News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by joshuahedlund on Thursday August 22, 2013 @03:04PM (#6259308)
I like this argument, too, but the common response is that Lasik and cosmetic surgeries are elective - voluntary improvements to your body that are a sort of luxury that lend themselves to competition (shopping around, taking your time). By contrast, a lot of expensive medical procedures are much more critical and time-sensitive (you could say the demand is much less elastic), which makes it a lot harder for competition to work (though more price transparency might help!), especially if as another comment says[0], "You get taken to a hospital out of your control, and they're allowed to decide what services to provide and as well as the price they're going to charge you..."

[0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6258953

Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by bmmayer1 on Thursday August 22, 2013 @03:15PM (#6259392)
What the commenter suggested is exactly the situation right now: the hospital sets the prices as astronomically high as possible because they can get away with it, because the patients aren't paying it. Don't you think introducing patient choice into the equation would put some downward pressure on prices? And certainly if it puts any downward pressure on prices, it's a better situation than we have now.
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by dragonwriter on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:46PM (#6260310)
> Don't you think introducing patient choice into the equation would put some downward pressure on prices?

If you could magically make healthcare look like an Econ 101 market where rational choice theory and perfect competition both were even remotely reasonable models of what was going on, sure.

But "patients don't pay directly for services" isn't even close to the only way that healthcare doesn't look like an Econ 101 market. Rational choice theory is a deeply and fundamentally flawed model to start with, but its a tolerable approximation of behavior in lots of important cases (mostly, classes of products which are frequently purchased and used and whose utilities are very clear upon use, allowing any misperceptions about expected utility to be resolved so that most purchase decisions are in fact made with reasonably strong information about costs and utilities.)

Look, the rest of the developed world does as good or better (by most measures) healthcare than the US at vastly lower cost (whether measured per capita or per GDP), and they don't do it by making patient pay directly for services. The whole idea that we have to resort to abstract Econ 101 theory to determine how to control prices in healthcare ignores the fact that the rest of the developed world exists.

Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by Smudge on Thursday August 22, 2013 @04:02PM (#6259669)
If you're having a heart attack, are you really in a position to negotiate on price? At all? I get that there might be some downward pressure, but what prevents the hospital from just laying an absurd bill on you after the procedure?
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by duskwuff on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:10PM (#6260105)
It's somewhat akin to emergency non-medical services - say, a tow truck, locksmith, or plumber. Many of these services cost quite a bit more than they should. Why? Because the people who need them are in no position to shop around.
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by nsxwolf on Thursday August 22, 2013 @07:15PM (#6260721)
The hope with a real free market is that you wouldn't have to negotiate in that situation, the prices would already be reasonable.
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by dragonwriter on Thursday August 22, 2013 @07:21PM (#6260732)
> The hope with a real free market is that you wouldn't have to negotiate in that situation, the prices would already be reasonable.

The theoretical efficiency of a real "real free market" depends on the ability to evaluate and choose options in a competitive market for purchasing goods and services based on perfect knowledge of the costs of and utility from each purchase.

There's a whole lot of reasons that a deregulated market for "purchasing treatment for a heart attack you are currently experiencing" is not likely to have the features that theoretically create efficiency in a "real free market".

Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by nsxwolf on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:39PM (#6261238)
Also, a heart attack is a rare event, and presumably one that would be covered by a real insurance policy.
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by roc on Thursday August 22, 2013 @04:11PM (#6259745)
The real point to them being elective luxuries is that the would-be consumer can actually walk away entirely. You needn't get lazik from anyone. The same can't be said of many/most medical procedures.

You can't research the market and just skip getting a knee replacement altogether, the way you could with lazik. To say nothing of more serious problems.

Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by plock on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:12PM (#6260117)
The consumer also can't entirely walk away from the food market. That doesn't make food prices go out of control.
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by roc on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:38PM (#6260265)
Which would be a great point if not for the oversight, subsidies, reserves and incentives that affect staple foods.
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by plock on Thursday August 22, 2013 @07:35PM (#6260776)
The point is that consumers are still able to bid down prices despite having no choice but to participate in the market. Individual sellers still have to convince individual buyers to buy their products, and to do so they have to price their goods competitively. It doesn't matter that there is no alternative to participating in the food market because there are alternatives within the food market.
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by venomsnake on Thursday August 22, 2013 @06:12PM (#6260443)
According to USDA in 2011 15% of US households suffered from food insecurity - for them they are already out of control.

And there are the other couple of billion people on the planet that cannot afford a dollar per day for a meal.

Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by plock on Thursday August 22, 2013 @10:30PM (#6261361)
They're not out of control, those people just happen to be very poor. They haven't been going up like crazy like health care costs have.
Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by bmmayer1 on Thursday August 22, 2013 @06:38PM (#6260546)
> 15% of US households suffered from food insecurity

...partly because of healthcare costs, which is the number one cause of bankruptcy in the US. You're making our point.

Re:The Man Who Was Treated for $17,000 Less by rthomas6 on Thursday August 22, 2013 @04:26PM (#6259840)
If my breaks need replacing or my A/C goes out, I'm not going to use my car insurance to pay for that, because that would make the insurance really expensive, and create a similar price insensitivity. I don't see how that's different than getting knee surgery or whatever.

OTOH if I get in an accident where I'm not at fault (let's assume the other person didn't have insurance), I'll use my insurance to fix the car, because it's a sudden emergency with a high cost. I don't see how that's different than a heart attack or whatever.

I don't see why people conflate all medical care into one group. Routine care and emergency care are clearly separate.