News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The NSA: ‘The Abyss from Which There Is No Return’ by scrrr on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:20AM (#6250427)
> And once the government starts operating outside the law, answerable to no one but itself, there’s no way to rein it back in, short of revolution.

Exactly. Or can somebody think of an example in history where a government gave up some of its rights? These sorts of authorisations (anti-terror laws and whatnot) don't go away, because they are too convenient for those in power.

Re:The NSA: ‘The Abyss from Which There Is No Return’ by jerf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:57AM (#6250730)
The British Isles have a long history of the government relatively painlessly surrendering and/or distributing bits of its power going back centuries. It of course also has some examples of it being done only painfully and with blood, but there's still multiple existence proofs there.

I don't think we've reached the point where this is out of the question per se. I do think it's pretty unlikely that we're going to be able to just extract out this particular bit of government, though. The only hope is a broad-based move in a libertarian direction. Plink just the NSA right now and adhoc combinations of other agencies will seamlessly move right in. To name one example, the DEA would happily step in to this sort of surveillance if the NSA wasn't there.

(I operate on a "direction" theory of voting. You don't have to be a libertarian right now to vote that way. You just have to think we have too much government right now. It's not a forever commitment. If we somehow finally reach "too little", feel free to vote for "bigger".)

Re:The NSA: ‘The Abyss from Which There Is No Return’ by CapitalistCartr on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:31AM (#6250521)
In the early Nineties the White government of South Africa conceded power to the Black African National Congress. At that time, they had made about six nukes, with the help of Israel, which they weren't willing to hand over to the new government, so they dismantled them and the whole program.
Re:The NSA: ‘The Abyss from Which There Is No Return’ by narrator on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @11:26AM (#6250977)
The Eastern Roman Empire gave up a lot of its power when they decentralized the military in favor of the "theme" system. Ironically, this reform was undertaken in order to more effectively combat the constant Islamic invasions that were taking place at the time (More at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theme_system).
Re:The NSA: ‘The Abyss from Which There Is No Return’ by trebor on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:53AM (#6250707)
And a revolution fighting against modern weaponry is practically guaranteed to fail. With the government constantly trying to restrict the citizens' access to weaponry there's no way to even make parody (pun intended) to hold the government accountable. Add to that the fact we've a standing military, something the Constitution never authorized, that's professionally trained. We've had problematic generals before but none of them tried to seize control of the country, yet.

If a revolution breaks out we aren't talking about a conflict the size of Syria's or Egypt's. We're probably talking about the biggest civil war ever, or a military coup. And the outcome of it (no matter if it worked or failed) would effectively gut the USA.

Tyranny is almost assured. We're on the bubble right now if the outcome hasn't already been decided (and we won't know except in hind-sight).

Re:The NSA: ‘The Abyss from Which There Is No Return’ by abawany on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @06:43PM (#6253800)
I hope that just partly like in Syria, the troops would eventually balk at killing their fellow citizens. However, I admit that such a possibility is less likely for armed forces that are engaging in war remotely.

*: I believe that at some point, the majority of Syrian resistance was formerly the Syrian army.

Re:The NSA: ‘The Abyss from Which There Is No Return’ by kaonashi on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @11:03AM (#6250789)
The security state received a nice trim back in the 70's. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_Committee
Re:The NSA: ‘The Abyss from Which There Is No Return’ by gizmo686 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @11:20AM (#6250930)
Ignoring the cases where the government was on the loosing side of a war, the only example I can think of is the American colonies, which voluntarily gave up power when they formed the union.
Re:The NSA: ‘The Abyss from Which There Is No Return’ by tomjen3 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @11:14AM (#6250867)
Cincinatti gave up his power to rule Rome absolutely as soon as his reason for becoming dictator ended, so there is that.