You say "I don't want to downplay this" but then follow with: "we have bigger problems." How much more could you downplay it?
I hypothesize that folks (not necessarily OP) do this, consciously or unconsiously, so they can more easily justify inaction for themselves. "Well I could volunteer on Sunday at the Soup Kitchen but India has it so much worse. How could I/we be so selfish?"
It's really difficult to comprehend how much worse off people have it in the developing world unless you see it firsthand. But it's still a false dichotomy to compare one population against the other as a form of argument. It's not as if we can turn our backs on the homelessness problem in this country because things are worse in the third world.
In many places, these resources don't account for all of the demand and have absolutely no chance of matching it.
1) This kind of article is pure propaganda, intended to make money for Business Insider by "raising questions" and selling ad revenue against the pageviews.
2) "We" aren't responsible for the decisions of people who live within a 100 mile radius. If "we" are held responsible for their outcomes, financially and morally responsible, then "we" will also demand control over their lives to a degree you'd find unpalatable. This can be trivially solved by re-institutionalization and a Boston-Bombings-style sweep and cleanup of the camp. It won't be because the idea is to give them (and Business Insider) our money without giving us any control over their behavior or the use of funds.
3) The questions raised by BI are highly selective. For example, they put expensive homes on this map: http://www.businessinsider.com/homeless-in-silicon-valley-in...
But they don't talk about quantitative easing or Bernanke's 85B/month in mortgage purchases, which have the express intent of driving up home prices.
One could go on. But the right answer is that we didn't cause this, we're only paying attention to it because of BI's SEO, BI itself isn't going to dedicate its operation to donating money, you aren't going to dedicate your life to helping them, and so on. The right answer is no action on this issue that you heard about today, will forget about tomorrow, and is insoluble anyway.
Refuse to be guilt-tripped by cynical manipulators relying on maudlin sympathy, people who want to draw your attention to an issue, blame it on you, and then charge you (involuntarily via tax) a pretty penny for not solving it. For how many billions have been spent on "the homeless" to date? The result is only to subsidize them and build a permanent caste of homeless caretakers.
The real solution is to reverse de-institutionalization (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deinstitutionalisation), but that would be fought tooth and nail by "homeless advocates" who'd see their budgets vanish in a trice. Public homelessness as we know it is subsidized, it is a government-and-NGO-caused phenomenon.
Waiting until everything is "easier to solve" sounds more like an excuse than anything else. Besides, every little bit helps the grander problem that you allude to so how could it not be helpful on every level? We can make excuses all day about why the problem exists: "Oh man, wait until I can vote again, then the gov't will be fixed and the big problems can be solved." "Once big banks and corruption are under control, then we can start feeding people and offering more services."
These kinds of attitudes that allow our complacency as Americans (or elsewhere for that matter) aren't intelligent as being part of solving some greater problem at the expense of others. These attitudes are part of the problem.
We owe it to ourselves and humanity to get past our own brains, see a problem in front of us, and do something about it.
I never said we should wait until everything is "easier to solve", only that solving big problems make easier problems easier to deal with. This mean we should prioritize the hungriest of individuals in this world, rather than just feeding the local homeless.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_eq...
There is a greater relative disparity in wealth between the rich and poor in the US of A than India. (relative poverty) Out of the developed countries the US is easily one of the least unequal (if not the most unequal -- I haven't checked) places. This is, of course, because universal health care is communism and social security is for spongers and the lazy.
In absolute terms there is undoubtedly more extreme poverty in India than the US. Why that is so is not as simple as the country's broken social institutions, we're still talking about the world's largest democracy here. I would imagine the caste system plays a part. Colonialism too.
Wealth disparity is not what Rayiner was talking about. He was talking about social infrastructure. You're actually adding to his point here.
What he meant was that the wealthy class in India have about the same spending power as the middle class in the United States. They are sheltered away from the extreme destitution that is on display everywhere in their country and don't interact with the poor at all. It's perhaps 10x what you'd see from a rich person walking in NYC avoiding a beggar asking for change on the street.
Rapid urbanization and the slow collapse of the caste system has left a vacuum in India's culture that leads to stories like that of the poor woman we saw on Hacker News just last week or so. That is the lack of social infrastructure. Not enough is being done, and not quickly enough, to positively impact the society in a meaningful way. As it is now, India is in a state of culture shock that does nothing to help its economic system.
We cannot solve the problems of the people by not knowing them in depth and that is major investment. We cannot offer one size fits all "learn to code" solution that earned the tech industry the recent mocking.
