People do choose to install Adobe Flash into their varied browsers, and they do so successfully and rapidly. It is a real capability in the world today.
For every authoritarian iPhone sold, there are forty-odd Flash-enabled phones sold. Not ubiquity yet, but we're getting there.
Browser vendors could indeed improve plugin communication for things like prefs-setting, cookie-blocking and so on. Instead Opera, Mozilla, Apple and Google are on a dysfunctional goosechase with VIDEO.
<em>"If your web app requires some plugin you WILL lose at least a small part of your target audience."</em> That's true. But it will be more accessible than requiring a browser update, or change in browser brands.
Browser plugins let people choose their favorite browser brand, without losing functionality to other brands of browser. It's cross-browser functionality. Plugins enfranchise minority audiences, and makes it easier for minority browser vendors to compete.
jd/adobe
I'm sure you hope they're chasing wild geese, but from where I'm sitting, almost all Flash usage on the web, weighted by user volume, falls into two categories: that requiring video, and that which web browsers can already do pretty well without plug-ins. Thus once browsers have semi-decent video support, much of the need for Flash on the web will disappear.
If you're holding onto a lot of Adobe options, you might want to hope a little harder about that goose-chase thing. As for me, I'm betting on the browsers and genuinely open standards: so far, that duo has slowly crushed everything else.
Gotta love those disruptive technologies.
There are many technology-oriented and societal reasons to prefer an "open" web. The fact is that the AIR-reader delivers today what is likely to appear in browsers over the next couple of years.
- Users must install and maintain an additional piece.
- Less likely to work in all environments (mobile phone, etc.)
- Plugins bypass the authentication mechanisms built into browsers. Maintaining session currency requires sharing information between browser and the plugin - extra work to develop and many Flash/Silverlight/etc. developers just don't bother.
- Plugins may provide an additional vector for malware. They may not be harder to secure than native browser stuff but you have to worry about two things. E.g. Flash cross-site scripting attacks.
- Requires more than one set of development tools (e.g. Firebug can't see inside Flash or Silverlight objects on a page)
- Unnecessary most of the time: E.g., a lot of common Flash animation can be done equally well with native browser techniques like Javascript, CSS...
- Future browser technologies will make plugins even less necessary: e.g. Flash was probably the best option when YouTube came out but when HTML 5 starts to take over the video and audio tags may make it superfluous.
If your web app requires some plugin you WILL lose at least a small part of your target audience - Silverlight more than Flash. If you don't absolutely have to have the functionality a plugin gives you, why short-change yourself like that?