News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reshaping New York by rayiner on Saturday August 17, 2013 @04:00PM (#6230186)
I think the majority of New Yorkers support his policies. He has basically engaged in a massive gentrification of the city. This has pushed poor people (many of them minorities) out of Manhattan and even Queens and Brooklyn, has led to higher housing prices, tearing down of "historic" buildings, etc. As a result, there are tons of people who hate him for these things. But I think the core demographic of upper middle class Manhattanites generally supports these policies.

As an aside: I was watching a documentary about Giuliani (then U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York) the other day. It was about how in the early 1980's he led a full-scale attack on the Mafia, by bugging the cars and houses of the heads of the five families and using the collected evidence along with the RICO Act to send them to prison. Apparently, after being indicted one of the bosses (Paul Castellano) was assassinated just a few blocks away from where my office was in Midtown. Today, that whole area is basically Disneyland. It is crazy how different New York is today than how it used to be. Last year, My wife used to stroll all over Manhattan with our daughter, often late at night waiting for me to get out of work, without any worry at all.

Re:Reshaping New York by icambron on Saturday August 17, 2013 @06:29PM (#6230587)
> He has basically engaged in a massive gentrification of the city.

Can you elaborate on that? Specifically in what policies Bloomberg supports that have led to gentrification.

I ask because often gentrification is an effect of making a city a nicer place to live. Better public transit, lower crime, better schools, etc. Rich people move in and outbid poor incumbent residents for their apartments. But tearing down historic houses is a signal in the other direction: the city is building new, bigger buildings to house all of those rich people moving in, thus taking price pressure off the incumbents and preventing gentrification. It's hard to simultaneously hold the ideas -- as "tons of people" apparently do -- of "I want to keep New York historic" and "I'm against gentrification" without also thinking, "I'm against making the city nicer". Unless, I guess, those are different people hating on Bloomberg from different directions? Or he's causing gentrification in some other way that I don't understand?

Re:Reshaping New York by busterarm on Saturday August 17, 2013 @06:35PM (#6230607)
I don't know specifically what the other poster was referring to, but traditionally the Landmarks Preservation Commission hasn't given a shit about 'historic' buildings in the outer boroughs unless they can preserve an entire district. I think to get a clear answer you'd have to make sure we're all using the same definition of historic.

There are definitely buildings that have been torn down for new construction that debatably should have been preserved. A lot of the area around Astoria Park has been demolished for new highrise construction that has mostly not been completed due to market events. Not only are these a blight on the neighborhood but they tore down some absolutely fantastic sites to put them there. Specifically in Astoria Village.

The neighborhood, though mostly safe, has been in a shit state for decades due to neglect from the city and housing projects from the 60s.

[1] http://forgotten-ny.com/1999/05/astoria-village-part-1-queen...

[2] http://forgotten-ny.com/2005/06/astoria-village-part-2-queen...

[3] http://forgotten-ny.com/2007/12/astoria-village-part-3-queen...

Re:Reshaping New York by icambron on Saturday August 17, 2013 @07:17PM (#6230723)
Right, so that's the kind of thing I'm talking about. I don't know anything specific about Astoria Village, but if rich people want to live there (and presumably they do, or else the real estate developers who wanted to build there were incompetent), then they'll move in one way or another. And with historic Astoria being relatively low-density, they'll displace the existing residents by bidding up rent prices. Unless there's a bunch of new construction.

I have no doubt that there are buildings that are of enough historical importance that they shouldn't be demolished to build high rises (i.e. that marginal bit of rent pressure is worth it). I also don't know if in this particular case -- especially given that they weren't completed due to a housing crash -- building high rises ended up being wise; sometimes developers are foolish or shit just happens. And perhaps those things really are all that happened in Astoria; I couldn't say. My point, though, still holds in the general case and certainly holds for something the size of NYC as a whole: preserving historical buildings is fundamentally in tension with preventing gentrification. It's a tradeoff.

