News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by angersock on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:05AM (#6271427)
This is why the most interesting OC on the 'net seems to come from the swamps of 4chan and reddit (and SA and YTMD and the like).

There is very little to gain (other than targeted advertising and srs bznz) from giving up anonymity online, and if you make friends somehow you can always coordinate out-of-band.

I'm really sad that so many places want me to integrate my gmail or my real name or my birthday or whatever other bit of personal info I claim into their registers.

We're still recoiling from the NSA stuff: why the fuck should we accept companies that want to do the same things to us?

EDIT:

I'll go one step further. An author I'd read in some scifi story or something similar had suggested that the mark of our era was the relentless pursuit and shaming of hypocrisy. The idea was that, having embraced moral relativism and given up any attempt at judging people on a cultural basis, nerds and soon the rest of people flocked to the last bastion of the judgemental: chiding others for doing something other than what they'd preached, or saying something different at different points in time.

Without anonymity, it can be very difficult to conduct useful intellectual discourse, especially if you aren't strong-willed enough to deal with trolls and jerks who say "But aha! Yesterday you claimed A, but today B; which is it?".

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by cstross on Sunday August 25, 2013 @07:07AM (#6271663)
Footnote: An author I'd read in some scifi story or something similar had suggested that the mark of our era was the relentless pursuit and shaming of hypocrisy.

That was "The Diamond Age" by Neal Stephenson. Lots of other interesting sociocultural post-scarcity speculation there, too.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by clicks on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:45AM (#6271511)
You bring up good points.

And speaking of privacy in anonymous forums and NSA snooping, I've been thinking as of late:

We can reasonably conclude now that NSA is probably in the game of data mining in a manner much like Google or Facebook, graphing networks and all. Data mining is considerably easier to do on social networking sites like Facebook where there's a push from the beginning to tie accounts to real identities, unlike anonymous forums. Now, the thing is, Reddit/4chan is a breeding ground for contrarian thought, indeed it is where a lot of the interesting stuff is born in the eyes of three-lettered agencies -- half of the Lulzsec memebers were active Redditors, Edward Snowden was a Redditor, every other programmer with unorthodox political interests is on Reddit. So I am really very confident that NSA/FBI keeps a special tab on Reddit, but what I'm curious about is how they go about doing that. I don't think Reddit staff has made a deal with three-letter agencies to help them tie anonymous accounts to real identities... but I wouldn't be surprised if these three letter agencies are putting a concerted effort on gathering data from anonymous networks in hopes of linking all things said and done under the guise of anonymity back to some real world id. (I imagine are probably sitting on a good many zero days, and can presumably carry out operations in which they surreptitiously steal a lot of data that can help them to tie Reddit accounts to real id's, for example).

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by hershel on Sunday August 25, 2013 @06:28AM (#6271594)
First, basic reddit isn't even encrypted. Many probably use it that way because their https is slow.

Now since there are time stamps on reddit posts, even https could be possibly annonimized using traffic analysis.

And if you use Tor, there are tools that might work against Tor.

Considering all this, the fact that reddit sells anonymity, and people use it for really personal info - which could easily be hacked even by someone with a network sniffer - is not honest.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by jdbernard on Sunday August 25, 2013 @02:21PM (#6273012)
Reddit doesn't really sell anonymity in the face of someone who is determined to find out who you are. People expect a basic level of anonymity, but they don't expect it to hold up before NSA level scrutiny.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by morpher on Sunday August 25, 2013 @11:46AM (#6272409)
I don't think the point of this post was anonymity against those with large resources, but rather day-to-day anonymity for social interaction.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by hershel on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:13PM (#6272496)
The parent asked about NSA. i replied.

But the lack of default https IS relevant to day to day hacking: the case of a wifi sniffer.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by ams6110 on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:25PM (#6272541)
I wouldn't trust Tor. It's surely deeply penetrated by the NSA, if in fact they didn't create it to begin with.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by rohit89 on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:48PM (#6272608)
This keeps popping up again and again. The source code for Tor is public.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by qq66 on Sunday August 25, 2013 @09:42PM (#6274671)
The idea that Tor is compromised by the NSA, if true, is not by releasing compromised source -- it's from the NSA running the tens or hundreds of thousands of Tor nodes required to compromise the system.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by consonants on Sunday August 25, 2013 @10:56PM (#6274921)
That's a red herring.

It's the network that is compromised. If you operate enough exit and relay nodes, you can be pretty damn well sure of where the traffic originated.

Anonymity hinges on the nodes, if an entity controls most of the nodes then the network is pretty much an effective honeypot.

