News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Non-Indians have benefited most from patent regime in India by icebraining on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @02:18PM (#6291694)
It is a strange fact that government grants and enforces monopolies on molecules that are designed to save lives, monopolies which then lowers the supply.

This is a simplistic view. After the molecule was discovered, the patent certainly lowers the supply, but if the patent is what enables the molecule to be discovered in the first place, then it actually increases the supply.

Of course, whether the claim holds is questionable, but it's not like these drugs where flowing from the trees until the bad government came and limited it.

As for the taxes, I don't know the Indian patent office, but the US counterpart makes money.

Re:Non-Indians have benefited most from patent regime in India by belorn on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @04:32PM (#6292442)
By the time the patent application is being sought, the invention is already made. As such, the patent is only there to encourage more inventions. The question is then, should a democratic countrey give out such monopolies, while knowing the harm it will do to a majority population that won't gain any benefit for 20 years, for a maybe increase in new inventions?

Or to put it in concert fashion, should a farmer sacrifice a family member to a sickness today, just so he might be able in 20+ years buy a generic version when the price has gone down? If put to a vote, would the majorly of the citizen inside a country vote to vow never allow anyone die just because they are too poor to pay the medicine, or do they rather want the chance of increased new medicines which only a small minority can afford in the next 20+ years?

What would the democratic vote say? My bet would be on the living and not on the patents.