(And it's a bit of an odd one too: the people who care and should care the most about the historic value of a neighborhood are the people who actually live there. But if constrained housing supply forces them to move, they won't be around to enjoy it anyway.)

This is a big issue for me because this exact conversation is happening in my neighborhood in Cambridge, MA, which keeps very strong control over new construction. Rent is skyrocketing with people like me moving in to a poorer minority neighborhood because it's nice and we like it. Developers see that as a market opportunity and the city should see it as a signal to allow more construction to reduce rents. But many (most?) of the residents oppose new construction on the grounds that it will change the neighborhood's feel and, incorrectly, that it will cause gentrification. It will certainly do the former, but it will help prevent the latter.

Re:Reshaping New York by bradleyjg on Saturday August 17, 2013 @07:27PM (#6230754)
I'm with you. The occasional building is fine, but this business with whole neighborhoods gets out of hand. The landmark commission recently created a landmark district in the east village. The east village is an ugly neighborhood of undistinguished walk up buildings. It's no historic Penn Station, that's for sure.

The justification was that it was historically important because generations of immigrants had moved through the area. Generations of immigrants had moved through the area, because at the time it was built it was high density housing, and so was affordable. So to honor that history we are going to keep in as a museum that no one can afford to live in. Brilliant!

Re:Reshaping New York by busterarm on Saturday August 17, 2013 @07:35PM (#6230793)
That's for damn sure!

I still get a chuckle at how the former Mars Bar's upstairs residents got such a sweet deal got their fancy new apartments for $10.

http://ny.curbed.com/archives/2013/06/18/jupiter_21_launches...

I don't mind this though. That old bar was a f'in dump and the rest of the block with it.

Re:Reshaping New York by driverdan on Sunday August 18, 2013 @05:48PM (#6234380)
I don't see anything worth preserving in those photos. Maybe the triangle building. The homes are just like the rest from that period you'll find in the northeast, nothing particularly noteworthy.

I don't understand why people think they should be able to tell owners what to do with their property. Don't like it? Buy it yourself.

Re:Reshaping New York by paddy_m on Saturday August 17, 2013 @09:40PM (#6231228)
Building new bigger buildings is the only way to lower the cost of living in the city. There is a massive shortage of realestate in the city. Build more and build it faster.
Re:Reshaping New York by icambron on Sunday August 18, 2013 @12:25AM (#6231640)
Or making the city a worse place to live.
Re:Reshaping New York by asveikau on Saturday August 17, 2013 @04:09PM (#6230212)
> Today, that whole area is basically Disneyland.

I am sure lots of entities public and private have contributed to and accelerated this situation, but we must also keep in mind the nationwide trends in violent crime in the last few decades. I think this sets the stage more than any particular mayor, police chief, development company etc. can do.

Re:Reshaping New York by rayiner on Saturday August 17, 2013 @04:15PM (#6230234)
There has also been a nationwide trend of aggressive policing and aggressive prosecution with statutes like RICO, largely pioneered by the work of people like Giuliani in New York. Abstract trends of decreasing crime didn't break the Mafia...
Re:Reshaping New York by busterarm on Saturday August 17, 2013 @04:31PM (#6230288)
And the Mafia has largely been involved in white-collar crime (stock scams like pump & dumps, running boiler rooms, etc) since at least the early 80s. The Mafia hasn't really had much impact in violent crime statistics in an incredibly long time.
Re:Reshaping New York by enraged_camel on Saturday August 17, 2013 @04:27PM (#6230275)
It is important to understand that violent crime is one of the many tools at Mafia's disposal. You could be living in a New York today that does have Mafia but similar levels of crime.
Re:Reshaping New York by mc32 on Saturday August 17, 2013 @05:07PM (#6230380)
While true, how does this explain Chicago and Detroit?

I think there are general trends but local policies (and lack of such) contribute to direction.

I think if Koch or Dinkins had been mayors for the times Giuliani and Bloomberg were mayors, crime stats would be noticeably different --less than mid 90s, but higher than today. Of course, that's just speculation.