Re:Beg HN: Please only report serious GitHub outages (1h+)
by dasil003 on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:14AM
(#6165583)
Lighten up, he just posted a suggestion and request that maybe Github being down isn't something that people need to rush here to post the minute a web request times out. If he succeeds in lowering the rate of people posting this useless information than it's a net win.
Re:Beg HN: Please only report serious GitHub outages (1h+)
by benatkin on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @07:16AM
(#6165928)
I don't think it would be a net win, though. Neither you nor OP has established that 30-40 minutes is a better threshold for when a story is made about GitHub being down than what it currently is (apparently 5-10 minutes when there aren't a lot of other good stories to compete with on HN). You and OP might prefer it, but you're just a couple of data points.
Re:Beg HN: Please only report serious GitHub outages (1h+)
by 300bps on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @07:15AM
(#6165926)
I was reminded of someone who emails a list of thousands of people and this is the first Reply to All saying, "Can you please take me off this list?". Then there are many more such requests and then they will be followed by emails desperately asking people to, "STOP REPLYING TO ALL!!!!"
Re:Beg HN: Please only report serious GitHub outages (1h+)
by jeswin on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:49AM
(#6165664)
Take it easy. It's a perfectly valid suggestion.
Nobody's work suffers due to a ten minute outage, since it's "git"-hub.
Re:Beg HN: Please only report serious GitHub outages (1h+)
by darxius on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @07:09AM
(#6165910)
Some people host websites/projects on Github pages. They definitely suffer when Github is out cold and might want to move to fallback.
Re:Beg HN: Please only report serious GitHub outages (1h+)
by PommeDeTerre on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @07:30AM
(#6165966)
There are many automated systems that'll detect outages, and take some sort of an action in response. There's no need for this site to be involved in any way.
This is hacker news, and many of the hackers here use GitHub so when it goes down they might be spinning their wheels. If it is down for less than three minutes it probably won't make it off the new page. I think your arbitrary 30-40 minutes isn't better than what became the norm based on user behavior on HN. Why do you, Toshio, think you know with a high level of precision, how long GitHub needs to be down for it to be relevant to HN?