The "display your real name" Youtube pop-up is clearly designed to be misleading. The damn thing doesn't even have a "close" button. Nor does it have the option everybody wants to choose ("I'm not displaying my real name because I just don't want to").
I'm with you on this, I had no trouble with my accounts being associated until they decided it had to mean my real name appeared on youtube.
I understand why they do it given the state on comments there, but for me this is why I keep my account dissociated ever since (despite the stupid popup that keeps asking me the same question every couple of days).
Personally, I like commenting on really unseemly videos and only having an obscure username attached to it.