Ask HN: Flag != Downvote, Right?
This was a pretty interesting bit of investigative journalism that I submitted the other day:
"Dozens of CIA Agents at Benghazi Attack, Being Kept Quiet w/ Monthly Polygraphs (thelead.blogs.cnn.com)"
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6152006
and it was definitely relevant to HN given all of the concern of late about abuses by the intelligence community and the "War on Leakers". However, it was flagged to death because the word "Benghazi" has become so politicized that apparently some HNers just read the headline, incorrectly assumed that it was some sort of right-wing talk radio screed, and flagged it without even bothering to click through to the article.
This was an interesting piece of journalism, giving a detailed description of the pressure the intelligence community exerts to silence "potential leakers". The reporter (Jake Tapper) is probably one of the best in the business right now - with a reputation for being very balanced, and on a network with a similar repuation.
This was no Fox News or MSNBC political hit piece.
This problem seems to be getting worse and worse.
UPDATE: And... This was flagged in 10 minutes. Great, The Circle is Complete.
- Stories that could be considered as positive towards Microsoft - Personally, I'm not a big fan of Microsoft, and if there was a Reddit-like downvote for stories, I might consider using it for some of these submissions. But uniformly flagging anything that could be construed as positive towards Microsoft seems quite out of line and petty.
- Political stories or opinions with a Libertarian bent - based on user comments, HN seems to be about 1/3 Liberal, 1/3 Libertarian (with a few conservatives thrown in), and 1/3 moderate/apolitical, but comparable political stories and opinion pieces by Paul Krugman, Matt Taibbi, Ezra Klein, Matthew Yglesias, and other Liberal writers don't seem to run into the same flagging issues that Libertarian ones do.
- Stories that are negative towards Apple - this doesn't seem to happen as much anymore, but was probably one of the best examples of abusive flagging a couple of years ago.
- Political stories in general - I'm sympathetic to HNers who get frustrated when NSA or Aaron Swartz stories completely take over HN, and I'll admit that HN has been a little too politics heavy of late. However, I find it really troubling when HNers openly make comments about how they are "flagging every political story they see". I've witnessed some really interesting submissions and comment discussions get unfairly snuffed out because of this attitude.
I would be curious to hear about any other abusive flagging patterns HNers have noticed, or any opinions on what can be done about it.
I know that there is a thread buried away somewhere for feature requests and that this probably isn't the place for it, but I wish flagging could be more transparent somehow. Maybe with an icon to make users aware that flagging is taking place, and where they could have the opportunity to counter it - or unflag - a submission when they feel that the flagging is abusive?
From http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
"What to Submit
On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.
Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic."
You even admit in this discussion that the phenomenon isn't new ('all of the concern of late about abuses by the intelligence community and the "War on Leakers"') and that it would be covered on TV news ('this piece has been picked up and heavily covered by major news outlets everywhere').
If you want to discuss this story, that's great, but HN isn't the place for it.
Here are some of the HNer comments from the killed thread, to help illustrate:
wisty 23 hours ago | link
> In exclusive communications obtained by CNN, one insider writes, "You don't jeopardize yourself, you jeopardize your family as well."
> Another says, "You have no idea the amount of pressure being brought to bear on anyone with knowledge of this operation."
I think the implication is pretty clear here.
-----
pgeorgi 23 hours ago | link
"The goal of the questioning, according to sources, is to find out if anyone is talking to the media or Congress."
Media: okay. I can sort of see why. Congress: What the ... are they hiding?
This has nothing to do with the Fox News crowd or shrill former politicians, and I think you're betraying your own political biases by refusing to engage with the substance of the matter.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6152006