Given that the FBI has been incredibly vocal about their efforts to take down Tor, and the fact that it is synonymous with illegal activity (drugs and child porn); operating enough nodes to investigate and bust criminals seems right up their alley.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by rohit89 on Monday August 26, 2013 @06:14AM (#6276109)
There are user options to specify which entry and exit nodes to use [1]. I'm not saying there aren't ways to defeat Tor but I dislike this knee-jerk reaction that a lot of people have with it because of its origin.

[1] https://gitweb.torproject.org/torspec.git/blob/HEAD:/path-sp...

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by consonants on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:21PM (#6278393)
That doesn't prevent the 99% of Tor users accessing hidden services exposing the location of the service to whoever is operating the majority of honeypot nodes.

It also doesn't prevent owners of relay nodes from construing the origin of traffic. It may not be as accurate assuming the user routes their traffic through uncompromised entry/exit nodes, but given the resources certain agencies have they can cross reference ISP etc traffic logs to determine the identity of tor users.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by milsorgen on Sunday August 25, 2013 @01:06PM (#6272692)
I've given some thought to anonymity on reddit and I've come to the conclusion it is all but unobtainable. Every now and then you see it happen, posting similarities or offhand comments are tied between accounts exposing what happened to so-in-so in the myriad of subreddit dramas. I change my account every so often, mostly because I tend to come across as a dick. Still I gain karma fairly steadily yet I prefer being blunt on reddit and that's not the person I wan't friends and family interacting with online, so I change it from time to time to keep my visibility low. So while I may not be 'strong' anonymous it still serves a purpose for me and allows me to engage in discussion whereas on other sites such as G+ or FB I completely abstain from conversation for fear of offending someone. At the end of the day that is useful even if I know full well those with the inclination could easily discern who I am.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by bad_user on Sunday August 25, 2013 @03:18PM (#6273284)
I think you should try being less of a dick in general. It happens to me too, as I get easily offended, however what I noticed is that if you want to educate people, it is far better to do it with well reasoned and nicely phrased arguments. Few people get away with being dicks, like Linus or Jobs, but that only happens for people that earned respect and credibility.

Incidentally this is why I prefer HN for the moment. The comments on Reddit tend to get too negative and full of insults. Anonymity is a doubly edged sword, sometimes bringing out the worst in people.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by samstave on Sunday August 25, 2013 @07:18PM (#6274192)
I agree that it is unobtainable.

I mode one of the top 50 /r/ on reddit, as well as some much much smaller ones. I have multiple accounts - but not in a gaming-the-system sense; I had a primary account and a novelty account... I wound up posting "primary" comments under my novelty account by mistake after leaving myself logged in with that account some time ago... now my novelty is my primary and my primary is dormant.

In the smaller /r/ I mod - I post instructional vids, and google linked them back to my real name. Even though I have an anonymized account for youtube, I also have a real-name account.

Once when posting, for reasons which are obfuscated by google, my uploads went to my real-name account which I posted to reddit...

So... ultimately, its easy to tie all these together as strong-selectors back to me :(

I have an idea on how to deal with tracking which may completely eliminate the ability to track a browser, but the issue is that even with 100% anonymity of an account on a site like reddit, ultimately you will post something that connects that account to your real-ID.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by RandyRanderson on Sunday August 25, 2013 @06:56AM (#6271645)
I imagine these agencies as being the same as big companies - huge bureaucratic messes with, hmm... not the best employees.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by kintamanimatt on Sunday August 25, 2013 @10:25AM (#6272087)
Cogs that are missing a few teeth will still turn most of the time, albeit inefficiently. No matter how much of a bureaucratic mess a business or government department is, shit always seems to get done ... eventually.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by adwf on Sunday August 25, 2013 @07:52AM (#6271756)
Yeah I remember reading this article a while back:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-gloucestershire-1414498...

Basically, GCHQ have to operate on the same pay-schemes as other civil service departments. Which means roughly £20k starting salary. Now if they want to hire the best of the best, straight out of university, they're going to have to compete with the City firms who will offer £90k+ to fresh grads. Not to mention the fact that GCHQ is in Cheltenham, not exactly an exciting cultural hotspot for young 20-somethings.

Makes me slightly less worried about government spying when I realise the trouble they have to go through to keep anybody half-decent.

No idea whether it's the same in the US. Do anyone know if they have strict guidelines on what they can pay civil servants?

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by Systemic33 on Sunday August 25, 2013 @08:22AM (#6271824)
You are forgetting that most governments then take in contractors in big IT projects, which in many cases have outrageous budgets. Now you've got the A+ people employed.

