News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by wmf on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @03:50PM (#6129554)
IMO this headline is a little inflammatory; the (mostly unenforced) ban on servers is a pretty small carve-out. Also note that the NN people haven't been complaining much that every consumer broadband plan also bans servers.
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by Terretta on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @04:20PM (#6129746)
That's not a "small carveout". That's a muzzle. It's asymmetric power, that you're only allowed to consume, not to publish.

What's more, from a technical standpoint, it's different for a fiber provider than for a cable company. Coax cable capacity is asymmetric. It can carry only a given amount of data and they can carve it up to give you more down and less up, equal amounts, or more up and less down. Obviously most users want fast downloads and aren't as concerned about uploads.

By contrast, fiber is symmetric, offering full capacities up and down at once. So while cable has a technical justification for "service levels" to offer a server, fiber providers do not. Google Fiber is 1000/1000 Mbit/s symmetrical. Forcing the consumer to not use the idle uplink is against consumer generated content and consumer ownership of their own content, for the sake of a "differentiated business plan". It's against the democratization of consumer created content that consumers can control themselves.

(Google has dogs in that hunt too, you "should" host your content on G+ or YouTube, and host your email on Gmail, rather than drop in a Mac Mini Server or "host any type of server" at home.)

FWIW, my $50/mo residential plan doesn't ban servers, even though the company offers business plans from $200/mo up. I can host a mail server and a web server, with dynamic DNS and open ports 25 and 80. Ports >1024 are open for all classes of service, even their lowest.

Finally, I think the point here is that other consumer broadband providers weren't lobbying for network neutrality. Telcos weren't, cable wasn't. Google was.

It feels a bit icky when "don't be evil" turns out to mean "for now ... until we have an offering in that area that enough people adopt and this practice we used to actively call evil turns out could make us more money and is actually good ... for us".

Mind you, being magnanimous until they own enough customers is an excellent strategy. They just need a different slogan and to quit with the flip flopping.

Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by jauer on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @05:32PM (#6130197)
> By contrast, fiber is symmetric, offering full capacities up and down at once. So while cable has a technical justification for "service levels" to offer a server, fiber providers do not. Google Fiber is 1000/1000 Mbit/s symmetrical.

Link symmetry is a property of the datalink protocol and service provisioning, not the physical media.

Many, if not most, FTTH deployments use PON which delivers asymmetric bandwidth that is shared among a number of users. GPON delivers 2.488Gbps down and 1.244Gbps up and is typically shared between 16 and 64 users.

Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by Terretta on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @07:44PM (#6130887)
For some reason, I was under the impression Google's FTTH (fiber to the home) was using real (active) fiber networking home runs instead of telco/cable's bastardized passive optical splitting down and TDM up. Wiki cited 1000/1000 symmetric, so I assumed they were using active symmetric.

Seems to be some debate about it:

http://www.dslreports.com/forum/r27731107-Google-Fiber-Lates...

If it's not real fiber networking, then yeah, same asymmetric song and dance as cable.

But see pages 10 and 11 of this Google PDF explaining why they might as well use symmetric point to point:

http://static.googleusercontent.com/external_content/untrust...

It says end run to users is the ultimate future proof approach and a costs negligible amount more.

If they didn't go that way, well, I am disappointed.

Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by jauer on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @08:18PM (#6131041)
It is also possible that they are using WDM-PON with a different wavelength for each subscriber.

Even with Active Ethernet (the industry term for dedicated run of fiber to each subscriber) you likely still have a bandwidth constraint somewhere, be it at the switch uplinks or border routers so some level of oversubscription is a given.

Right now FTTH networks are getting away with some pretty wild oversubscription ratios since content and consumption are lagging. From what I've seen on my network residential traffic tends to interleave pretty well as it is really bursty. Business traffic tends to a constant during the work day so can't interleave as many business customers. It will be interesting to see what Google Fiber charges medium & large businesses.

Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by Terretta on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @10:50PM (#6131627)
Just checked your profile -- love what you're doing. I helped start up a metro ISP in early 90s that we grew gangbusters by guaranteeing no busies and max modem speeds, till it got rolled up by a telco in late 90s.

Incidentally, as this is about hosting one's own servers, early on I wrote the first (as far as I know) dynamic DNS for dial-up users, so when you connected to a Portmaster and auth'd via RADIUS, your username.isp.com got pointed to your dynamic IP, allowing you to host over dialup under your own name. Customers even ran their own mail servers at home since SMTP was happy to wait for them to dial in. I believed in user publishing then and still do today.

From day one competitor telco ISP services (and telco backbone links) were so oversubscribed it felt immoral. Sorry to hear that's still not changing.

Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by voltagex_ on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @06:31PM (#6130553)
Crap, the Australian NBN is going to be GPON. It's going to be DOCSIS2 all over again - good until you get a lot of users in your neighborhood.
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by MrKurtz on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @06:03PM (#6130343)
They are hardly even a broadband player, their coverage in miniscule.

Google Fiber is an experimental / policy altering service, its TOS as this point in time is inconsequential.

Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by Wilya on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @04:14PM (#6129701)
I just read the TOS of my provider, and servers aren't banned anywhere.

Reselling is prohibited, any kind of "professional use" is prohibited, but they don't say anything about servers.

Besides, the reason nobody hosts servers on personal connections is that the upload speed is terrible, not any sort of legal/contractual thing.

Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by smtddr on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @04:21PM (#6129750)
I think running home-servers falls under "professional use", but if I'm wrong please correct me.
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by kevingadd on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @04:30PM (#6129820)
The OP itself points out non-professional uses of home servers (Minecraft)...
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by wmf on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @04:36PM (#6129856)
In general, ISPs don't mind non-professional servers; they're really banning commercial hosting.
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by md224 on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @05:56PM (#6130311)
Yep, and in this case Google is "really" banning all servers for non-business accounts, according to the original article.
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by rosser on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @05:50PM (#6130281)
[citation needed]
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by wmf on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @06:34PM (#6130566)
The millions of people who have been kicked off their ISPs for gaming, using Skype, running a little server, etc. Oh wait, that didn't happen.
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by stonemetal on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @05:39PM (#6130231)
If I run an email server for my family, or a web server to host my personal blog what is "professional use" about that?
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @06:35PM (#6130579)
> Also note that the NN people haven't been complaining much that every consumer broadband plan also bans servers

Yes, they have. In fact, the bans imposed by other broadband providers were the key motivation for NN folks. (Including the FCC commissioners that included the neutrality provisions in the Open Internet report and order.)

Right now, many NN advocates are yelling louder about Google because Google was on their side until very recently, and now is taking the exact opposite position.

Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by benologist on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @04:56PM (#6129976)
"No servers" means entire classes of consumer products that could leverage a very fast home connection are preemptively banned out of existence for another decade.

You could replace a lot of stuff with plug-in-and-forget devices on a very fast connection - dropbox, email provider, personal web hosting, etc.

Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by Lozzer on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @06:46PM (#6130623)
Admittedly in the UK, but the ISP I use don't have a problem with people running servers: http://www.aa.net.uk/
Re:Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on... by flagnog on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @04:14PM (#6129700)
every other consumer broadband plan has been against them from the start. Google, on the other hand is the only company to start off saying do whatever, then change their tune once they started offering broadband.