News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by user9756 on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:40PM (#6278550)
Actually I remember a documentary were it stated that the Persians paid men and women for their skills working on projects. I can't remember the name of the documentary (probably from the discovery channel).

A quick google search - http://hsc.csu.edu.au/ancient_history/societies/near_east/pe...

And - "Men, women and children worked in ancient Persia to support a diverse economy. Workers were paid in wine and grain, with skilled laborers paid more than unskilled, and supervisors paid more than workers. Men were paid slightly more than women, but female supervisors were paid more than the men working under them. Young women received maternity leave and were paid money for each child they had."

http://www.ehow.com/about_5414474_jobs-did-ancient-persians-...

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by zeteo on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:03PM (#6278714)
>Workers were paid in wine and grain

That's not pay, it's logistics. Even on the worst forced labor projects they're still usually feeding the prisoners.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by paganel on Monday August 26, 2013 @03:01PM (#6279151)
Maybe just a little OT, but my grand-parens lived in an mountain valley somewhere in Eastern Europe and even though I was still a kid I remember that when they were bringing people in to help them with agricultural work (collecting hay etc) often times said people were not paid with money but instead with "days-worked".

More exactly, once person A had worked for you for two days you had to pay back by working two days at her place, let's say helping her collecting potatoes or whatever, "number of days worked" was a sort of currency. And providing food to the hired workers was also part of the deal.

Obviously things have changed now, as even then (25 years ago) this practice was beginning to fade off.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by tanzam75 on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @02:02AM (#6281740)
What you describe sounds a lot like the labor-day (trudoden) accounting system for collective farms in the Soviet Union. They actually did pay wages to the workers according to the number of labor-days worked. (Note: It wasn't literally one day -- harder tasks could earn more than one labor-day per day.)

If one farm needed some temporary labor, it would've been easier to trade labor-days with another farm than to settle in cash.

I don't know about other Soviet bloc countries, but I would not be surprised if they used a similar system. 25 years ago would've been towards the end of the Communist era, which would also explain why it was fading.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by user9756 on Monday August 26, 2013 @03:06PM (#6279181)
Eh, you simply changed the meaning of the word; it clearly states "paid" and not "feed".

You are fully aware that you can offer work in exchange for things rather than gold or fiat money?

From the other link we'll find

>Free workers were even recruited from neighbouring satrapies at harvest time (Dandemaev and Lukonin, 1989: 157). Paid free-born labourers worked on the Babylonian canals, and free non-citizen farmers worked the land of the state, temples and the rich (Dandamaev and Lukonin, 1989: 152), and provided the corvee labour at such sites as Susa and Persepolis (Kent 1953DSf 22-58). They could not be sold, and so were not actually slaves, and could be considered non-citizen workers.

(my emphasis)

The discussion is more complicated than quoting a couple of random non-related articles on the Internet. But simply changing the meaning of a given statement and dismissing the entire counter argument is dishonest.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by zeteo on Monday August 26, 2013 @03:42PM (#6279399)
I apologize if my previous reply came across as too curt. But I think a sharp distinction needs to be drawn between two work systems that are quite different:

A. Market based, in which a certain reward is provided for performing a certain amount of work. Workers are generally free to come and leave, and respond accordingly to variations in wages.

B. Command based, into which workers are essentially corralled by threats of force (explicit or implicit), and often provided with nourishment so they can keep laboring until their obligation is fulfilled.

It's possible to talk of "payment" under scenario B [1], but it cheapens the term and it definitely doesn't indicate market-based relations. Transfers of food and drink (which make for poor currency, especially in places that are already minting coins [2]) are on the contrary a good indication of the corvée system at work.

[1] See e.g. this Wikipedia entry: "Corvée [...] was unpaid labour imposed [...] by the state [...] The corvée was the earliest and most widespread form of taxation [... The] Medieval agricultural corvée was not entirely unpaid: by custom the workers could expect small payments, often in the form of food and drink consumed on the spot." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corvee

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persian_daric

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by user9756 on Monday August 26, 2013 @04:49PM (#6279840)
That is a good distinction.

Although if I may digress and make a small comment. The market economy could be argued somewhat "command based" too. The difference being that you are given money to buy the food and shelter you need (rather than being given them directly). And then you have the entire "debt economy" when it comes to "laboring until their obligation is fulfilled".

While I now understand your argument, I saw the issue more as the state at least acknowledged an exchange, and a right for the worker to receive some compensation. Perhaps not the most valuable. But something, in a time were you could easily have slave labor; "payment" in its simplest form without any connotation to specific economic models.

Speaking of slave labor however. There was a part about slaves (in one of the articles I quoted). It stated that more skilled labor (doctors, nurses and teachers) were kept as slaves. Now, in a market economy those kinds of skills would (should) be especially rewarding in the model A you are talking about.

When I think about it, I can't say that lower skill work really would seem to differ in the two models you mentioned. In today’s world you could find lower skill work that pays more than simply keeping a person alive (e.g. in many European countries), but generally speaking this is not true in all (most?) places.

But I digress. Again.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by seanmcdirmid on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:14PM (#6278794)
Ya: free to go but free to starve isn't much of a choice. Outright slavery isn't necessary.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by IsThisObvious on Monday August 26, 2013 @05:16PM (#6279977)
How is paying me money any different if my only option if I quit was live on the streets and starve?
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by seanmcdirmid on Monday August 26, 2013 @09:24PM (#6280904)
Monopoly on means of survival is effective slavery. People in early agricultural societies didn't exactly have many choices.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by lostlogin on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @02:51AM (#6281886)
This is the argument behind the movements for a living wage. However this is now, no early agricultural society, just first world shining light capitalism. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Living_wage
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @05:12AM (#6282345)
There are huge limits to capitalism in terms of automation. We are going to hit those limits in our lifetime and society is going to need some drastic adaptations.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by dhughes on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:54PM (#6278654)
> skilled laborers paid more than unskilled, and supervisors paid more than workers. Men were paid slightly more than women, but female supervisors were paid more than the men working under them. Young women received maternity leave and were paid money for each child they had."

It makes sense, people were paid for their ability to add to society. Men paid more possibly due to their greater strength; carry more, build more faster and women for having children.