Just look at the prime real world example: Edward Snowden was a contractor, and not employed by the government.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by nnethercote on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:57AM (#6271541)
> An author I'd read in some scifi story or something similar had suggested that the mark of our era was the relentless pursuit and shaming of hypocrisy.

Sounds like Neal Stephenson's "The Diamond Age": http://steveedney.wordpress.com/2006/11/08/hypocrisy-relativ...

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by angersock on Sunday August 25, 2013 @06:30AM (#6271596)
Aha, I believe that was the one!
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by dageshi on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:36AM (#6271492)
Or "your future prospective employer is going to google your name when you apply for a job"

In which case I'd suggest you've got a very strong motivation for not posting anything remotely controversial under a real name account.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by angersock on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:42AM (#6271503)
At this point, even with my handles and nicks, that cat is out of the bag. I look at it this way: if they wouldn't hire me over something I said online, I don't want to work there anyways.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by dageshi on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:52AM (#6271531)
That assumes you'll always have the luxury of being able to pick and choose your job. For you perhaps that's the case, for others it won't always be the case.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by angersock on Sunday August 25, 2013 @06:32AM (#6271600)
I wouldn't want to claim that mindset for anyone other than myself--and again, I support anonymous pseudonyms for people.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by superuser2 on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:09PM (#6273732)
Reddit to me serves a completely different purpose from GMail, Facebook, and Google+. Those are for using the internet to talk to people I know (or knew) by real name.

If Facebook was pseudonymous I would never touch it again. The only advantage it presents over email is that I can find out about and message someone in my real-world life when all I know is their name. It's email without the need for an address book.

Reddit is a community in its own right, just like HN, so it makes sense to have separate identities in those spheres. That's not an argument for letting my friends make me discover and remember AIM-esque screennames just to send them messages.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by lutusp on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:41PM (#6272597)
> Without anonymity, it can be very difficult to conduct useful intellectual discourse, especially if you aren't strong-willed enough to deal with trolls and jerks who say "But aha! Yesterday you claimed A, but today B; which is it?".

I believe being held to account for one's past actions and present views is called "personal responsibility", and yes, that has certainly fallen out of fashion. If you think being forced to be consistent from moment to moment and day to day hinders useful intellectual discourse, maybe we're using different definitions of "useful".

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by Dylan16807 on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:51PM (#6272627)
Being responsible has nothing to do with not changing your mind. What in the world are you talking about?
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by lutusp on Sunday August 25, 2013 @02:48PM (#6273175)
> Being responsible has nothing to do with not changing your mind.

Being responsible has everything to do with changing or not changing your mind. An anonymous troll can lie and say, "I never said that." A named person cannot -- he has to accept personal responsibility for his past statements and actions.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by Dylan16807 on Sunday August 25, 2013 @03:04PM (#6273229)
I think you're confusing different scenarios. Nobody was talking about lying. A responsible person will respond "I said that, but I changed my mind because X", and everyone should be happy. But in the problem angersock mentions, people complain, accusing hypocrisy as if everything you have ever said in your life was uttered mere moments ago.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by RandyRanderson on Sunday August 25, 2013 @06:52AM (#6271634)
I completely agree that you really don't gain anything (as a user) by using a real identity. I'm not so sure the organization gains much on the other side either...
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:58AM (#6271543)
>> the mark of our era was the relentless pursuit and shaming of hypocrisy.

You must live on a different planet than me. :-)

Let me take an example I saw this week:

I have some Eastern Europeans with different opinions in my Facebook. One upset discussion right now is about why Russia gets so much criticism for homophobia these days.

They assume it is an old Cold War prejudice, since the whole Middle East and much of Africa are something like a factor of ten worse.. And they get almost no media cover. Including the immigrants (at least in Sweden), which have the same opinions.

It might be some unspoken racism from the left wing (not expect better of the primitives), but it is probably just hypocrisy -- harsh criticism of an external example as a way to get everyone on the same page.

I'm all for tolerance and acceptance of the gay community, but I seem to be quite unusual in being equally shocked by hypocrisy and double standards as by homophobia.

Even if you use double thinking in a good cause to spread tolerance in a group, it clouds your analytic capability in the group. That is a bad thing.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by stygianguest on Sunday August 25, 2013 @06:09AM (#6271562)
This is not hypocrisy and has nothing to do with the cold war. Quite to the contrary: we hold Russians to a higher standard than Saudi Arabia. Like we hold the USA to a higher standard than either country in regards to privacy.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @06:27AM (#6271593)
If totally different standards for different people/countries regarding intolerance is neither hypocrisy nor racism -- what is it?

