How is EC “relatively untested/unproven”? It's been in OpenSSL for ages (by internet norms), is the subject of numerous national standards. It secures a billion dollar bitcoin economy.
Re:The Factoring Cryptopocalypse
by redthrowaway on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:31PM
(#6193578)
He said it's not time for the average programmer to switch to a new and untested ECC implementation, not that ECC itself is new and untested. By the standards of any of the common RSA libraries out there, their ECC counterparts would be relatively untested given how much comparative use each has seen.
For what it's worth, Tom Ritter recently posted his notes on de-anonymizing alt.anonymous.messages[1], something widely believed to be very anonymous and very secure. It's an interesting read and shows why you not only need the crypto to be sound, but the implementation and your own use of it to be right too.
[1] - http://ritter.vg/blog-deanonymizing_amm.html