You can slice the world to arbitrarily small groups of people, making any problem someone else's. I don't feel the national borders are particularly meaningful in this context, especially considering the amount of Indians living in Silicon Valley.
I'm sure Rayiner feels deep sympathy for places that are not presently near to him (such as India, in this thread).
If every major problem in the United States were already solved, it would be more reasonable to then try to help others solve their problems. But that's not the case.
If you have people suffering right in front of you, it just makes sense logistically to help them first. Helping our own homeless and unemployed would aid in stimulating the American economy.
The bottom line is that there isn't any sane reason why an American would prioritize the needs of another country before his own. Nor would it be sane for an Indian to prioritize America's while she lives in India. It just doesn't make sense. You tend to your side of the street first.
> If you have people suffering right in front of you, it just makes sense logistically to help them first.
> there isn't any sane reason why an American would prioritize the needs of another country before his own
You're making several statements basically asserting that proximity is the only relevant factor when determining how easy it is to help one person or grow an economy. But we're not all paramedics. I'd argue that the American economy has already grown so much, and people are already given so many opportunities here, that making improvements here is going to be way more expensive in terms of natural resources and manpower, than improving an area where much simpler problems are still unsolved.
For example, spending $1M fighting malaria in Africa improves the GDP of Africa by $12M.[1]
> Helping our own homeless and unemployed would aid in stimulating the American economy.
This seems to be evidence of national bias. Why should I care about the American economy in particular?
1. http://www.rbm.who.int/cmc_upload/0/000/015/330/415680a_r.pd...
(Personally, I'd answer 'yes' and 'probably not', respectively. If you want to help people in bulk, you can probably get easier targets if you're willing to look in some of the poorer countries in the world. GiveWell's charity evaluations seem to confirm this: http://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities)
"Dunbar's number is a suggested cognitive limit to the number of people with whom one can maintain stable social relationships. These are relationships in which an individual knows who each person is and how each person relates to every other person."
There is no 'fixing homelessness.' You 'fix' it in India, or in the US or in Canada or in where ever. Sending money to 'fix' India or Africa is a decision to not spend it 'fixing' issues at home.
If you elevate 1000000 Indian people to the working class they will begin consuming a lot of stuff, some of which will be made in the US or having major part of its IP from US. Some of these dollars will come back home. After all what one person spends is another ones income.
There is nothing wrong of course with trying to help closer to home first.
America's situation is different; they have an idealogical opposition to social welfare and there is no system to opt out of. The homeless situation in SF is far worse than in any EU city I know of.
I don't know if I'd really call it a situation. Homeless people choose to go to SF because it's one of the best places for them. You won't freeze sleeping on the street, plenty of handouts...
Anyway, whatever the reason, I think it is actually a "situation". Many cities have homeless problems, but SF's is amazingly in your face. Most SF people I know would simply not walk through Tenderloin at any time, even in broad daylight. It's in the middle of the freaking city! That is not normal.
I've only been in the TL for three years or so, but I've spent the majority of that time wondering how regular working-class families with kids can afford to live in the area. I can't imagine how street-level pushers or prostitutes make rent. Maybe they rent places out in Hunters Point or Outer Sunset?
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-everyman-psychiatris...
I recently lived in the Tenderloin for six months, and my impression was the the majority of the chronically homeless there are crazy.
Union square has a lot more alcoholics and drug users, and 'talented' homeless people like street performers and pick-pockets. They may have some minor issues but they're clearly there by choice.
Like Copenhagen I believe it is extremely intermingled with substance addiction problems, especially alcohol. It's a hard nut to crack, that's for sure.
If you are a legal resident you will be offered a place to live, as well as money to survive, if you have the wherewithal to go to the social services. The ones who don't use this are usually mentally ill or too deep into substance abuse of one sort or another.
The thousands you are talking about are probably illegal aliens, who are obviously not offered the same services that residents enjoy. Can't really blame Copenhagen that thousands of people without resources or prospects stream into the city from other countries. In either case, they all reside in government or privately run shelters with beds and meals available, which is I guess is why we don't see them in the street the way you do in New York and San Francisco.
But I once worked in India for 3 months, in Mumbai, and I can tell you that on a global scale, this is nothing.
My commute in the morning consisted of driving, for 1 HOUR, through the largest slum in the world. 20 kilometers on a side big.
So while its terrible that this exists in Silicon Valley, on a global scale we have much bigger problems.
For me, that's the biggest reason I hope Bill Gates keeps on doing what he's doing.