My theory above is that totally different standards for different parts of the world really is political propaganda to the citizens of the country where the media writes.

Do you have another explanation?

(To take another example -- even with a Palestinian description of Israel, the Sudan atrocities were a thousand times worse. My local leftwing media (more or less all local media) complained many times more about Israel, anyway. And never about that Israel was criticized every year in UN but Sudan very little. How many thousands of times is reasonable for different standards?)

Edit: Note when I wrote that immigrants, even citizens now, in Sweden is criticized much less.. Not even that is neither racism nor double standards?!

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by rjd on Sunday August 25, 2013 @07:03AM (#6271657)
Its got a mythos as the last frontier of Europe, of hard country and hard men, enduring under dogs ... down trodden but never giving up.

Emerging from each massive injustice with a new culture rich from strife, from the cossacks to beauty hidden within the works of the communist era. And the sadness of what totalitarian rule did to a people trying to build an equal and fair society, the people who died for others, and eventually all in vein.

It resonates as a country to admire, a people to admire, the mystique of its history and taste of its asian influence. And despite that its a foreign place. London to St Petersburg is closer than LA to New York, at times Russia has been part of Europe.

The double standard for me and many of friends (whom I talk history with it) is one of love, sorrow, and admiration. When the illusion of the Russian mythos breaks and the reality of human condition seeps through you get held to that standard. Not one of a distant problem, a stranger in a strange land, one of a friend.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @07:48AM (#6271743)
Are you a Turing Test program that misunderstood and went off on a tangent? (That would explain a lot on HN, recently.) Or are you just trying to change the subject?
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by VLM on Sunday August 25, 2013 @08:02AM (#6271781)
So you claim its "political propaganda to the citizens of the country where the media writes" and ask "Do you have another explanation?" and he responds that its "the mystique of its history and taste of its asian influence".

Not seeing a problem here?

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @08:09AM (#6271793)
I gave another example. It is easy to give more examples of the hypocrisy I talked about -- without Russia.

Edit: Not that it is relevant, but I've liked most every Russian I've spoken to more than five minutes. And Putin scares me when he limits press freedom and organized crime gets integrated with the police.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by rjd on Sunday August 25, 2013 @07:58AM (#6271772)
No Im just jet lagged :/ and gave you another reason for the double standard towards Russia.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @09:18AM (#6271941)
On consideration, sorry for being pissy (English slang, iirc). Your comment was relevant to part about what I wrote and very well written.

I posted a theory about something I find strange -- and waited with bated breath for either support or to be short down with a good reference that taught me a lot about the world. Sigh, no luck on that part. Maybe no one knows.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by Amadou on Sunday August 25, 2013 @11:20AM (#6272304)
Israel and Russia are considered 1st world countries. That implies a level of social progressivism and standards of living that 3rd world countries don't have. So when a country fails to live up to those standards they get criticism.

You might see that as propaganda, I see that as acknowledgement of reality. Everybody expects Israel to behave like the democracy they claim to be, nobody expects the Sudan - with its self-appointed president of nearly 25 years - to behave like a democracy. In other words, Sudan's problems are a symptom of Sudan's level of social progress, while Israel and Russia's problems are seen as an aberration in their level of social progress. You would never see the Olympics hosted in Sudan.

As for immigrants being criticized for holding 3rd world views after moving to a 1st world country, they don't have the kind of power that a government does so the harm they can do by acting on their beliefs is significantly less than what the state could do.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @11:46AM (#6272408)
>> Israel and Russia are considered 1st world countries. [There are higher standards for them]

I acknowledged that when I wrote "How many thousands of times is reasonable for different standards?"

So, how many factors of ten higher standards should be held for Israel than for, say, the countries that spend a large part of their GNP on artillery for use on civilians?

3? 4?

(I've asked that multiple times and never gotten an answer when people repeat your argument. Including in what you comment on.)

>> Sudan's problems are a symptom of Sudan's level of social progress

I also brought up that at least Swedish media avoid mentioning that the dictators taking control of the UNHRC and not complaining about each others.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Cou...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Cou...

That is not explained by you thinking it is OK to have a factor thousands in different standards.

>>As for immigrants being criticized for holding 3rd world views after moving to a 1st world country, they don't have the kind of power that a government does

You really see no problem having factors of ten different standards for different groups of citizens inside a country?

