News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No, really—consciousness is worth thinking about by seiji on Sunday August 11, 2013 @07:57PM (#6196928)
So neurons fire and we see this pattern of activity in a state of wakefulness ... well, okay but WHY?

We see ones and zeroes go into our ALU and the result is an operating system. Okay, but WHY?

Or, we see two molecules joining... and the result is a human baby! Okay, but WHY?

You can't necessarily see the entire outside system from micro-components.

Re:No, really—consciousness is worth thinking about by lmm on Monday August 12, 2013 @06:52AM (#6198573)
>We see ones and zeroes go into our ALU and the result is an operating system. Okay, but WHY? >Or, we see two molecules joining... and the result is a human baby! Okay, but WHY?

Right, but we can answer those questions. We can explain how the high-level OS is written in lower-level primitives, how these correspond to machine instructions, and how those correspond to electrical impulses. You wouldn't say "oh yeah, an OS is just electrical pulses firing, there's nothing you don't already understand here", or "oh, you understand basic organic chemistry, now you understand all animals".

I'm not saying there's anything mystical to it, but there's this great big chunk that we don't understand yet, and saying "oh it's all electrical impulses" doesn't really shed any light on that.