News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Non-Indians have benefited most from patent regime in India by belorn on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @12:23PM (#6290994)
It is a strange fact that government grants and enforces monopolies on molecules that are designed to save lives, monopolies which then lowers the supply. One would naively think that society enforcement arms would prefer that sick people had access to medicine, rather than erect pay wall barriers that dooms some poor people to a slow and painful death.

I wonder what the majority of the Indian people would prefer. What percentage of citizens of the Republic of India can actually afford the products of companies like Novartis AG when they demand patent licenses, and how much taxes would be free up by abolishing the patent office and patent enforcement?

Re:Non-Indians have benefited most from patent regime in India by icebraining on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @02:18PM (#6291694)
It is a strange fact that government grants and enforces monopolies on molecules that are designed to save lives, monopolies which then lowers the supply.

This is a simplistic view. After the molecule was discovered, the patent certainly lowers the supply, but if the patent is what enables the molecule to be discovered in the first place, then it actually increases the supply.

Of course, whether the claim holds is questionable, but it's not like these drugs where flowing from the trees until the bad government came and limited it.

As for the taxes, I don't know the Indian patent office, but the US counterpart makes money.

Re:Non-Indians have benefited most from patent regime in India by belorn on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @04:32PM (#6292442)
By the time the patent application is being sought, the invention is already made. As such, the patent is only there to encourage more inventions. The question is then, should a democratic countrey give out such monopolies, while knowing the harm it will do to a majority population that won't gain any benefit for 20 years, for a maybe increase in new inventions?

Or to put it in concert fashion, should a farmer sacrifice a family member to a sickness today, just so he might be able in 20+ years buy a generic version when the price has gone down? If put to a vote, would the majorly of the citizen inside a country vote to vow never allow anyone die just because they are too poor to pay the medicine, or do they rather want the chance of increased new medicines which only a small minority can afford in the next 20+ years?

What would the democratic vote say? My bet would be on the living and not on the patents.

Re:Non-Indians have benefited most from patent regime in India by naterator on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @02:32PM (#6291785)
I'm not a huge fan of patents for many cases, but drug patents are something I support. Don't forget that while someone might die today from not having the drug, more people may die in the future because it's not worthwhile for a company to invent new drugs without patent protection. We can debate what is fair patent protection for drugs, but protection is essential. It's easy to see a drug that exists and ignore all that went into making it, and also easy to ignore the drugs that will never be invented because they're not worthwhile to make. It's also deadly.

http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2005/10/if_france_gets_its_wa...

And getting mad at Novartis in this case for "evergreening" also isn't entirely fair, because up until 2003/5 India was the wild west when it came to drugs, and thus Novartis couldn't really sell it there anyway. If India had product patents when Gleevec was invented in 1995, maybe they would be on course to have the generic soon. Instead, the rest of the world is subsidizing cheap drugs for India. We invent, we pay, they benefit.

Re:Non-Indians have benefited most from patent regime in India by belorn on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @04:37PM (#6292473)
While someone might die tomorrow for lack of medicine not invented yet, someone will die today for not being able to buy the patent licensed medicine. While it might be deadly not to provide that incentive for invention, question does lay if its moral to let people die today, just so some other people might not die tomorrow.

Of course, evergreening is an extra evil in itself, and lets not forget that pharma also get a extra special monopoly after the patent has expired just for doing drug trials.