Besides, I think you simplify (on the border of excusing) unpleasant regimes that oppress, mass murder and steal -- when you just describe the reason as "different levels of social progress". Countries today are poor mainly because they are controlled by corrupt juntas (or in a conflict, usually created by juntas). Every country on the planet with population over a few millions can and should have a competent government.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by Amadou on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:09PM (#6272485)
"How many thousands of times is reasonable for different standards?"

That is hyperbole. You've quantified something that is not really quantifiable. As long as that is your argument you'll got no satisfactory answer. All you are doing is begging the question.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:17PM (#6272510)
>> [E.g. Sudan's atrocities is at least a factor thousand worse than anything from Israel] is hyperbole.

And that is not an argument. I motivated my position, you're calling names.

I wrote specifically that Sudan is at least a thousand times worse than Israel -- even with a Palestinian description (where e.g. killing people attacking civilians is not self defence). Look at number of dead, rapes, deportations etc etc -- what is NOT a thousand times worse?

If we can't quantify e.g. human rights violations we should close down international law.

Etc.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by Amadou on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:30PM (#6272563)
Your complaint is that the media criticism is not proportional to the level of harm. The hyperbole is in your measurement of the criticism.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:43PM (#6272602)
Let me note that you are arguing something completely different than you started with.

>> Your complaint is that the media criticism is not proportional to the level of harm. The hyperbole is in your measurement of the criticism

Well, no.

One is at least a thousand times larger than the other in effect.

The criticism (in my local Swedish and from much of the European media) is much larger. See e.g. the UNHRC discussion above. That is all I need for my thesis to not be "hyperbole".

Notes: 1. Since the Syrian situation started it has been very quiet re Israel, the different standards would probably be too obvious. 2. Serious media, e.g. BBC/NY Times, was (well, by definition) more serious than bad media.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by Amadou on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:52PM (#6272631)
Let me note that you are arguing something completely different than you started with.

Yes, I started off explaining why there is relatively unbalanced coverage.

You made it clear that your argument is based on hard numbers that you've basically made up. So now I am pointing out that making up hard numbers and not accepting arguments that don't precisely fit your arbitrary numbers is just a form of rhetoric. Measuring the effect of coverage is even more arbitrary. "Effect" is something so vague that there aren't even any units to measure it.

You will not receive any satisfactory answers because you have designed the question to be unanswerable so as to advocate a position rather than seek an explanation.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Friday August 30, 2013 @07:43PM (#6304853)
As an addendum, seeing this a few days later, I'll add a note also about the other side of my claim, to be complete; the Swedish/European media I'm familiar with.

For any given year before the Syrian crisis, you could find kilometers of criticism of Israel. On the other hand, the first thing I saw over decades in Swedish about the Tunisian dictator was when he fled!

The criticism of Syria, easily one of the planet's worst police states even before the present atrocities, was a bit more than Tunisia -- but far from even one kilometer/year.

(Note that Syria was a large part of the Israeli conflict, so it should be discussed quite a lot.)

(Not hard data, but hardly arbitrarily. I could continue with mentioning that Pallywood and torture among Palestinian groups where just censored in Swedish. And so on, and on.)

But frankly, I think you knew this too.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @01:18PM (#6272735)
>>hard numbers that you've basically made up.

Here are quick overviews of the facts I claimed in the GP:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_Sudan

http://www.oxfam.org/en/emergencies/sudan-southsudan

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli%E2%80%93Palestinian_con...

But you knew that.

So it is easy to claim different standards as a factor of thousands. But you knew that, too.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by ShardPhoenix on Sunday August 25, 2013 @09:16AM (#6271937)
This might be an issue of thinking on the margin - that given their starting points, it's theoretically easier to get Israel or Russia to meet (leftist) American standards than to get Sudan to meet them.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:07PM (#6272478)
I am far from an expert in either case, but that doesn't seem logical.

The Russian government is killing press freedom and stealing the oil income. They need external enemies and blame the west. Any criticism from the Western world seems to be dismissed as anti-Russian hate mongering.

Re Israel, good luck influencing them: (1) Consider the US reaction on 9/11. Israel had something like that continuously since long before 1948. (2) I believe most of the Jewish population there aren't descended from European refugees but people kicked out from countries in the Middle East, for having the wrong religion. They think things like "They stole three times the size of Israel from us personally when they forced us out, we're getting back the parts of the West Bank some of us was kicked out from".

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by pipy on Monday August 26, 2013 @05:28AM (#6275976)
I am Russian and live in Russia. I don't usually write comments, but, since I've never seen any reasonable explanation of the Russian homophobia issue on any Western website, I'm going to bite the bullet:

First of all, as banal as it may sound, Russian State Duma doesn't represent the interests and wishes of the general public in any meaningful way (at least, if compared to any Western European country or US). The votes are constantly rigged, and even though the Putin is supported by the large majority of population (sad truth), Russian State Duma by the huge part is literally a bunch of degenerates, clowns and Putin's yes-men at best. So, they can pass any insane law that they wish to pass.

