I am not dodging the question; my answer is yes. Applying a LNT model to alcohol exposure is silly.
Do you really think that a Mormon drinking 3 glasses of wine in his life has a one in a million chance of losing his liver?
Re:Micromort
by Dylan16807 on Friday August 23, 2013 @11:09PM
(#6267437)
That specific mechanism? Probably not. But I wasn't here to say the effects were linear. I was just pointing out that complaining about sample size in a theoretical experiment where you can multiply the size in your head is a nonsensical objection.
Perhaps. I was merely trying to be precise with my answer so that I wouldn't say something silly (expecting the exact same number of deaths). I wasn't trying to be bitchy, though I fear it came off that way.
Yes, I would be shocked if an extra millionth died, because we have done many many studies of alcohol consumption, and they show that below a certain level (40ml a week or something?) there is no measurable effect on health.
Re:Micromort
by Dylan16807 on Saturday August 24, 2013 @11:21AM
(#6268865)
I thought wine was supposed to be vaguely positive?
If we had 10e20 people in each group and gave an extra 0.5 liters of alcohol to each one, would you be shocked that a millionth of them died?