Also: how are you going to self-study when you don't live at home? Studying is a full time job.
http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~oholtz/teaching.html
has homeworks for Rudins "Principles of Mathematical Analysis", and Halmos "Finite-Dimensional Vector Spaces". Finally most problem books (again Springer has a nice selection) have very detailed solutions. Yes, there are proofs that can be done in a number of different ways, but in my experience diverging too far is not very common and in most cases some core ingredients have to make it in in the end anyway. It's impossible to go through a lot of exercises "writing complete nonsense solutions" like that, when you are precisely checking your solutions against the given ones. For many types of exercises there are also simple ways of validating your solution, for example, in probability theory you can often do a computer simulation. In the end that's what anyway has to be done in real world and in research work.
Also lots of people have convinced themselves of lots of silly things. You can probably find dozens of papers from people with bachelors in math (or no degree) claiming they have solved P=NP. A lot of these turn out to be completely bogus, but the authors nonetheless thought they were serious attempts.
Again, I agree doing it at the university is more effective way of doing it, and if you have the possibility to do it, good for you! But most of us can afford to dedicate at most 5 years to studying full time, and than other responsibilities kick in and you can't do it anymore. The majority of your life all the new knowledge you get will come from self-study. So you better learn to do it.
For me, merely pushing myself through a theoretical CS curriculum made me see (and write) hundreds of proofs, hear them explained by professors, and see non-trivial exercises solved during recitations. I don't think you can get the same kind of experience by just reading a textbook, even if it does offer full solutions to problems.
Maybe when there will be full video lectures for both lectures and recitations for the basic math (or theoretical CS) curriculum you could self-study by watching those and solving problem sets. Right now, the math courses offered by Coursera don't seem to match college level, and their platform doesn't really work for proof-based courses like Analysis, Linear Algebra (not the applied kind), etc...
MIT OCW has excellent courses for discrete math, calculus and linear algebra and in some cases videos from the recitations are included.
http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/mathematics/18-01sc-single-variab...
I also stressed a few times already I don't think it is "the same kind of experience". But as long as you make an effort you will make progress and not everyone can manage to fit a university degree in their schedule.
Halmos, Rudin, and Spivak 'Calculus on Manifulds' were at least at one time the main references in Harvard's Math 55 as at
http://www.american.com/archive/2008/march-april-magazine-contents/why-can2019t-a-woman-be-more-like-a-man/?searchterm=Sommers
and are some of the best stuff for a ugrad
math major.Your last sentence is on the center of the target of reality.
Don't worry: I've tried to show that P = NP and know that while I've had some candidate ideas I don't have a good idea or a proof. And, I've nearly never written a bad proof; once catch on to how proofs are done, they are surprisingly easy to check for correctness.
Studying is not a full time job -- I was heavily self taught in math and totally self taught in computing and nearly never studied full time. E.g., I read Nearing on linear algebra, Halmos 'Finite Dimensional Vector Spaces', Fleming 'Functions of Several Variables', yes, with the exterior algebra, and much more while working full time in mostly DoD work around DC. I did the research for my Ph.D. dissertation in stochastic optimal control independently in my first summer in graduate school.
Edit: There's a better answer in this thread in
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6177643Anyway, this is almost irrelevant to what I was saying. Even if you assume every person can reason well, I'm saying you could still be in error unless you seek validation and guidance. It's really easy to think you've given a solid argument for something, but actually be wrong. It happens to everyone.
*By the way, there is a definite trend in physics for math, instead of experimentation, to be leading the way towards discovery.
As such, I think it's ridiculous to go up to anyone and tell him/her to just "study by yourself", I could give a maths book to a biologist and that person would understand absolutely nothing without guidance.
There is plenty of free access to materials and papers.
It's incredibly cheap and fast to communicate with pretty much anyone in the world.
All that is really required is motivation, discipline, and curiosity.
When there wasn't cheap access to global communication networks and near-zero cost to duplicating data then it made sense to go to university because that was where everyone who you would be interested in talking to would be. That's where the libraries and books were. I don't think that is the only option anymore. And that's a good thing.
You can learn anything you want on your own and still have all of the benefits of a college (access to knowledgeable people, peer review, etc).