Secondly, the regime's popularity is monotonically decreasing, albeit slowly. And the reason is that the relative economic prosperity is based only on high oil and natural gas prices (which can still help you during the next couple of decades). The industrial complex is in decline and nothing is able to revive it (because of the fact that any owner of successful company can be stripped of his ownership in any time -- and this is de facto at the core of the regime and cannot be changed).

When you begin to understand that your popularity trend wont ever change, you start looking for means for tightening control and providing alternative channels to drain the public discontent. For their main ideology the ruling regime has adopted the "back into the future" style monarchism and religion (which is miserable at best, but is the only choice when the largest opposing part of the public still praises higher standards of living in atheistic USSR).

Some jerk has made an arbitrary decision that it is a good idea to also go after gays. The passing of the anti-gay-propaganda law and the half-assed media campaign followed.

How does majority of the Russian people really relate to gays: 1) First and foremost, no one even thinks about the issue. When the large part of a population lives below poverty line, when there are significant issues with police misconduct and corruption, etc. etc., you have larger issues to think of. 2) Literally the overwhelming majority of the people I ever new are highly tolerant to gays. I'm speaking this as a person that has contacts within diverse social groups (university dropout, served as a conscript in a military for two years, born in another region, but now a long time Moscow resident). 3) This does not preclude that the Russian people as a whole are probably less fond of gays than Western Europeans, but not even near the scale of the current media hype. This is sad. But there are some orders of magnitude sadder things in Russia for everyone to deal with every day.

Now, when US and UK have some relationship issues with Russia, they have decided that this is a good time to raise the issue. Since the Russia is de facto tabula rasa for West and vice versa, the bullshit card has worked really fine.

I am personally for allowing gay marriage etc. etc., but we shouldn't even be talking about this, because this "Russian homophobia" is pure propaganda stuff, on both sides. There are huge issues in the West and Russia that are much more important.

Slightly offtopic: great lecture about ideology by Slavoj Žižek https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1Kb4JZGpA0

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @09:51PM (#6287551)
Thanks for an interesting read about a subject, when the main discussion was about the media garbage regarding the subject!

Some points:

1. I was lucky I saw that, stuff disappears quickly from the front page on HN. Next time the subject comes up, please post it again (or a link). Others would appreciate reading it too, imho.

2. If you go back just a few decades, intolerance to homosexuals were also official policy in the west. This moral panic about Russia is a bit ridiculous (my original point). Russian attitudes will change when (/if :-( ) the economy gets better and social development gets going.

3. As probably most West European computer people, I know enough Russians/East Europeans to understand that "Russians are X" is as stupid as generalizing about West Europeans.

4. I doubt there is a conspiracy to make Russia look bad. The coverage of human rights violations in Caucasus would then be much better. (You bought your local media's hype. :-) )

(I added the video to my "Watch Later", I would rather watch that than write more tests for old code... Just 20 pages of tests or so left. :-( :-) )

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by pipy on Wednesday August 28, 2013 @11:08AM (#6290457)
Hi! I'd like to thank you too! It was kind of disappointing to become aware that my reply wasn't probably read by anybody (since there were no new posts on the thread at all). And equally refreshing to read your reply! :)

Thanks for a tip about posting a link on HN news, it didn’t cross my mind since I usually think of it as if it is a feed with important and interesting stories for the general public. It's hard for me to judge if my reply was interesting to anyone apart of you and a couple of other posters on the thread.

As about conspiracy theories, maybe I didn't choose the right words. I don't think about the Russian homosexual issue as a part of some grand plan, rather as a temporary and somewhat arbitrary distraction from more important issues. At least today, when Russia is more or less compliant with the West on the major issues. Even when the most of the people like to think otherwise, Russia is nowhere near waging an independent foreign policy (we can probably argue on that for a long time, but I don't think it's worth it). Also, such distractions and theme changes as "Snowden revelations" >> "Problems of Russian homosexuals" don't even need to be conscious.

