News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by pfraze on Monday August 05, 2013 @10:08PM (#6164453)
> It can access that data 20 times faster than the best breed of flash memory

> could also perform its storage functions at 20 times lower power

> non-volatile

> 10 times the endurance of NAND flash chips that it could replace

If this is true, wow, but I have a hard time believing it.

Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by 31reasons on Monday August 05, 2013 @10:12PM (#6164466)
They haven't mentioned the price or may be I missed it. That may be the important factor.
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by kcorbitt on Monday August 05, 2013 @10:19PM (#6164489)
They also don't compare the read speed (17 MB/s) to existing flash memory. They showcase an amazing write speed, but most applications access data a lot more frequently than they create it.
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by wging on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @12:52AM (#6164868)
They do say "It can access that data 20 times faster than the best breed of flash memory" but a rate of 17 MB/s means this is incorrect.
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by shenberg on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @01:21AM (#6164939)
They're probably referring to latency, which is very low (30ns). It still is disingenuous, but that's marketing.
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by vlasta2 on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @03:58AM (#6165368)
I guess it is more accurate to talk about latency, because throughput can always be improved by accessing multiple cells in parallel.
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by bostik on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @01:30AM (#6164958)
Even then the limit is unlikely to come from non-volatile storage itself. The current effective flash R/W speeds are pretty much limited by the controllers.

I remember an article stating that embedded flash controllers typically have a 20MB/s speed limit. This in turn meant that wireless speeds beyond 200Mb/s were mostly worthless, because the devices simply could not utilise any more. If someone can find the article again, I would be delighted.

However: if the reality with RRAM is even half as good as the claims go, then it would certainly encourage the hardware vendors to invest in somewhat better controllers. After all, what good is a new, hyperspeed storage medium if you can't access it any faster than the old one?

Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by ars on Monday August 05, 2013 @11:07PM (#6164592)
The price of a chip is more or less the die size. And they clearly show a smaller die than existing technology.
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by agildehaus on Monday August 05, 2013 @11:20PM (#6164619)
Since when is the price of a chip in any way related to the size of its die?
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by redangstrom on Monday August 05, 2013 @11:57PM (#6164716)
Price or cost?

The whole premise of taking NAND from 25nm to 19nm (for instance) is to fit more floating gates in the same area. You can take that as a smaller die, or as more bits on a slightly larger die than the previous generation.

Die size is indeed a major factor on cost. For a given technology (litho node + process, e.g. # and type of steps), the cost to process a wafer is fairly constant regardless of die size.

If you shrink a die size, you fit more die on a wafer. Additionally, yield goes up (given an independent manufacturing defect density), and especially for large die, the tessellation around the edges has a major impact.

Indirectly, even testing is related to die size, in that there is a limit to tester parallelism, and more gates means more time and more combinatorial patterns to test, e.g. for stuck-at testing.

There are of course non-linear costs in packaging and package-level testing and elsewhere.

Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by yread on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @01:41AM (#6164990)
Please, be civil. There are better ways to ask a question.
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by Symmetry on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @07:01AM (#6165881)
The per unit costs of a chip[1] are essentially constant per wafer. The smaller a chip is, the more of them each wafer will produce. Also, the smaller a chance there is that any given chip will be ruined by an imperfection. So then number of chips you get from each dollar of production cost is a bit less than linearly inversely proportional to the area of the chip. There are other factors too, though, and wafers from more advanced nodes will tend to be more expensive. However, the two examples being compared here were both from the 25nm nod.

[1] Which dominate with memory since production runs tend to be large and the regular patterns make for less design investment than, say, a CPU.

Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by ddeck on Monday August 05, 2013 @11:55PM (#6164710)
It's always been related, but it's not the only factor. Packaging, assembly and test are the other primary components of manufacturing cost. You are correct though, that price (as opposed to cost) is going to include amortized R&D, marketing, license fees, margin etc.
Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by DennisP on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @09:49AM (#6166524)
From another article:

"[Crossbar's CEO] could not estimate the price of a 1TB RRAM module, but said it will cheaper than NAND flash partly because RRAM is less expensive to manufacture."

http://www.pcworld.com/article/2045926/startup-crossbar-pits...

Re:Crossbar Resistive RAM stores a terabyte on a chip by Einherji on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @12:33PM (#6167551)
I agree, these claims seem incredible, I would love to see things like this backed up with a demo.