Re:Newest YouTube user to fight a takedown is copyright guru...
by thenomad on Friday August 23, 2013 @06:15AM
(#6262599)
That's not quite 100% true - there were various sites that disseminated video to and from consumers. I ran one of them, Machinima.com, which was founded in 2000.
However, they were few, far between, and didn't work nearly as well as YouTube. I'll admit to making a massive mistake disregarding Flash video back in those days in favour of downloadable content!
YouTube really has been a remarkable thing - one of the few .coms that can genuninely claim to have significantly changed the world.
Re:Newest YouTube user to fight a takedown is copyright guru...
by eksith on Friday August 23, 2013 @07:21AM
(#6262792)
Before YouTube there wasn't any consumer-accessible dissemination of AV media online
Are we forgetting eBaum's World? Metacafe? Break (used to be Big-boys.com)? And of course right after YouTube came LiveLeak (from the same guys as Ogrish and I wouldn't touch that with a 10-foot pole).eBaum's was fighting the copyright fight (and for less than honorable reasons) long before YouTube existed.
Before YouTube there wasn't any consumer-accessible dissemination of AV media online. You had to have serious equipment, there was no social distribution and copyrighted material couldn't get used anywhere.
YouTube came along and simply overpowered the copyright holders with both sheer volume and variety of copyright infringements and followed through with the financial and legal muscle of Google behind it. There was a long time when it wasn't clear whether YouTube would actually survive its legal battle and I assume that the instant-take-downs were a compromise that was reached to allow them to continue.
I'm glad that Lawrence Lessig is fighting this case and it's a good time for it to happen. However it's also worth keeping in mind why these instant take-downs were instituted in the first place - it was (I presume) because it was the only way to placate copyright holders into allowing the whole thing to continue.