You've made a great point about Caucasus and the overall horrendous human rights record of Russia. And it is a really interesting point that the media has raised some relatively mild issue instead of, just from the top of my head, jailing of union workers that were fighting for better wages and improvement of abysmal safety controls on the factories of Western automotive conglomerates that are based in Russia. Or even something just as horrible and at the same time not strictly related to the interests of Western business. An equally interesting question is why we hear lamentations about the homosexual propaganda law now and not couple of years before, when the policy was implemented. These are important issues that you've raised, but the answers to them don't lie on the on the surface. IMHO, they also don't lie in the field of conspiracy theories, rather in the field of human psychology and the somewhat recent history of US-USSR relations. I'd really like to expand on this, but now I need to write some code, too. :)

Good luck!

It would be interesting to hear your opinion about Žižek's points! (Don't consider this too binding: if you won't find time to watch the talk, or would be reluctant to express your thoughts about it, I would understand! :))

P.S. If memory serves me well, the largest media hype about atrocities in Chechnya was just before the Kosovo War, when Yeltsin hasn't yet decided not to provide direct military support to Milošević regime. At least, that was my impression.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Thursday August 29, 2013 @11:04AM (#6296185)
Hi again,

I have no clue how posting stories works. (I have a suspicion that a of extra accounts are often(?) used to vote most stories up, so they get to the front page.) Most of the times when I get (or lose!) karma is when I write something in a very new story.

Interesting point about laws re homosexuality, I didn't know they were that old. Hmm, maybe there is some reason why it is so visible right now. Maybe not only the Chinese state can set the media's agenda...?

Good luck yourself! Still writing tests and I'll go drink at a wedding this weekend. :-( :-)

I'm aiming for beginning of next week.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by pipy on Friday August 30, 2013 @08:34AM (#6301342)
I'd like to correct myself: I've said that the policy was implemented couple of years before, this is not correct. The first country-wide law ‘against propaganda of homosexuality to minors’ was really passed on 11-th of June, 2013. But we had multiple similar laws that were passed on regional levels long before, starting in 2006 when the law was passed in Ryazan Oblast, and culminating in 2011 when it was passed in many other regions and Saint Petersburg among them. And the media was talking about the need for such laws probably for five or six years.

Here is a good summary of the situation: http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=auto&tl=en&u=...

I should have checked the facts earlier. The media was babbling about the need of the law for so long, that it seems that I've lost touch. The ruling party has introduced the bill in March of 2012. They government is doing so many blatantly absurd things, that it's hard to track of all of them. The current issues that I'm interested in are the dissolution of the Russian Academy of Sciences; extending of blatant religious propaganda to small children in schools; possible two-fold or three-fold increase of the utility payments; introduction of the ‘non-state’ center for fighting ‘atheist extremism’ by the church which is so integrated into the ruling regime, impudent and crooky that it alienates not-insignificant part of it's own congregation; the legislation for prohibiting the Tor network and the growing list of banned websites; dismantling of free education. And the disturbing fact that anything that doesn't go along with government's plans is becoming ‘extremism’. Even small local protests against non-political issues are being videotaped by the FSB, in the regions some people literally go to jail for protesting against minor stuff, etc., etc.

Have a good time! Since I haven't been invited to any wedding party, I have no choice but to resort to drinking alone. Ha ha, just kidding. In the coming days I would probably do some work. )))

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Friday August 30, 2013 @08:04PM (#6304937)
Oh my Cthulhu, thanks for a depression :-( :-)

I had forgotten about the Tor network and most of the other craziness.

So, the last dictators kept the church down and the coming one one hugs it closely? Re religion...

As a hard line atheist, I have to admit the Orthodox churches I saw in a short St Petersburg visit long ago impressed me.

You know Scandinavian "taste"? One extra line in a design is a bit... brave. Two lines is, well, avantgarde. Three -- beyond tacky. The churches there made my eyes bleed from the sheer amount of details, while they blew me away with sheer beauty. Cool feeling.

I exaggerated the drinking. I was outsourced to Romania a couple of years back and am still here. People here are nice but just don't drink for fun. (In the small villages they are said to drink like sponges, I'll avoid moving there. :-) )

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by gyardley on Sunday August 25, 2013 @11:38AM (#6272374)
In most cases inter-country opinions are just a way to manifest bigotry in a polite and acceptable way.

The Europeans holding the American government to a different standard on privacy are doing so because they're reflexively anti-American.

The people holding the Russian government to a different standard on gay rights are doing so because Russia's an old Cold War enemy they intrinsically dislike.

The people who hold the Israeli government to a different standard than any other nation on earth do so because they hate Jews.

