Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on Transfinite Cardinal Arithmetic with Wolfram Alpha. Parent comment
By defining it as the inverse of multiplication, of course! (Assuming the inverse exists.)
A number n can be defined as the class of all sets that are 1-to-1 with { x1, ..., xn }, where xi are distinct "things".
Then, x * y is the class of all sets that are 1-to-1 with the cross-product of any element of x with any element of y.
(2/3 is the wrong answer according to this definition; the right answer is any n > 0 or aleph 0).
Which is exactly the problem: it's not well defined.
By defining it as the inverse of multiplication, of course! (Assuming the inverse exists.)
A number n can be defined as the class of all sets that are 1-to-1 with { x1, ..., xn }, where xi are distinct "things".
Then, x * y is the class of all sets that are 1-to-1 with the cross-product of any element of x with any element of y.
(2/3 is the wrong answer according to this definition; the right answer is any n > 0 or aleph 0).