Amazon vs. Walmart is an extremely interesting battle to watch. Amazon has massive advantages in technology; Walmart has massive advantages in size, distribution, and logistics. Amazon is gaining a lot of ground in the US; Walmart is much stronger than Amazon internationally.
If I had to place bets, I'd take Amazon in the long run. They're much more forward thinking and are playing a much more strategic game. Walmart has become overly reliant on price leadership and has had a very hard time orienting toward the future of retail. The Innovator's Dilemma will catch up to it eventually -- but it'll take awhile, because Walmart is so damned massive and dominant right now.
Frankly, looking at the US map, as a non-american, even there their presence isn't particularly exhaustive. The USA just happens to be a big market.
So yes, I'd say that's significantly stronger than Amazon's international footing. Walmart has serious competitors internationally (Carrefour, etc.), and Amazon is barely one of them.
I'm as bullish on Amazon in the long run as anyone you'll find here. But even I have to admit that Amazon's international presence is one of its most glaring weaknesses, especially in specific juxtaposition to Walmart.
Walmart is actually investing in startup ecommerce plays in brazil (where it has been established 40 years)
-http://www.4-traders.com/TESCO-PLC-4000540/news/Tesco-Market...
The US is on level with Turkey, only Mexico and Chile are worse.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_equ...
I just hate people saying what-not about easily verifiable facts.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_equ...
The US disparity is equal with France and lower than that of Germany.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_equ...
Culturally, I often wonder about the consumer value of monopolized markets.
These days, however, the threat of new entrants into any given market is much higher. Starting costs are drastically lower than they were when conventional microeconomic theory was being worked out. All things being equal, as a consumer, you still don't want a monopolist owning the market -- but the monopolist has to be somewhat cautious, for fear of disruption.
It seems highly unlikely that Amazon will ever operate a true monopoly over all categories of retail. Nor will the government (and competitive lobbying) allow it to get there. But an oligopoly is certainly possible.
(On a micro level, Walmart has basically functioned as a de facto monopolist in certain regions where it has virtually no competition. Those days are over, though.)
The trouble with this is that it plays exactly into the article's point. We can't disprove that Amazon will one day choke all the other retailers out of existence. We can always say, "tomorrow will be the day, just wait."
Meanwhile, Chinese factories are selling bicycle parts on eBay. Will WalMart fail but be replaced by manufacturers selling direct to end-users and disintermediate Amazon? I have no idea, but it's no less plausible than Amazon driving absolutely everyone out of business.
I'm not trying to debate eBay vs. Amazon, I'm simply suggesting that if we're talking "long games," there's a lot of uncertainties. Profitable companies are winning now.
I think they could probably beat ebay in this kind of game if they'll be interested.
Seems unlikely, because the main reason to go to Walmart or Best Buy is to get the product the same day you want it, and also to see it in person before buying it. Amazon won't drive everyone else out of business until they offer both of those.
I've only done it once. It was a defective milligram scale costing in the low teen 2-digits, which arrived DOA. Taking a chance, I resubmitted my original order and dropped off the defective unit at the local UPS store. A couple of days later, I had a working scale and an account credited to reflect the purchase of one scale, net.
http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-06-06/costco-ceo-c...
Bezos doesn't have an end game, he'll just keep driving growth until he gets sick of it. Then they'll get Steve Balmer to make the growth stop :)
In cloud infrastructure I think it's safe to say Walmart is actually the smaller contender.
Over time cloud infrastructure could subsume all of retail, at least in theory. If that's the case wouldn't you rather own Amazon than Walmart?
I'm not implying this is reality, I'm just saying predicting future potential is not as simple as current Market Capitalization might imply otherwise IBM would own the NASDAQ today.
Walmart does ~500B in rev. Amazon did 61B in rev in '12 and is on pace for 72B-ish in '13.
What is the 'end game' of Wallmart? I mean, don't most established companies just want to continually drive growth till they saturate the market, then reap?
As far as when the Amazon endgame starts, my guess is when they are doing as much business as walmart
So.. why is that "fucking ludicrous"? Seems to me they're playing the Long Run Equilibrium game just fine: "In the long run, every competitive firm will earn normal profit, that is, zero profit."
Right now, the only obstacle to Amazon's profitability is Walmart. If Walmart didn't exist, Amazon's pricing control supremacy would ensure they could operate at the lowest possible market price on every item, and as the market maker for product, they would control the cost floor as well.
In a sense, the end game for Amazon is this: it's fucking ludicrous to run a company without profit for years. At some point someone else is going to try to take more profits because of the volume pressure of Amazon. The end game for Amazon is choking all of the other retailers out of existence, IMHO.
They don't have to flip a switch, they just need to wait. They're playing the long game.