News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by dredmorbius on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @12:53PM (#6135108)
> The key phrase

There are several key phrases there.

"To promote the Progress"

"for limited Times"

"to Authors and Inventors"

and of course "the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries"

But you omitted the operative language from the enumerated powers clause itself: "The Congress shall have Power to".

That's a grant of power, but not an obligation to act on that power.

Which is to say:

I've heard people claim that Congress must enact copyright and patent laws. No, Congress has at its discretion the ability to do so.

That those laws be to promote science (writing) and arts (technology). Which would seem to render any _retrospective* extension of the acts as unconstitutional, as well as any execution of the powers (say, by overly-broad grants of low-quality patents).

And that the grants be restricted to authors and inventors. Not the employers of authors and inventors, not entities which can buy, for the remainder of the protection period, the rights.

Narrowly read, an Author or Inventor would retain exclusive rights and would only be allowed to grant a temporary and nonexclusive grant of that right to others.

Patent and copyright were an interesting experiment at an interesting time (the US Revolution occurred on the eve of the Industrial Revolution, and ended a period of over 1000 years in which technological and economic change had proceeded at an absolutely glacial pace). The experiment appears to be failing in significant ways.

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by anigbrowl on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @04:52PM (#6136760)
Narrowly read, an Author or Inventor would retain exclusive rights and would only be allowed to grant a temporary and nonexclusive grant of that right to others.

An excellent argument.

Likewise, when the standard copyright term exceeds the median human lifetime, the 'limited time' effectively becomes 'forever.' One of the few things I like about the patent system is that the term is 20 years, which is a reasonable period of exclusivity for a genuinely patentable idea (vs. the abusive attempt to patent the obvious or prior art for litigation purposes).

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by dredmorbius on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @10:39PM (#6138321)
> when the standard copyright term exceeds the median human lifetime, the 'limited time' effectively becomes 'forever.'

The Supreme Court has, unfortunately, ruled otherwise.

Lessig, in his retrospective on the Eldred case (term limits extension suit that went to SCOTUS) feels he should have focused on the promotion rather than limited terms clause.

Coulda shoulda woulda. Thanks for trying anyway, Larry.

Re:Why does Amazon have more books from the 1880s than the 1... by DannyBee on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @10:59PM (#6138391)
Larry should have let a more experienced SCOTUS lawyer argue about it, but he also realized that in his retrospective too :(