> Additionally, I think people who care can be quite contentious.
People who care will challenge the status quo. This is often deeply unpopular, especially in larger orgs. If you don't empower the people who care to make positive changes to the status quo, then those people will give up and stop caring. And then probably leave.
Specifically I don't think points 3 and 4 are quite on the money - how much you care is often based on how much you perceive people care about you, and equity can be a pretty big signal of that. Additionally, I think people who care can be quite contentious.
Still, a good enough point to talk about. Apparent enthusiasm is one of the best things you can select for, when you see it, and it can make up for a lot of other things that might be lacking.