One outstanding example was his method for a 'free energy' spacecraft movement system, that hinged on an arm throwing -foo- into a receiver. The argument was that there is a difference between throwing something and merely releasing it at speed, and he didn't have the understanding of physics to realise there is no difference.
Another one of his ideas was a system for finding prime numbers, which he couldn't articulate well enough for people to figure out whether it was a valuable predictor or merely a sieve.
He was a regular at the forum and respected, and I've never seen so many people patiently explaining physics and maths at such clear lengths before... and he just couldn't grok it, because he didn't have the standard language to get his ideas across.
This anecdata doesn't contradict the GP though, who is talking about doing self-study in parallel with formal study.
Since in many cases PhD is basically free, it is by far more competitive than Bachelors.
I never got anywhere trying to get into Princeton as an undergraduate, with average SAT scores over 700, but did get accepted in the math (or statistics) department as a graduate student. I'd read lots of John Tukey's work -- uniformity in topology (in the back of Kelley's 'General Topology'), Tukey's lemma in axiomatic set theory, stepwise regression, power spectral estimation (Blackman and Tukey), the FFT (Cooley and Tukey), and 'Exploratory Data Analysis', had been working in applied math and computing, wrote G. Watson, and got accepted. I also got accepted in the Division of Applied Math at Brown and in Operations Research at Cornell. I went to Hopkins.
Your point about graduate school is spot on, though. The game completely changes (though I think it's still mostly a game). I especially love the "don't buy this muffler..." quote!
Kudos for being accepted by all the big names!
In many cases an Ivy League Bachelors is basically free as well.
Between tuition waivers for lower income students, and parents paying for higher income students, an Ivy League Bachelors is effectively free to most of the time.
For PhD, As sidww2 pointed out, and what I have experienced as well, the admission pool becomes much more international; and now you are competing with the world. There is a phrase about China saying that underlines the scale well: "in China when you are one in a million -- there are 1,300 other people just like you".
Moreover, overall the number of spots in graduate schools is by far smaller than for undergrad; making competition even tougher.
I'm a math major and recently I started studying CS and I couldn't agree more!
Technically, yeah, I made a generalization: cheaper schooling means shittier quality education (not bad, just worse). Of course, I haven't stepped into every community college classroom. But this is the psychology of the people looking at your application.
Technically technically, what actually matters is all the things that go along with going to a cheaper school, not really the fact that it's cheap.
2. "The rigor was pretty good" - does that mean you kept taking math classes (real analysis, etc)? If not, then how can you make that claim?
Sure, the first two years at Harvard can be something special, especially if the student uses AP or tests out of the standard first two years of ugrad school. E.g., Harvard's Math 55 taught to freshmen at least at one time used Halmos, FDVS, Rudin's 'Principles', and Spivak's 'Manifolds'. That's usually junior or senior level stuff.
I know one guy who went to Harvard and as a sophomore took a reading course from A. Gleason. So, if in the next two years he knocked off one of Hilbert's problems, like Gleason did, then he could also become a Harvard 'Fellow' and skip a Ph.D.! But, again, we're talking engineering, not being so advanced as a ugrad that really should end up with a Ph.D. in math instead of a Bachelor's.
What's so wrong about just taking the first two years of college as just the usual first two years? A CC can provide that. A CC can use a good calculus book; when I took calculus, I used the same book Harvard used; that is, Harvard was willing to teach a calculus course, just calculus from just a common book, to I don't know who took it. Given the book and anything like a competent CC teacher, the Harvard course doesn't have much room to be better than a CC course, especially if the student followed my recommendations on self study before the course.
I know; I know; maybe the freshman English lit course at Harvard is taught by a Nobel prize winner in literature and can provide some astoundingly profound insights into Henry James and, thus, change the lives of the students. I'm not impressed.
You seem eager to "pay a lot" for the first two years of college.
also, if you start your degree at a CC and transfer to a 4 year to finish, what does it says on your diploma? exactly what it would say if you went there for four years. I wouldn't recommend keeping secrets about your life, but if no one asks...
I did keep taking math classes! I have a math minor.
