News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by rayiner on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:22AM (#6249372)
Absolutely ridiculous. There is no reason copyrights should be protected more strongly than traditional property rights. If I trespass on someone's land, it's not a felony. If I build a hotel on someone's land, it's still not a felony. The redress for copyright violations should be civil lawsuits, not criminal prosecutions.
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by mercurial on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:27AM (#6249393)
> There is no reason copyrights should be protected more strongly than traditional property rights.

There is one: lobbying.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by frank_boyd on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:10AM (#6249939)
Exactly. It really can't get any more obvious than that.

If we don't take money out of politics our country is going to go down for good.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by rayiner on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:13AM (#6249963)
You can blame the tech industry for this one. Criminalizing copyright infringement didn't get much traction until Microsoft, Oracle, etc, made a big deal about it in the context of large-scale piracy by the Chinese, etc.
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by tzs on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:06PM (#6252219)
There were criminal penalties for willful, for-profit performances of dramatic and music works in 1897 US copyright law. The 1909 act expanded this to all types of willful, for-profit infringement. I'm reasonably sure neither Microsoft nor Oracle had anything to do with this.
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by jlgreco on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:59PM (#6252175)
The DMCA was 1998. Wasn't that around the same time that Microsoft was getting hammered by the DOJ?

My impression is that the general consensus has that being about the time that Microsoft learned its lesson about ignoring lobbying. Maybe Oracle had something to do with it, but it seems like Microsoft probably missed that particular ship.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by Zoomla on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @11:24AM (#6250960)
Didn't that start with Disney?
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by nateabele on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:09PM (#6253332)
The only real way to get money out of politics is to stop allowing politics to have such a high return on investment. Unfortunately, that ship has probably sailed for good.
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by alan_cx on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:00AM (#6249549)
Don't Americans have guns to protect property? I suppose in fairness Disney cant run out and wave a gun at people downloading cartoons.

Yes, its disgustingly over the top, but then, what isn't these days?

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by rayiner on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:07AM (#6249914)
Generally, defense of property must be proportional to the harm threatened, and use of deadly force is not authorized: http://www.volokh.com/posts/1176499503.shtml (interesting blog post in the context of "hacking back").
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by hga on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:59AM (#6249860)
No, actually. Outside of Texas, the exception that proves the rule, you are not allowed to use lethal force to protect property.

As I understand Texas law (which I wouldn't surprise to find judicially nullified someday, like similar Oklahoma law), you are allowed to use lethal force on someone stealing your property after a verbal warning.

Which is in no way analogous to the point you're making. US law very much does not support "self-help" as its called to redress wrongs after the fact.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by jbooth on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:14AM (#6250389)
I'm pretty sure the castle doctrine applies in most states?

Hell, 'stand your ground' applies in a decent plurality of states these days.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by hga on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:39AM (#6250591)
Weak Castle Doctrine, no duty to retreat in your home, exists in 46 states according to Wikipedia, which sounds about right. E.g. assume you have to retreat from your home in Massachusetts, no matter the current law, case law or circumstances.

Stand Your Ground in 22 states. As in no duty to retreat any place you have a right to be, which prevents second guessing from the calm and comfort of a courtroom. Or as Oliver Wendell Holmes put it in the 1921 US Supreme Court case Brown v. United States, "Detached reflection cannot be demanded in the presence of an uplifted knife."

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by jbooth on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:47AM (#6250655)
"E.g. assume you have to retreat from your home in Massachusetts, no matter the current law, case law or circumstances."

Why?

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by hga on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:59AM (#6250749)
Because that's what the courts want very badly, at least as of the '80s. Several rounds of the solidly Democratic legislature passing "this time we mean it!" laws and the courts judicially nullifying as much as they could.

In one case I "watched" by reading the Boston Globe as it was tried, a man was sent to prison because he wasn't willing to leave his sleep daughter to the tender mercies of an home invader.

Too many people wonder why Michael Dukakis won only 10 states in 1988; not those of us in the the state who were paying attention to e.g. these judges he elevated to the bench.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by jbooth on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @11:56AM (#6251190)
In the 80s? It's 2013, man, get with the times and start ripping on Chicago.

In this decade, I'd go to the anecdote from WI last year of the dude who, upon a high school party being broken up by the cops next door, shot a kid hiding from the cops on his porch and wasn't charged.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by hga on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:49PM (#6252096)
I'm referring to the '80s because that was when I was residing in Massachusetts, and that was what I could look forward to if I used lethal force in self-defense. Also an automatic 1st degree murder trial, "Let the jury sort it out" was the AG's idea of prosecutorial discretion.

