News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @12:05PM (#6195251)
I have been a VLC user on Windows for years. I've actually stuck with VLC 1.1.5 for 2 reasons:

1. It plays any local video I throw at it. Other people tell me "It doesn't play some of my videos" but I haven't seen this actually occur. Or when I do, it's because they're using a newer version of VLC which has removed support or changed processing. VLC has terrible license problems and awful feature creep. I had some .mkv files which didn't play correctly, so I downgraded from 1.1.10 to 1.1.5, and they play just fine. That's right, the 3-year old player plays the newest .mkv files much better than the 2-year old player or the newest player.

And unlike mplayer, mplayer2, wmp, and most other players out there, you don't have to goto some random website and download some random codec pack, and install it with who knows what malware.</FUD> All the codecs are included with the program.

Reading this github doesn't tell me why I should use mpv instead of vlc 1.1.5. Actually, it tells me I'll have to go find these random codec packs again, opening myself to possible CSRF attacks and other malware from poorly-secured or malicious codec providers. I'm already trusting the media player install package to not be evil, and I'd rather only have to trust 1 install package instead of it and several codec install packages.

2. I actually downgraded from VLC 2.0 to 1.1.10 because of VLC's terrible responsiveness. I don't know what changed, but it has made VLC 2.0 too annoying to use. The delay is a second or 2, which is a second or 2 longer than it used to be, and a second or 2 longer than it needs to be. When I go from a quiet video to a loud video, and I roll the mousewheel to lower the volume, that volume change needs to happen immediately, not after a 1-2 second delay.

I like that responsiveness is one of the bullet points.

I would have downloaded it and tried it out, but I don't know how to make this on Windows.

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by w1ntermute on Sunday August 11, 2013 @01:51PM (#6195554)
> And unlike mplayer, mplayer2, wmp, and most other players out there, you don't have to goto some random website and download some random codec pack, and install it with who knows what malware.</FUD> All the codecs are included with the program.

You're absolutely right to tag that as FUD, because I have never had to download "random codecs" from "random codec packs" in order to get videos to play in MPlayer on Linux (I don't know how it is on Windows).

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by pkj on Sunday August 11, 2013 @02:08PM (#6195607)
>never had to download "random codecs" from "random codec packs"

Second that. I have had videos which couldn't be played on VLC (codecs or missing frames) play nicely with mplayer. Easily the best versatile player, especially if you are conversant with the command line options ( or take a quick look at man page).

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by userulluipeste on Monday August 12, 2013 @06:48AM (#6198566)
At least some time ago, for Windows there was a (main) installer that included the player and the most used codecs, and there also was available an additional package with the uncommon codecs. This is what I've got after a quick search: http://data.netfast.org/downloadse.html
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @02:28PM (#6195677)
mplayer and mplayer2 use the Windows codec libraries.

Playing a video usually means having to learn about codec packs like ffdshow from Google searches and random internet forums, and then finding the legitimate website for the codec pack (not a linkspam site or a rehosting company like cnet who bundle Ask toolbar into the installer), then locating and downloading the codec pack on the (sometimes intentionally) badly designed website, and giving it blanket permission to alter files on your hdd.

I don't want this to become a fanboy flamewar, but the above process is time consuming, technically difficult & also requires a broad and complex network of social trusts. Whereas VLC "just works", well at least the older versions.

---

I don't know where my responses would lead a media player developer. I don't like licensed codecs, but I understand that encoding groups will use the codecs which work best; illegally if necessary since encoding tv & movies for free downloading are all still legal and moral grey-areas. And I know people want to be paid for their art which others have demand for. And free media player developers don't want to pay to license codecs when they gain no benefit over just supporting whatever codec libraries the OS has installed.

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by lotyrin on Sunday August 11, 2013 @04:00PM (#6196111)
Are you thinking of Media Player Classic? Mplayer/Mplayer2 use their own bundled ffmpeg as VLC does.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @04:18PM (#6196175)
...I thought mplayer was media player classic...
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by w1ntermute on Sunday August 11, 2013 @04:51PM (#6196281)
There is absolutely no connection between the two. Media Player Classic is an open-source imitation of the "classic" UI of Windows Media Player, and is only for Windows and was originally closed-source (but is now GPLed). MPlayer is an open-source cross-platform media player that doesn't have a default GUI.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by asperous on Sunday August 11, 2013 @04:30PM (#6196210)
You should edit your post then, mplayer is completely different. It plays tons of formats, and is my personal favorite media player.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @04:45PM (#6196257)
It's too old to edit.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by xiaomai on Sunday August 11, 2013 @02:47PM (#6195762)
None of what you are saying about mplayer has been true for years. And it has never been necessary to download codec packs for mplayer2.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by seagreen on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @11:39PM (#6209812)
Just wanted to let you know that this comment of yours from last year was a huge help: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4476649

Thanks!