That a guy started at a community college and ended up with excellent GRE scores is an impressive 'trajectory', and mostly good graduate schools will be sufficiently impressed. The graduate schools are hungry for highly motivated, good students and will want to grab what I described.
I wish I could delete the rest of this branch.
Anecdotally, in my own case, I hit employment parity with my Ivy League/Top-10 school peers at 6 years, and have long since surpassed most of them in the job market and standard of living (due to an unbelievably smaller debt load).
The only people I know from my starting peer group who I could comfortably say have a higher standard of living than I do also went to regular 'ol state schools but just worked harder/smarter than I did.
I get fairly regular recruitment pitches from the Google's, Amazon's and Facebook's, and have worked for some of the biggest and best companies in their industries. (I've noticed an uptick in Google courtships over the last couple years as they finally brought their data crunching prowress to analyze hiring success and found that their traditional hiring pools did not necessarily provide the best employees)
All that being said, if I were so inclined, there are positions (high end consulting, finance, high-level politics) that I'm less likely to ever end up in due to fierce protectionism by "old guard". But I'm finding those hard kernels of school fashionistas are rapidly disappearing now as well.
On the other hand, if you don't have the money there are not a lot of opportunities left. And I for my part prefer some who showed that kind of ambition over everyone else who hand it "the easy way" (not meaning an MIT degree is easy at all, just saying there are roads with more rocks than others).
If you are in software, then likely you are heavily self-taught. Well, being self-taught in nearly all parts of academic engineering is easier than in practical software if only because in nearly all of academic engineering the learning materials are much, much better written.
To do self-study in academic engineering, it is crucial to get some of the best materials, usually, still, textbooks. For this, investigate and pick carefully. Indeed, you should have little trouble finding what the favorite textbooks are for what you want to learn -- likely can get enough just by going to the Web sites of the most relevant universities, departments, courses, and professors. For the engineering schools, don't be reluctant to go right to the top -- MIT, Cornell, CMU, Georgia Tech, Stanford.
If you need more, then maybe send a nice e-mail to some professors, in a few words explain your situation, maybe include a list of the candidate books you have found, and ask for suggestions, say, the textbooks he's been using, on the list or off.
Point 2. If you want an 'expensive' Bachelor's degree, say, for $50,000 a year at an Ivy League university, instead shoot for a Masters or better yet a Ph.D. from such a school. Why? In important ways, the graduate degree is faster, easier, and cheaper than the Bachelor's. In my experience, at the best schools, Ph.D. students rarely pay tuition anyway. And from the famous Ivy League schools, it's generally easier to get accepted for a Ph.D. than for a Bachelors.
Point 3: If you want a Bachelor's degree or need one (say, to get accepted for a Master's or Ph.D.), then one option is just go to about the cheapest school you can, maybe starting with just a two year community college and then transferring to a four year college to finish your Bachelor's. "Don't pay a lot for this muffler" -- uh, Bachelor's degree. Everyone in higher education understands that there are good students with little money or family background in academics and respect such students. If you learned well, then as you finish your Bachelor's you can get some high GRE scores which will look great applying to a Ph.D. program and make up for starting at a community college.
Point 4. Even following Point 3, to save money and get better results, still emphasize self-study. That is, before taking the course, study the course on your own first. Then take the course, lead the class, ace the course, amaze the professor, and get glowing recommendations, say, to a good four year college for your last two years, or from a four year college to a Ph.D. program, as the best student he ever had, maybe get a scholarship. Besides, this way might get to take extra courses at once, save tuition money, time on campus, and expenses commuting to campus and look still smarter, all because you just studied the material before you took the course.
Of course, this self-study stuff can work great for the more theoretical and mathematical parts of engineering but work less well where you might need time in an expensive lab. So, emphasize the theoretical and mathematical parts and for the rest do what you can without a lab. Then in school, when you take the lab course, you still have a head start.
E.g., on self-study, I got a Ph.D. in essentially applied math, but I never really took freshman calculus. Instead, in my freshman year the poor school I was at insisted I take some 'college algebra' which was beneath what I'd covered in four years of math at a relatively good public high school. So, not to fall behind, I got a decent calculus book and dug in. For my sophomore year, I went to a much better college and started on their sophomore calculus (right, never got course credit for freshman calculus), was likely the best student in the class, was a math major, wrote an honors paper on group representations, and got 800 on the Math knowledge GRE.
