)
Basic Job is worse because some individuals cannot get jobs simply because they are not productive enough - forcing them upon employees would be worse for the economy than giving them an income to live on