News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Russian Man Changes Small Print in Credit Card Agreement,... by scotty79 on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @07:52PM (#6176465)
Do you have in UK these scammers that invite bunch of old people to some sort of meeting where they give them cake, some crappy gift and convince them that some other crappy thing, like a wool blanket is worth few thousands dollars and they sign agreements with them so they can pay for the said blanket in installments?

The rule you described is really nice but is it used in practice to fight such scammy business practices?

Re:Russian Man Changes Small Print in Credit Card Agreement,... by SEMW on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:30AM (#6179114)
I've never heard of it, but I wouldn't be surprised if we did.

But: It's not clear to me that the rule is at all relevant to that scam. As you describe it, it's not that the victims reasonably appeared to be agreeing to do one thing when what they signed said something different. They were persuaded to buy a blanket for x thousand dollars, and did.

The most obvious tool contract law has to undermine that is misrepresentation. If the scammer told a lie to get the victim to sign, then the contract's voidable by the victim. (This is true even if the misrep is innocent. If it's fraudulent, then you get a better measure of damages - and, of course, the scammers might've committed the criminal offence of fraud).

There's also a doctrine of 'undue influence', which if proved can also make the contract voidable.

Finally, even if the contract is valid, since R v Hinks [2000] UKHL 53, it's not impossible that the scammers could be convicted of theft of the money. So, validly transferred per civil law, theft per criminal law! Which is... surprising. (IMHO it's bloody stupid, but that's another debate).

Re:Russian Man Changes Small Print in Credit Card Agreement,... by thepicard on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @08:42PM (#6176657)
Your example is ridiculously contrived.

I would imagine the rule is not used extensively in practice because it exists as a preventive measure should such a thing ever come up.

Re:Russian Man Changes Small Print in Credit Card Agreement,... by dfox on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @09:37PM (#6176876)
That is not an contrived example but pretty accurate description of actual scam scheme that got popular again in recent years.