News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by mapgrep on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @01:39PM (#6135477)
Look, I'm all for limiting copyright but let's think about exactly what you're looking at vs what's in the original study (http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm/SSRN_ID2295085_code...).

The WaPo chart is for editions, not titles. If you list by decade for titles -- actual original works of creativity -- the 2000s utterly demolish each prior decade within this sample, and the 1990s surpass most, by the study author's own estimate (rather than manually identify duplicate titles, the author seems to havbe looked at some subsample and divided the whole public domain batch by 4).

See Figure 2 in the study.

It makes sense that public domain books have way more editions than titles; it is a market of duplication and redundancy, where you differentiate yourself using packaging and SEO type tactics. A spammy market, in other words. Printing a public domain book mainly involves some scanning, layout work using widely available software, and sending it off to the printer ("These tasks can be performed in less than a day," says the study). Oh, except you don't even need to scan anything for one of the many works already online, and you don't need to print anything if you use a print-on-demand service. So a lot of the "editions" in the WaPo chart are simply crap duplication garbage angling for a few pennies profit.

Now you can still make a case against lengthy copyright with this data, but it's trickier (because it's more honest). You can point out the population has grown tremendously and also as the study states: "In a world without copyright, one would expect a fairly smoothly downward sloping curve from the decade 2000-2010 to the decade of 1800-1810... Instead, the curve declines sharply and quickly, and then rebounds significantly for books currently in the public domain initially published before 1923."

The WaPo includes a paragraph summarizing this but the chart used is not the more honest Figure 2 but the misleading Figure 1.

Another issue? All the book figures in the study are based on an undisclosed set of subcategories of Amazon's "Literature and Fiction" category, a total of 7000 or so results later whittled down to 2317 based on a cross check with library of congress. What happens when all categories, the full range of textual creative expression, are included? We don't know.

If you want to make a convincing case that copyright terms are too long, use convincing data. "Look, public domain means more heavily duplicated garbage editions on Amazon!" is not particularly convincing.

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by WalterBright on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @02:47PM (#6135978)
I have several thousand books from the 80's and 90's. Very few are available. Consider one example:

"Mastering The MFC for Windows 95 using Symantec C++" by Richard Parker published by Thomson Computer Press.

It's long out of print, and I wished to make it available to my customers. I contacted the author, he was all for it, but said he didn't have the rights, I'd have to contact the publisher.

The publisher is out of business. I could find nothing on who owned the rights. Dead ends everywhere I looked.

So everybody loses. The author, the publisher, me, and my customers.

BTW, there is one used copy for sale on amazon for $14,763.21:

http://www.amazon.com/Mastering-Mfc-Windows-Using-Symantec/d...

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by mongol on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @04:18PM (#6136559)
Is there any aspect of that book that motivates that price?
Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by ijk on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @04:49PM (#6136741)
Obscure used books on Amazon tend to get automatically bid up to astronomical prices, as the repricing bots mistake the noise of an empty market for a signal: http://www.michaeleisen.org/blog/?p=358

As of this moment, the most expensive book on Amazon is going for one billion dollars: http://www.amazon.com/s?rh=n%3A283155&field-is-available-new...

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by anigbrowl on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @04:54PM (#6136768)
There's an insurance scam just waiting to happen here.
Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by anigbrowl on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @04:48PM (#6136736)
No, it's just automated pricing based on it being rare. You set a high price, other pricing bots come in and undercut it - unless the book is sufficiently rare or obscure, in which case the high price remains.

Funnily enough, my book is a good example of this. There's three copies on Amazon, priced within 1 cent of each other: http://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/1898275351/ref=dp_olp... It was one of the elss well-selling ones in the series so it's become 'rare' by virtue of its own obscurity, rather than inherent merit of its own :-)

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by JonnieCache on Thursday August 01, 2013 @07:12AM (#6139513)
Note to self: set up own pricing bot to bid rare books down to cheap rates and then snap them up. Finally that copy of the Dune Encyclopedia will be mine!

EDIT: Apparently it can be had for only £15 now. How depressing.

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by WalterBright on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @05:02PM (#6175611)
It's now up to $30,219.92 !!
Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by TheBurningOr on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @02:46PM (#6135976)
FWIW

The Atlantic covered this story much better (http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/07/the-ho...) and their coverage included two additional charts. One corresponds to your criticism of adjusting for titles vs versions. In that chart, the drop off in the mid 20th century is still evident but not as extreme. In the second chart, they account for differences in the number of books published per decade using third party sources. In that version, the divergance is actually much worse.

I don't think there were any responses to your criticism of the categories.

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by mapgrep on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @04:36PM (#6136668)
Thanks for the pointer! I think you're right that The Atlantic piece is more fair.

On the "adjusted" chart you reference, my thought was the adjustment makes that chart not hugely useful to the copyright debate. In other words, the debate has one side people who say "copyright encourages creative output" and on the other people who say "copyright actually limits the spread of creative output." By showing books available as a percentage of total books published, rather than showing absolute output, the adjusted chart is useless for the question "might strong copyright encourage greater output," instead measuring only the answer to the question "does copyright tend to limit distribution." Both sides in the debate agree the answer to the latter question is "yes." They do disagree on the scope of the problem so I suppose the adjusted chart addresses that point but it seems like a minor and muddled bit of data. You look at it and might think "ah copyright is really holding down the distribution of media" but when you realize it's basically a percentage chart (based on a small and not necessarily representative sample) and then realize book output has hugely grown it's hard to see the differences in the chart as particularly consequential for the debate. At least IMHO.

I would like to see that same chart adjusted for population growth.

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by Retric on Thursday August 01, 2013 @12:04AM (#6138564)
It's a lot cheaper to write and print a book now than in the 1800's, the population is much larger, and autors are often far more prolific. So, really your better off looking at the years before and after copywrite law changed vs the overall trend.
Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by hammock on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @02:40PM (#6135931)
There are still more titles in 1880 than 1980 in Figure 2.

http://i.imgur.com/SzUjfj0.gif

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by mapgrep on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @04:52PM (#6136761)
Yup. They could use a fair, non misleading chart in the WaPo piece and still make a good point about copyright.