Ooh -- can I make silly generalizations, as well?
My personal favorite theory about why iOS makes more revenue in the app store, is that more Android users wildly mash at their phone screens with their giant, greasy potato-chip-dust-covered fingers in a Monster energy drink-induced aggro-fog and so are mostly unable to either understand or properly use their device well enough to access an app store and install stuff.
Or. Maybe people have different tastes for different reasons. And maybe the cherry-picked single data point that Final Fantasy III (which seems to have not sold very well at all) happened to be more popular on Android devices doesn't really mean much of anything conclusive (the PDF you linked to certainly doesn't have much to say about it). Maybe there are more "whales" on iOS simply because more users are comfortable using the platform and downloading apps, and given that app phones are damned near ubiquitous, both platforms will have smart-and-savvy users and rich (or poor or middle-class) "idiots." And everything in between.
Going back to iOS devices, they provide a simple filter. People who buy them pay more, and they are therefore likely to pay more again. It really says nothing about their income or credit card balance. It is purely about spending habits.
(I certainly feel this. Ubuntu/Android suits me, but if I'd held my nose and bought an apple toolchain (mac->phone) 5 years ago I probably would be better off today.)
I would have an easier time accepting this were it phrased differently. Are these people really idiots, or are they just vulnerable consumers? To draw a comparison, are alcoholics "idiots" or are they just vulnerable to alcohol? I believe that science tells us that is it the latter. To apply this, I'd be more likely to say:
"iOS makes more revenue in the app store because no average it's users are more susceptible to pressure to spend money."
It would be like two towns where one makes much more money in their restaurants, and boasts about their rich and discerning clientel and how the other town is full of people who can't appreciate good food, or are simply cheap etc. Very much making value judgements about people based on the size of the revenues.
But when you look into it, the vast majority of the money is spent on alchohol, and a fair portion of that is spent by people with drinking problems, which is encouraged by the restaurant owners.
You can and should feel sorry for those people, and angry at the people taking advantage of them, but in terms of disrupting the previous, and widely accepted, storyline of "connoisseurs of fine dining" the temptation to call them a town of winos is too much, for me at least.
(apps = food, games = alcohol in this terrible analogy. And I suppose these new breed of psychologically exploitative games are like caffeine-infused cocktails designed to get you messed up quickly or bars that encourage such drinking)
This is a good point. I knew a guy who would probably classify as a whale. He made about 40k and because of his spending habbits was effectively quite poor.
Nobody said they are lesser people. But iOS does sell to the richer demographics, the same way the Mac laptops are bought by richer and more urban demographics.
(Also: "idiots", really? Actually being richer makes it more common for them to have university education).
Plus, besides the guys only go for "open" and "tinkering", most of the other tech savvy users go for iOS. Where by tech savvy I don't mean hackers but people more likely to buy and use lots of apps, as opposed to just buying an occasional game or utility.
Sone example demographics: most people that care about mobile photography tend to buy iOS (and almost all books and projects done by amateur/pro photographers on a mobile phone, have been done with iPhones). Almost all people that care about mobile music (e.g synths, audio recorders, guitar amp emulations, et) buy iOS. Almost all mobile video projects I've seen were done on iOS, etc etc.
PS: I already had google wallet set up due to previously using it to pay for something from my desktop.
That Wired article is similarly ridiculous - I find it exceedingly hard to believe that people who spend $6000 on alcohol in one night and have to replace this inane habit with equally obscene in-app purchases aren't just outliers. They're also not indicative of any real substantial user-base.
What I'm trying to get at here is that your favorite theory is completely unsupported as written. It's a gross oversimplification, generalization, and it's potentially insulting.
If this theory makes you feel better about your choice of platform, then bully for you. Just be aware of its implications.
Now, I'm perhaps not serious about that, and I'm just reacting to the tone of "Android users are lesser people" that's been prevalent recently. But I will note that according to this report:
http://www.distimo.com/publications/archive/Distimo%20Public...
A $15.99 Final Fantasy game from Square-Enix made 73% of it's revenue from Android in May 2013 while the "free" Candy Crush Saga and Simpsons: Tapped Out games made much more money from iOS.
These "free" games are apparently designed around "Whales", people who spend literally thousands of dollars on them:
http://www.wired.com/gamelife/2012/11/meet-the-whales/all/
"Lee says that spending money on games like Clash of Clans is actually saving him money in the long-run: Before he started gaming, he says he and a small group of friends would go out drinking, sometimes spending as much as $6,000 in a single night between them."
"He wound up spending nearly $5,000 in that game before trading it for Clash of Clans, but says that’s far less than what he would have otherwise spent on alcohol.
“I actually save money playing these games instead of going out and drinking,” he said.
...
"Vince P., who also asked us to withhold his last name, has been playing the Facebook game Battle Pirates since early 2011. His total spend: over $16,000.
“It does kind of shock me, for sure, that it was that much,” said Vince, who goes by the username “Spoon” in Battle Pirates. “And it’s all for nothing.”
Vince is 45 years old, divorced, with a 16-year-old daughter. He says he makes between $200,000 and $400,000 annually. He looked positively distraught over the situation during a Skype interview with Wired, as he tabulated a list of his receipts."
It's my semi-serious theory that these people, at least in the US, are more likely to own iOS devices.