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by xiaomai on Thursday August 15, 2013 @04:41PM (#6220449)
Oh thanks! That's always nice to hear.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by SimHacker on Sunday August 11, 2013 @12:33PM (#6195323)
VLC may play lot of videos, but it has the most systematically terrible user interface of any program I have ever seen. Just absolutely horrible, on a level that could not possibly just the results of ignorance and carelessness, but it actually seems to optimized to actively fuck the user on purpose.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @12:50PM (#6195366)
Uh...what?

The UI is plain, but all of the controls I regularly need are there. And I ABSOLUTELY LOVE that every hotkey is rebindable. If you don't like "change subtitles" to be V, you can change it to be P or even Alt-V. (Why can't we rebind Windows Copy to be Alt-W instead of Ctrl-C?)

And last I checked, the UI can be skinned too, but I grew up with plain interfaces.

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by SimHacker on Sunday August 11, 2013 @01:48PM (#6195547)
So why does it have one set of controls in window mode, and a totally different set of controls in full screen mode? Who decided that?
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @03:09PM (#6195847)
I don't know -- I'm using a 3 year old version where the windowed and fullscreen controls are almost the same. (the only difference is fullscreen doesn't have "shuffle" or "playlist")
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by coldtea on Sunday August 11, 2013 @02:42PM (#6195745)
The same guy who did the same for Quicktime and tons of other programs back in the day...
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by barrkel on Sunday August 11, 2013 @02:51PM (#6195778)
You're quite right. It's almost unusable on Windows in its default configuration.

I particularly like how difficult it is to toggle full-screen playback with the keyboard. F11 makes it full screen, but doesn't hide the controls. Ctrl-H hides the controls, but also disables keyboard shortcuts!

So now, when you want to get out of full-screen mode, you have to know that you need to press Esc followed by F11. Not even double-click gets you back to windowed mode.

This kind of asymmetric mode toggling drives me up the walls. That, and the fact it doesn't pause when you click the video.

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @03:08PM (#6195841)
This must be some new weird change with the most recent version. The version I use has F as the fullscreen button, and either F or ESC will exit fullscreen. And the controls auto-hide.

That's why I stick to the 1.1.5 version!

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by barrkel on Sunday August 11, 2013 @08:07PM (#6196956)
No, F11 is the only way documented in the menu to get full-screen playback. F is not documented anywhere in the player UI; instead, it's buried away in the keybinding section of the preferences. The whole point of showing accelerators in the menu is to enable keyboard shortcuts for frequent commands to be learned; that VLC doesn't do this consistently is, alone, an indictment of its UI.

F11 and Alt-Enter are generally the two idioms for getting full-screen behaviour on Windows. Both work in Media Player Classic. Alt-Enter comes from the old DOS box from Windows 3; I'm not sure, but I think IE 4 pioneered F11. In any case, F11 works with Firefox, Chrome and IE; Alt-Enter also works with IE, Mintty, etc.

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by drummer32 on Sunday August 11, 2013 @04:33PM (#6196222)
Nop. 2.0.5 here (2.0.8 is the latest) and f works just fine. I guess barrkel had enough time to whine on a forum but not enough to look in the program's preferences.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by SimHacker on Monday August 12, 2013 @05:25AM (#6198365)
OK, perhaps I was too harsh saying that VLC had the most systematically terrible user interface of any program I have ever seen. I had forgotten about The Gimp. They are both suffering from the same kind of pathological user interface problems that seem to result from a pretentious and cliquish committified developer community whose individual members each care much more about overdeveloping their particular paroquial corners of the applications than how it all fits together as a whole, and who religiously refuse to even consider looking at competing commercial products because to expose themselves to any non-open-source software would make them impure and suck out all their precious bodily fluids. But at least VLC's name wasn't chosen for the express purpose of being bigoted and obnoxious and repelling ordinary mainstream users, under the false pretense of being whimsically humorous and self deprecating like Git.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by ciupicri on Sunday August 11, 2013 @12:47PM (#6195359)
What's so horrible about it? It looks like most media players. The playlist could use some love, but if you're only playing a single (long) video at a time it doesn't matter to much.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @12:53PM (#6195378)
The playlist actually has a lot of options which are randomly buried in the settings. You can change settings so double-clicking a video file just adds it to the end of the playlist. Or you can make every new video open in its own new player. Like I said, feature creep is one of VLC's biggest problems.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by SimHacker on Sunday August 11, 2013 @02:01PM (#6195586)
Some but not all of the changes I make to the configuration (like key bindings in particular) don't take effect until I restart VLC. What the fuck???

http://forums.logitech.com/t5/G-Series-Gaming-Keyboards/G19-...