So, I covered freshman calculus well just on my own from just a calculus book. You can too. Indeed, if you take a calculus course, mostly you learn from the book anyway.
Just study the material from the book before the course instead of mostly from the book (which usually you have to do anyway) during the course. If you get hung up, then ask for some help, on-line, from some videos (if they help -- not all of them are good), knock on the door of a prof and ask a question, etc. Tell him you are studying on your own and want to be clear on, say,
or some such. Mostly a prof's office hours are not very busy, and a prof might answer one good question for you even if you are not in such a class or even in his school. If he refuses, then to heck with him!There are some poor textbooks out there, and some of the better books will still have a poor chapter or two. A bad book or chapter can be a chuckhole in the road but only if you let it. If some material seems not well written, like drilling through bedrock, or needing prerequisites you don't have, then get 1-3 alternate sources, maybe just by photocopying some chapters from some books in a library or buying some books as supplements. E.g., there is a book on linear algebra by E. Nearing, and it quite good except it has a chapter in an appendix on linear programming that is just awful. Nearing understood a lot of linear algebra but not linear programming!
So, get copies of, say, the three best books. Learn mostly from the best book and use the other two for alternate explanations (so that you won't get stuck and won't misunderstand).
Now, textbooks are darned expensive, the latest editions, in hardcover, commonly over $100 a copy. Three such books could set you back $300 -- bummer. So, instead, in nearly all undergraduate courses in engineering, get used texts, in good condition, 5-10 years old. Such books will still be plenty good and will save you a bundle of money.
E.g., I took sophomore calculus from the text by Johnson and Kiokemeister. At the time, it was also used at Harvard. It's a beautifully written, highly polished book. Tough to write a better calculus book.
So right away from a Google search at
can see So, can get it for $10. Don't pay a lot for a great textbook.Actually I got my copy 'used' from a student who had tried the course the previous year and learned that he should major in English or some such instead! More generally, due to such circumstances, a lot of used technical books are actually in quite good condition.
You don't have to work all the exercises, but you should work enough exercises so that you are sure you can work all or nearly all of them. A good textbook will have in the back answers to half or more of the exercises; so check your work with the answers. Occasionally an answer is wrong. If you suspect such, then maybe e-mail the author! Or ask a local prof to check your solution and impress him that you beat the textbook!
Occasionally let a difficult exercise go unsolved or ask for help; in some books, 1-2% of the exercises are in there poorly written, out of place (need material not yet covered in the book or not in the book), or are to see if a student can recreate some brilliantly clever argument mostly unrelated to the book. Don't let yourself get hung up on 1-2% of the exercises afraid you missed something -- give such an exercise a good shot, then just ask for help or drop it.
Continue this theme of self study, especially if you want to go for a Ph.D. E.g., at one time the Web site of the Princeton math department just flatly stated that the graduate courses were introductions to research by world experts; no courses were given for preparation for the qualifying exams; and for the qualifying exams students were expected to prepare on their own. Indeed, in that case, why bother to be on campus in expensive Princeton, NJ?
So, broadly, you can get a Bachelor's paying little or no tuition.
Then for a Ph.D., or even some Master's degrees, the big trump card is having published some research in a good, peer-reviewed, academic journal of original research.
For how to do the research, that would need another post!
In the whole thing, nearly all the work was self-study from used textbooks, and the tuition you paid was tiny. You cut down on time and cost commuting to campus, eating campus food, etc. You aced nearly all your courses, and you avoided a huge list of potential 'political' and other problems.
Learning is not a spectator sport but an individual thing with hard work, done alone in a quiet room. You can blow a lot of time and money going to class when what you really need is just hard work, alone, in a quiet room, which, indeed, the courses won't much replace anyway.
Not everyone learns the same way. But, since you learned the material before you took the course, the profs never get to see how you learned; you never fell behind in a course; you aced courses, and you never got criticized for your learning style.
Net, lack of money is no great reason not to get a degree, even a Ph.D., in engineering. Indeed, the main challenge is just the learning and, then, research; if you can do that, mostly on your own, then money for your degree is not a biggie.