News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Transfinite Cardinal Arithmetic with Wolfram Alpha by lmm on Sunday August 04, 2013 @04:00PM (#6156856)
>If my definition of infinity is the set of all integers, why isn't this true - >(2 * infinity) / (3 * infinity) = 2/3

How do you divide one set by another set?

>How do you transition from that - to counting infinitely small dots on those circles and saying they have the same number of those dots? I don't see the connection from that exercise to the mathematical rules.

It's a paradox - "obviously" the larger circle contains more dots than the smaller one. But by drawing those lines you can see both circles contain the same number of dots.

I don't want to say that Cantor showed that our obvious idea is wrong. Rather, Cantor found a mathematically consistent and useful way to define infinities - or rather, a consistent and useful way to define the "size" of a set, which gives the expected answer for finite sets, and extends to apply to infinite sets - and if you use that definition, then both circles contain the same (infinite) number of points.

>Normal logic dictates that there should be more real numbers between 1 and 10 than there are between 1 and 2. Because 1-10 contains all the numbers that are in 1-2. >But that's not true!?

Exactly

Re:Transfinite Cardinal Arithmetic with Wolfram Alpha by valtron on Sunday August 04, 2013 @09:58PM (#6158001)
> How do you divide one set by another set?

By defining it as the inverse of multiplication, of course! (Assuming the inverse exists.)

A number n can be defined as the class of all sets that are 1-to-1 with { x1, ..., xn }, where xi are distinct "things".

Then, x * y is the class of all sets that are 1-to-1 with the cross-product of any element of x with any element of y.

(2/3 is the wrong answer according to this definition; the right answer is any n > 0 or aleph 0).

Re:Transfinite Cardinal Arithmetic with Wolfram Alpha by lmm on Sunday August 04, 2013 @10:53PM (#6158163)
>(2/3 is the wrong answer according to this definition; the right answer is any n > 0 or aleph 0).

Which is exactly the problem: it's not well defined.