News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Medium is building a new kind of company with no mana... by bsbechtel on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @02:05PM (#6168141)
I'm curious to hear how well it scales, and also what the downsides are once they come out. A lack of praise for employees seems like a fairly minor issue.

It's been said Valve is somewhat like high school with their completely flat hierarchy, although this is never mentioned in the many articles praising their management structure (or lack thereof). I'm curious if this type of management system causes similar problems.

That being said, everyone is different and some people (and cultures - Germany, Switzerland) function in a hierarchy very well, while others don't. I think the article alludes a little to this with the comment about individuals who take initiative vs those who don't. IMHO, those individuals who take initiative on their own are drawn to entrepreneurship and small companies, whereas those who don't are drawn to large corporations where others can set goals for them and as they achieve those goals, they move up. As Medium grows, they're inevitably going to attract more of the latter type, and it will be harder to provide meaningful roles for the former type.

Re:How Medium is building a new kind of company with no mana... by nomade0 on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @03:33PM (#6168673)
Based on what I read about Valve, it is not surprising that they have a lot of politics going on. That's the issue with flat structures - when authorities and accountabilities are unclear, you need make alliances (seen as "cliques" from the exterior) to get your projects moving forward.

On the contrary, Holacracy has processes that push for clarity. It distinguishes people and their roles, and provides forums (e.g., clear meeting processes) to address misalignments and conflicts between roles, in service of the company's purpose. It's well explained in this 3-min video http://youtu.be/9U_XDin5tjI

Disclosure; I work with HolacracyOne. Hope that clarifies the difference a bit

Re:How Medium is building a new kind of company with no mana... by jeremyt on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:06PM (#6169165)
Not really well explained. Nothing about the process is explained in the video.

The only thing the video does is spend three minutes saying "if you have a problem, solve it among yourselves rather than going to the boss".

Re:How Medium is building a new kind of company with no mana... by nomade0 on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @03:52AM (#6171423)
No, the processes themselves are not explained in this video. This other one explains "tactical meetings": http://youtu.be/8NrsVBATZCM

That said if you want the technicalities of the process, you'll find everything in the constitution (not as entertaining, but more accurate): http://holacracy.org/constitution