News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla outsells Porsche, Jaguar, others in California by freehunter on Monday August 26, 2013 @04:30PM (#6279704)
Originally I had a sentence at the beginning of my comment that said "as someone who grew up in the rural Midwest...", but I took it out. Perhaps I should have left it in, judging by some of the comments I've gotten.

Yes, trucks have an important role. I own a truck (paid it off and bought a car for commuting as well). My grandpa (a farmer) owns a truck. Many of my friends own trucks. But that excess capability that you speak of is the entire reason for owning a truck. Big engines, big transmission, big differentials, a big bed, and a strong frame is what a truck should have. If I can't tow a horse trailer let alone a load of steel, what good is a pickup? Pickup trucks have significant drawbacks (dangerous in the winter, deadly in accidents, hard to park), but none of that matters if you need a pickup.

You talk about contractors and fleet vehicles as if they're reason for mass-market full-size pickup trucks, but those are not mass-market use cases. Those are business uses. And let me make a big correction here, but most of the US is not rural. Not even close [1]. As of the 2000 census, almost 80% of the US was urban/suburban, and more than half of that was people living in cities over 200,000 people.

Pickup trucks are a status symbol, and while I don't have numbers to back it up, I would guess it would be more economical for people who need a pickup only occasionally to drive a car and rent a pickup. For the rest of us who actually use pickup trucks, the mass-market is turning them into minivan-substitutes the same way SUVs got turned from 7-seater trucks to soccer mom commuter cars. Compare the Tahoe today to the Blazer of 1985 for evidence.

[1] http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/planning/census_issues/archives/metr...

Re:Tesla outsells Porsche, Jaguar, others in California by sliverstorm on Monday August 26, 2013 @06:07PM (#6280217)
The excess capability is the reason for owning a full-size. I don't follow the full-sizes. Lighter duty trucks are being carefully pared down in some aspects, but they are hardly being made into sissy-wagons- today's quarter-ton trucks, for example, are commonly rated for 3/4 ton load capacity and 3 tons of towing.

I didn't mean most of the US population was rural, just that the majority of the US by area is rural.

Anyway, I'm getting a bit bogged down in the details. I just object to your characterization of trucks as a niche vehicle. While it may be technically accurate- as everything can be described as addressing a niche in the market- it implies the subset of the market is very small, and I don't think that's accurate, particularly not in relation to many other categories of vehicle.

I do share your fears of trucks becoming too "soft" though. I already had to flee the SUV market and put a camper on a light truck instead, because of how SUVs have been changed. My hope is that the market demand for actual trucks is large enough to resist the trend.

Re:Tesla outsells Porsche, Jaguar, others in California by freehunter on Monday August 26, 2013 @06:26PM (#6280299)
A Chevy/Ram 1500 or a F150 is a full-size. A Tacoma, Dakota, S10/Colorado, etc is a small pickup. I'm talking about the F150 mentioned, which is a full size pickup, which you're referring to as a lighter duty truck. Just want to make sure we're on the same page.

I did use hyperbole in saying that trucks are the most niche vehicle, but I'm using hyperbole to prove my point. Contractors, farmers, work men, yes they need pickups. A mom driving her kids to school does not. A person working in an office and living in the city does not. A person who occasionally pulls a camper does not (many SUVs and crossovers are rated for pulling the weight of an average travel trailer).

When snow hits the road, the first two cars to go into the ditch are old compacts (inexperienced drivers) and pickup trucks. Pickup trucks are inherently dangerous to drive, and the people you speak of (work men/women) tend to know how to operate (not just drive) a pickup.

I can agree to disagree, I'm just voicing my frustration at the number of $50k luxury pickup trucks I see driven by people who live and work in the city.

Re:Tesla outsells Porsche, Jaguar, others in California by sliverstorm on Monday August 26, 2013 @06:43PM (#6280397)
Good call, I wasn't thinking of the F150 as full-size. Of course it is not the same class as the Tacoma etc, but my uneducated mind thought of the F250 as full-size and the F150 as "something in between".

You're right on needs vs. does not need. Just the other day saw a Volvo wagon pulling a little camper, seemed to handle it quiet well.

As for snow on the road, I'd throw in that SUVs are disproportionately found in ditches where I live (my coworkers and I suspect because they breed false confidence) but yes, pickup trucks are also notorious for throwing people in ditches. Many ordinary drivers are not very good with RWD vehicles in slippery conditions.

I hear you on the last part. It does grind my gears a little bit to see the shiny, never-dirty top-spec F150's driving around town. Not to mention the pristine super-duty trucks, although most of the super-duties I see around where I live are either beat to shit and full of stuff or hauling- a service life well-lived.

Re:Tesla outsells Porsche, Jaguar, others in California by freehunter on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @07:53PM (#6287130)
For the definition of truck and commuter car I'm using, let me refer you to this imgur gallery of my truck (yeah, it's a 4Runner, not a pickup, I know) hopelessly stuck in a patch of clay, and the commuter car that I payed off my truck to afford, parked next to said truck.

It seems like we're on the same page, although my views might be a bit stronger than yours.

http://imgur.com/a/wQRHe#0