Should I tell the founder his top employees are lazy and liars?
1. I'm an employee at a small agency (<10 of us).
2. I've been here almost a year. I've already seen a couple of raises and a promotion. I'm killing it and I sense my job is secure despite what I reveal to my employer. But who knows?
3. I discovered the most senior employee was charging a client for work that was never performed.
4. I let it go. I discovered this 6 months into the job and just wanted to play it safe. Nobody likes a snitch.
5. We ended up losing the client. I felt guilty for not speaking.
6. At almost a year in now, I've found that last month alone this individual is billing four clients for work that was also not performed. It makes me sick when I'm around this person.
7. I've recently discovered that the next most-senior employee is also charging three of their clients for work that is also not being completed.
8. In a recent private meeting with the founder, I informed him that I think people aren't doing their work. He said that was "distressing," sighed, and we continued discussing some other matters. He also said he'd like any other concerns brought to his attention whenever I felt I needed to raise them, his "door was always open," etc. I know he could sense I was wary about telling him anything too specific. I'm glad that he didn't push the matter at that time. This was about 3 weeks ago.
I have another meeting with the founder later this week. What should I say?
Integrity is one of the most valuable traits you can look for in people. Rather than worrying about the company so much, I'd be more concerned with yourself and how it reflects upon you being associated with this type of behaviour.
Just my 2 cents. Good luck!
While not incompetent, I do believe he's neglected his responsibility to properly evaluate the performance of his employees more closely.
Unless major changes happen quickly, you need to quit. Your salary is being paid with stolen money, and you cannot accept that.
What I'd do:
- Give up any idea of continuing to work for that agency; you might come out of it smelling like roses, but you might get fired as well. Accept that acting ethically might cost you your job, and act on that assumption. Also, remember that being fired for acting ethically is, in the long run, an act of mercy: you don't want to be associated with crooks.
- Put your complaint in writing, with details. Names, dates, amounts, clients, anything & everything you can remember. Give it to the founder, and explain that you'd like something done about it.
- Repeat the previous step a few times. If nothing happens, tender your resignation. Again: do you want to work for crooks?
- If resignation is necessary (or, if you're fired), then go to the clients and present them with the very same written complaint you presented to the founder. Be aware that being sued by the agency is a very real possibility should that happen.
I wouldn't put those type of accusations in writing.
E.g. "oh yeah, that guy: I fired him for poor performance." How would you prove otherwise without a paper trail?
Now there are a few different ways to break the ice. I would start with something positive as most people don't like starting a discussion with conflicts. Maybe tell him about how you're excited about your work, because seeing clients happy and satisfied gives a sense of purpose and achievement, while strengthening the company brand. At the same time, you've noticed (and it pains you) that other projects are not being delivered, and causing clients to be lost, and the company looking bad. Share some evidence (a.k.a facts) that brought you to this conclusion, and if possible a way for his to double check. From there I'd play it by ear depending how the conversation is going. One thing to keep in mind however, is to see whether he knows already or not... if he does approve of such practices, then it's probably not a place you want to work at. Good luck :)
I will certainly bring evidence. The type of work not completed can still be audited by the founder. This indeed will be crucial in his realization of the issue.
Thank you very much.
The founder is fortunately technically versed enough that he should be capable of an audit of the work conducted by his employees. However, I think he's clueless to what's going on at the moment. He's an awesome guy and his heart is in the right place, but he's much more sales-oriented and concerned with bringing in business than he is with auditing the performance of his employees. Unfortunately. I believe he is indeed too busy with with other things to see this and I think he thinks everything is going well in terms of operations (despite my vague alert). That said, business was booming several months ago and he was not concerned at all about money then. These past couple months have been poor though.
It could be that the founder keeps himself officially "unaware" on purpose. This way he can shift the blame to others if it becomes public, and still make a profit from defrauding clients.
If he is truly unaware, you will still be up against two senior employees who will deny the accusations - and you may end up looking like the "crazy disruptive new guy".
I would suggest gathering as much documentation as you can on the excessive billing. Then approaching him without directly accusing the senior employees, and pitching it as a way to improve the business. "I have figured out why the clients left, we made mistakes on their bills!" instead of "Your senior people are defrauding clients".
If the founder seems to be unconcerned about the "mistakes", start looking for a new job.
But give him another chance. Address the issues you noted, and see if he cares. If you think he's a good person, you probably can explain the importance of keeping good relations and making sure that customers are satisfied (and if he disagrees, you probably should leave)
All of the over-billing is coming from supposed ongoing work (and of course not a retainer situation). It doesn't happen in any initial phase where it would be difficult to fake something.
The agency is small enough that we all have access to each other's client hours, invoice information, etc. and we often correspond directly with clients regarding their invoices, etc.
tell him from a business perspective so he can really understand. explain, how fixing this will save/make more money if not immediately in the future.
If you stay it will damage your reputation.