As for the Wisconson case you're referring to, the facts not surprisingly paint a very different picture. Per this news item: http://fox6now.com/2012/05/05/photos-of-bo-morrison-crime-sc... and others, the porch was only technically one, it was fully enclosed and furnished like an interior room, had an appliance (fridge/freezer?) and other indoor style stuff, and critically, from looking at the outside, it appears to be fully a part of the house. I say critically because the outdoor pictures make it very clear this can be legitimately scored as a home invasion, whatever friends and family of the deceased propagandize.

And per this from the shooter's wife, "[she] told investigators she heard her husband say, “What are you doing in my house” twice, then “Stay where you are” twice, and later a single shot was fired."

So only "weak", no duty to retreat (in 46 states) Castle Doctrine comes into play. He was not shot out of the blue or from behind, there was a confrontation, so as long as the couple have proper account of the story and the authorities don't catch them lying the failure to prosecute looks like its solid. Just like the Zimmerman/Martin was before it become a political show trial.

ADDED: Not surprisingly for a state that was until that year solid Blue, Wisconsin as of 2010 didn't have a strong Castle Doctrine, the case law explicitly says "The doctrine is for defensive and not offensive purposes."

When you hear "unbelievable" stories like this, you should be suspicious, they're generally unbelievable because they're flatly not true, except in the sense of Revolutionary Truth, which as techies we shouldn't approve of (our computers do not care about politics, just that 1 + 1 = 010).

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by jbooth on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:17PM (#6253052)
If we're being honest, the only reason to shoot the kid in that situation is because you've always hoped you'd get to shoot a home invader one day.
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by hga on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:42PM (#6253178)
A 20 year old "kid"???

Yes, he's in that awkward period between 18 and 21 where he's legally an adult who can't legally do a bunch of adult things, like the relevant posited drinking (according to the more detailed accounts I read he wasn't hiding from the police, the party was broken up by the incensed homeowner of the property where it was happening arriving), but if you're going to call young men who aren't even "teens" "kids", we have no basis for a discussion, we cannot get past your idée fixe that he was automatically an innocent.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by jbooth on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:01PM (#6253289)
Its Occam's razor -- if a house party full of underage drinkers just got busted, and a drunk 20 yo is hiding on your porch, do you personally think this is a flight or fight situation? Think this guy had a bit of an itchy trigger finger? Honest question.
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by cobrausn on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:54PM (#6251653)
I think he was referencing the events of the 80s because there was such a backlash to it that it led directly to events like you describe. The middle ground is dead.
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by hga on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:15PM (#6252278)
The backlash from the nation's "soft on crime" policies started much earlier, e.g. see Dirty Harry in 1971 and I gather Death Wish in 1974. Real world traction on reversing them, I think seriously started in the '80s.

But see my other reply in this sub-sub-thread: what middle ground is there between being forced by the law to retreat from your home and being allowed to use lethal force upon a reasonable apprehension of a sufficient threat? Do you really believe in allowing criminals to chase you out of your home, abandoning your loved ones who can't defend themselves?

It's ancient, ancient doctrine; per Wikipedia "The legal concept of the inviolability of the home has been known in Western Civilization since the age of the Roman Republic." When it comes to Western law you can't get older than the Twelve Tables in 450 BC (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twelve_Tables), in which I assume this was codified.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by cobrausn on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:10PM (#6253006)
No, I don't, but I was trying to clarify the statement. A middle ground for this is difficult, because it basically depends upon determining after the fact whether or not you or anyone else in the home was actually threatened (or whether you could reasonably perceive it that way).
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by hga on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:21PM (#6253070)
Errr, the latter is how these incidents are judged. E.g. the woman who recently ran down a man carrying a sawed off air soft shotgun; especially with the orange tip removed, she could not tell that he wasn't actually threatening in that way. Similarly, a criminal using a fake gun to commit a robbery gets a charge of armed or aggravated robbery.

This is determined after the fact all the time, presumably in the Wisconsin case, and definitely in the Zimmerman/Martin case before it was politicized.

Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by nnnnni on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:50AM (#6249813)
I'm pretty sure that not all states have castle laws, though.
Re:SOPA died in 2012, but Obama administration wants to revi... by hga on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:05AM (#6249902)
Castle laws pertain to "Your home is your castle", and maybe business. I'm not aware of any that touch on property, they just make it clear you have no duty to retreat from your home (ADDED: true in 46 states according to Wikipedia), and the better ones allow you assume a home invader is a lethal threat, as you can reasonably assume about anyone invading an occupied dwelling. Otherwise proving that could be lethal to you, e.g. challenging the intruder gets a bullet in reply.

Note as usual all this is subject to judicial nullification, in my home state of Missouri as of 2010 the latter part of our crystal clear Castle Doctrine has been nullified through middle level appeals court required jury instructions. Our higher level judicial appointments are not surprisingly done according to the Missouri Plan (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missouri_Plan), so the usual suspects control the process, not the people through their elected representatives.