"In VLC, as of 1.1.11, you have to go to interface, preferences, hotkeys, and doubleclick the GLOBAL hotkey you need to set. Press the media key on the keyboard, and it'll return but will act like nothing changed. Click "Apply" and it should show you the media key identification of the key you pressed. Once you have setup all your keys, save, and completely exit and restart VLC."

For me, on both Mac and Windows, VLC key bindings fail to take effect until I restart it (any key bindings, not just global media hotkeys), and many options simply don't get saved at all. I have to hand edit the configuration text file. Ridiculous.

http://forum.videolan.org/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=91154

"Saving can fail. And sometimes it can even output corrupted file."

http://forum.videolan.org/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=13340

"As for saving, make sure you click 'Save' on the options dialog. OK applies them without saving, while Save applies and saves them."

Yes I am pressing the "Save" button. There is no "OK" button, and if there was both an OK and a Save button, that would still be a terrible user interface design.

Basic simple things like that just don't work. Maybe my preferences file keeps getting corrupted, but that should NOT happen, ever. At least it should give me an error message instead of just silently losing. Shameful.

Then there's the way it decides to resize the playlist window really big for no reason at all. Why can't the playlist window just stay the same size?

It crashes all the time, and then when I restart it, it ALWAYS asks if I want to report the last crash to the development team. No I don't, and I also don't want it to ask me that every fucking time. I just want it to shut the fuck up and play a video. Of course there is no option I can find to turn off that annoying modal pop-up dialog. A not-terribly-designed user interface would have a checkbox on the annoying modal dialog that says "Never ask me this ever again", and I wouldn't have to go through an unsuccessful wild goose chase through the millions of advanced options searching for a way to turn that dialog off.

The simple preference user interface has checkbox options to disable video and audio. What's the point of that? In fact, those are the first options in the video and audio sections! Who would ever want to disable video or audio in a video player? You already have a volume and mute control, and you can disable video and audio tracks from the menus. So why is that the first option in the simple preferences user interface? Was there a huge demand from novice users for that option? Terrible user interface design.

There are many other things about the UI design that are extremely annoying, a lot having to do with the out of control feature creep and totally uncoordinated committee design. All those advanced options, yet there is no way to set it to always show advanced options every time. Isn't it ironic that it has millions of options, but no option to always show the millions of options by default? Or maybe it's just failing to save the "advanced mode" option. So lame.

It gives me the distinct impression that nobody on the development team gives a shit.

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @04:32PM (#6196218)
I had a problem similar to the one you described, but it went away when I moved backwards to VLC 1.1.5. I think 1.1.10/1.1.11 was just a very buggy release, as mkv playback is also broken on that version.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by Gormo on Sunday August 11, 2013 @08:45PM (#6197064)
Those are "options buried in the settings", quite the opposite of "feature creep". You've got to enable them, and doing so makes the application behave thew way that you want it to, and not be confined to the default configuration.

The programs that have a problem are the ones that dumb-down the UI to the point that it's impossible to deviate from the defaults.

Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by sitkack on Monday August 12, 2013 @02:39AM (#6197963)
It is the iTunes of the open source media world. An abomination, at least it isn't as bad as Calibre.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by oijaf888 on Sunday August 11, 2013 @12:57PM (#6195402)
Are all the codecs that VLC ships with freely redistributable? I was under the impression that many required licensing agreements even to distribute for free which impedes open source projects without a corporate backing from doing so.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by stephengillie on Sunday August 11, 2013 @01:06PM (#6195434)
AFAIK, they're not, which is one of the reasons that newer versions of VLC have problems playing videos which play fine on older versions -- because the license-requiring codecs have been removed, and only sometimes replaced by free codecs or workarounds.
Re:mpv - a free and open-source general-purpose video player by bloopletech on Monday August 12, 2013 @01:18AM (#6197773)
Does VLC 1.1.5 support HI10P (10-bit H.264 video)? That would be one reason to upgrade, as many anime releases now use HI10P (http://wiki.bakabt.me/index.php/Hi10P).