News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Four fears for authoritarians by raverbashing on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:32AM (#6256112)
"Can democratic state do without any secret service at all?"

Maybe. But probably they won't stay democratic for long. Some people are only there to make a mess.

"There should be no blank exceptions to free speech"

Remember that this works for the WBC. I'm not saying it's bad, but it's a consequence.

"you should have right to publicly criticize your employer"

But this is like it is. Free speech does not mean speech without consequences, but it means you have the right to speak your mind (as opposed to a "preventive silence")

Re:Four fears for authoritarians by asgard1024 on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:49AM (#6256169)
"But probably they won't stay democratic for long."

The word "probably" is precisely my point. To my knowledge, nobody ever tested this. We have police to deal with mess, which is under public scrutiny. Why SS should be exempt is not clear at all.

"Remember that this works for the WBC."

Not being American, I don't know what you refer to, sorry.

"Free speech does not mean speech without consequences"

I don't follow. I don't understand why speaking about what happened to you in the past should have any consequence to you. It may have consequence for the other people involved, that some may learn they are not so squeaky clean, and they will lose their authority, but that's precisely what the article was about.

Re:Four fears for authoritarians by raverbashing on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:57AM (#6256183)
"To my knowledge, nobody ever tested this."

I'm not talking about only internal threats, but external threats as well. I'm not sure that "nobody has tested this" but history has lots of cases of coups, invasions, etc (and probably other cases where things went differently)

The WBC is the Westboro Baptist Church, read about them and how they use freedom of speech laws.

"I don't understand why speaking about what happened to you in the past should have any consequence to you."

Because of something called Defamation. There's also the possibility of having admitted to a crime.

But yes, in the US freedom of speech is very strong, even there, it's not 100% free of consequences (which may be a good thing). In some other countries defamation laws stifle free speech.

Re:Four fears for authoritarians by asgard1024 on Thursday August 22, 2013 @07:03AM (#6256360)
These are the things where I believe we should change the culture. We should learn not to take claims on their face value. If everyone would do that, we would need no defamation laws or laws restricting free speech. All that would be just "noise". And my 3rd point was, we can maybe even automate such processing of information, for our own benefit.

I believe that the positive effect of not censoring stuff outweighs the negative effect of spreading misinformation, always. In other words, you cannot at the same time claim that people cannot distinguish misinformation and that they process it differently from truth (and therefore attempts to ban it will do more good than harm). And the idea of "free speech" in itself is a proof of that, so far.

Re:Four fears for authoritarians by kragniz on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:59AM (#6256187)
>Not being American, I don't know what you refer to, sorry.

I'm not american either, but I'm pretty sure he was referring to the westboro baptist church.

Re:Four fears for authoritarians by marvin on Thursday August 22, 2013 @06:38AM (#6256285)
Freedom of speech does imply that people will say unpopular things. And Westboro Babtist Church does fall under this protection. Regarding extrajudicial consequences of e.g. whistleblowing in the private sector, I think that this area needs explicit protections since the consequences of pissing someone off are so severe. (From what I gather, whistleblowing against a US employer is more or less career suicide). It goes without saying that this is a democratic problem.

In fact, the protection of the freedom of speech is another prominent example that if you just leave the market forces to sort things out, you will eventually end up with a situation that is in opposition to the ideal of a functioning democratic society.

Re:Four fears for authoritarians by hahainternet on Thursday August 22, 2013 @07:45AM (#6256506)
> And Westboro Babtist Church does fall under this protection

Not in the first world.

Re:Four fears for authoritarians by hyperventilator on Thursday August 22, 2013 @10:46AM (#6257446)
Yeah, in some parts of the "first world" you can do prison time for a tweet.
Re:Four fears for authoritarians by hahainternet on Thursday August 22, 2013 @11:32AM (#6257749)
You can do prison time for a tweet anywhere that has any harassment, libel, obscenity, juror protection or many many other laws. What's the betting you only disagree with a single subcategory of these.
Re:Four fears for authoritarians by hyperventilator on Thursday August 22, 2013 @11:40AM (#6257812)
I suppose you can defend giving someone jailtime for hurt feelings, but it sounds pretty stupid to me.
Re:Four fears for authoritarians by hahainternet on Thursday August 22, 2013 @12:21PM (#6258094)
Well I'll just go let all those victims of harassment know that it doesn't matter how they feel, hyperventilator has overridden them.
Re:Four fears for authoritarians by hyperventilator on Thursday August 22, 2013 @01:29PM (#6258553)
Yay, nanny state!