Re:Court Holds That Circumventing IP Address Ban Is “Access ...
by iopq on Sunday August 18, 2013 @11:24PM
(#6235442)
So you're saying that when my IP changes and I visit a website I was banned from I should be in prison?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Court Holds That Circumventing IP Address Ban Is “Access ...
by anigbrowl on Monday August 19, 2013 @12:26AM
(#6235616)
The penalty rather depends on why you were banned in the first place. If you deliberately violated the ban then it's equivalent to trespass, notwithstanding the publicly accessible nature of websites.
It's not that I love Craiglist particularly, but the fact is that their website remains their private property, same as any other commercial establishment. They have no obligation to serve people who don't respect their policies.
Re:Court Holds That Circumventing IP Address Ban Is “Access ...
by iopq on Monday August 19, 2013 @03:14AM
(#6236018)
Look, I've avoided bans on many websites on purpose. You're saying this should be a criminal act? If I get banned from Hacker News, and I make a second account using a proxy, I should get prison time?
Re:Court Holds That Circumventing IP Address Ban Is “Access ...
by phaemon on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:05AM
(#6236521)
> Look, I've avoided bans on many websites on purpose. You're saying this should be a criminal act?
Yeah, I'd say so. They're not your servers. If the person who owns them tells you to stop using them, then stop. They don't owe you anything, so just quit using their stuff. Easy, no?
> If I get banned from Hacker News, and I make a second account using a proxy, I should get prison time?
Why didn't you just go all out and say "the death penalty"? :-) No, I'd think a fine or some community service would be more than adequate.