No one likes to admit they're a nationalist bigot, so this kind of frank talk is never popular, but we pretty much all are.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by mangotree on Sunday August 25, 2013 @12:57PM (#6272652)
What a fantastic way to devalue other people's reasonable opinions. They hate what Israel is doing in Palestine territories because they hate the Jews. Brilliant!
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by richardjordan on Sunday August 25, 2013 @03:08PM (#6273242)
It's amazing how often I - as a non-Jew - hear rants about the Palestinian territories eventually drift off into anti-semitic stereotypes with the assumption I'll be sympathetic to the opinion.

Just like yes, most Europeans I know (which is kinda a lot given that I'm British and just happen to live in the US nowadays) who are ballistic about NSA spying give their own countries, often much farther along as surveillance states, a free pass because basically it's just another reason to attack the US (as is European left's recent flirtations with Islam, an ideology which in many ways you'd think is diametrically opposed to much of what the European left professes to believe - but anti-Americanism trumps all).

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by gyardley on Sunday August 25, 2013 @01:37PM (#6272821)
After seeing the blatant double-standard and after the hostile Palestine grouse-fest I tend to get from people the second they learn I'm Jewish (not Israeli, not anything about my personal politics), yeah - I'm going to call it like I see it.

Sorry, but the vast majority of you are bigoted hypocrites. If it wasn't Israel it'd be how we control the media or some other damn fool thing.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by Amadou on Sunday August 25, 2013 @11:09PM (#6274956)
I don't know where you live, but in the USA it has long been normal for pro-Israel jews to claim a sort of ownership of judaism. Ariel Sharon once said, "Israel is not only an Israeli project. Israel is a Jewish, worldwide project."

One of the most destructive stereotypes is the self-hating jew - that any jew who criticizes israel is incapable of making a principled argument, instead he's just internalized anti-semitism. So it isn't necessarily anti-semitism for people who have picked up on that cultural norm to assume that any random jew is in favor of israeli policies.

The younger generations of American jews don't feel that sort of affinity with Israel, and the Israeli government's policies have played a big part in that disconnect. It is such a big deal that the Netanyahu government ran some tv ads a couple of years ago that basically amounted to telling israelis not to marry american jews because they weren't jewish enough. That went over like a lead balloon, even the ADL criticized the ads. All in all, I think that sort of response is important progress in decoupling judaism from zionism.

And, fwiw, I'm a born athiest who married into a mixed family of secular muslims, secular jews and cultural catholics - my grand-niece is a mix of all three, although she's too young to know it.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by pessimizer on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:14PM (#6273757)
Homophobia in the Middle East and Africa has gotten ten times the media coverage of homophobia in Russia, so I'd say the premise is wrong. Russia is getting attention right now because they just passed a hateful law.

I'd never seen any coverage at all of homophobia in Russia until a couple of months ago, when that new law seemed to come out of the blue - so I'd ask the question: why hadn't we heard more about homophobia in Russia?

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=uganda+homosexual

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by berntb on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:27PM (#6273796)
There has been active Neonazi groups in Russia since the 90s, with gay bashing and attacks on non-whites. But it is a point, my example might be wrong since media coverage do differ.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by LordHumungous on Sunday August 25, 2013 @05:18PM (#6273775)
Ah, the old "other people are doing it too!" excuse. Russia has actively launched several anti gay initiatives recently, and subsequently repressed the protests from that nation's gay community. Therefore the criticism in the west is more about supporting an ongoing struggle than suddenly one day realizing that Russia's gay laws are backwards. I suspect the same criticism would be leveled against, say, Iran if that nation were in the middle of a crackdown on the Iranian gay rights movement.
Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by samstave on Sunday August 25, 2013 @07:48PM (#6274278)
>...since the whole Middle East and much of Africa are something like a factor of ten worse.. And they get almost no media cover.

I am convinced that there is a secret agenda for letting the majority of Africa just devolve and kill themselves. It seems that should the western world largely ignore the issues of Africa, ~50 years from now corps will be able to move into that region using the same tactics we see today in the ME, and rape it of its resources.

The difference being that China has started this rape already - and has caught the western nations (UKUSA) largely unprepared to follow suit.

Ever play Trade Wars on BBSs in the 80s? That's pretty much what the world boils down to.

Re:Reddit has the killer social network feature: anonymity by tokipin on Sunday August 25, 2013 @10:20PM (#6274801)
there are outcries when 3rd world countries do homophobic things, too.

i think russia's case is because 1) russia recently accelerated its homophobia by passing laws or intending to pass laws, 2) the olympic games are going to be held in russia, which brings up the question of gay athletes, 3) russia is in the news lately for a lot of things, such as for supporting the Syrian dictator, and 4) gay rights in general has received a lot more attention recently. in particular the U.S. essentially just legalized gay marriage