News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by jgalt212 on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:31PM (#6128525)
I commend Manning for sticking around to face the music and not going AWOL. As such, in my eyes, he's way more of a genuine activist than Snowden.

There can be no Letter from Birmingham Jail without the jail.

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by mcantelon on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:40PM (#6128605)
The strategy one employs to deal with being punished for revealing wrongdoing has nothing to do with how "genuine" the activism is. To suggest that Snowden, who has given up his life to alert humanity to the worst surveillance program in the world's history, isn't a "genuine" activist is, frankly, ridiculous.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by diminoten on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @03:07PM (#6129276)
Aristotle drank the hemlock. Who is/was a better philosophical mind, Edward Snowden or Aristotle?
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by spiek on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @03:35PM (#6129462)
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by diminoten on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @03:38PM (#6129483)
Oh shit, sorry. I'll leave the error so all this makes sense.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by tome on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:52PM (#6128689)
> the worst surveillance program in the world's history

"worst" in scale, certainly. What other criteria is it "worst" on?

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by mcantelon on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:04PM (#6128791)
It's worst in breadth and likely quite bad in terms of depth given their resources (and the ability, IIRC, to listen through landlines and cell phones). Surveillance depth will likely get much worse in the future, however, as they strongarm more companies into baking surveillance capabilities into mass-market devices (although they'll be competing, in this regard, with foreign manufacturers who will be/are also doing the same thing).

http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2012/03/petraeus-tv-remote/

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:02PM (#6128782)
>What other criteria is it "worst" on?

That's a state secret.

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by kaonashi on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:03PM (#6128788)
The manner in which it's being used at current is largely unknown to the public.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by sophacles on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:35PM (#6128560)
This is a false dilemma and disingenuous stance. You are basically saying that "unless you are willing to suffer, the problem you're talking about can't really be a problem".

(Actually you're saying that you can't be an activist without suffering, and the implication is that if it's not worth activism, it's not a big deal. So basically what I said).

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by jgalt212 on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:43PM (#6128629)
I guess that's exactly what I'm saying: You cannot be a true activist without taking heat from the powers that be and not running from them. So I guess we must agree to disagree. That being said, I think if you look at activists that have been studied and/or revered throughout history most have paid a steep price (many with their lives) for causes they support.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by mcantelon on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:46PM (#6128651)
The idea that Snowden, by giving up his entire life and making himself a refugee, isn't "taking heat" is an illogical talking point designed to smear him. You try fleeing your country permanently, leaving behind friends and family, and living stateless for weeks with the world's foremost superpower trying to bargain for you and tell me you're not "taking heat".
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by SwellJoe on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:26PM (#6128969)
"jgalt212" takes that position, eh? Have you read the book from whence your name comes? Taking the heat aint exactly part of the objectivist stance. I'm no objectivist, but I am an activist. Sometimes going to jail is a useful part of activism. Sometimes it is a waste of time, money, and life.

I'd rather Manning were not in jail. The information he revealed is his activism. Act of civil disobedience with the intention of being arrested has its place...it definitely has its place. Many dear friends of mine were arrested at the Texas capitol during the recent anti-abortion bill fracas, and I fully support their actions (one chained herself to the railing in the gallery; absolutely amazing and inspiring and impressive given that state troopers were confiscating everything suspicious going into the gallery, including tampons and condoms...she managed to get chains and a lock in). Their arrest was a source of massive media attention, including front page of the Austin Statesman...and that was the goal: making people aware of what was happening at the legislature.

Manning didn't need to be arrested to bring that attention to the leaked information, and it's unfortunate that our government, all the way up to the president (who promised openness, transparency, and to defend whistleblowers), are cowardly enough to shoot the messenger rather than address the crimes revealed by these leaks.

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by sophacles on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:52PM (#6129165)
I'm not willing to die because I think drug laws are too harsh (largely because I no longer use them), so obviously random people getting shot by mistake isn't a problem!

Never mind that I am willing to participate in less violent activism for that cause, I'm not a true scotsman.. er I mean activist.

Also, since I don't see you lining up to die for your stance on Snowden and Manning, you must not actually mean it - by your definition of course. Why should anyone care about it?

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by arg01 on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @06:05PM (#6130357)
Which is why the founding fathers decided it was best to get arrested by the British.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by Crito on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:40PM (#6129085)
Throwing yourself upon a pyre is only furthers your cause when very specific conditions are met. For Rosa Parks and MLK, those conditions were met. For Snowden, they surely were not.

There is no reason to throw yourself upon a pyre if it does not further your cause, and indeed many reasons not to.

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by 67726e on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:34PM (#6128556)
Why should someone have to lose their freedom for exposing another's wrongdoing? We should incentivize whistleblowers, not make them risk rotting in a jail cell for the rest of their lives.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by mpyne on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:33PM (#6128549)
Er, Manning would likely not have been caught without Lamo ratting him out. Manning 'sticking around' has been entirely outside of his control since that happened.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by rz2k on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:56PM (#6129193)
I think Manning probably lacked the sophistication to have as many options as Snowden.

Snowden, could have remained anonymous a lot longer, too, though probably not indefinitely. What do you think about him disclosing his identity before he had to?

I also don't think Snowden had the same options as Ellsberg to have his contributions to public debate so quickly recognized since there are different attitudes in Congress right now. Quite likely, as long as he remains safe for a few years, he'll get powerful senators as protectors, too.

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by elpool2 on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:02PM (#6128779)
Snowden's activism is quite different from MLK's so I don't think that's a very fair comparison. MLK was specifically advocating for breaking unjust laws. The whole point was to get arrested and then show the world "this is how African Americans are being treated." The point of Snowden's leak is to reveal unconstitutional spying, it's not necessarily about the plight of whistle-blowers. Getting himself arrested and put on trial does nothing to further his cause.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @03:22PM (#6129367)
Here we go again with the "your convictions aren't real unless you're willing to be tortured, imprisoned, and murdered for them" bullshit. As if black people weren't actually oppressed until King was jailed in Birmingham.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by kalms on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @05:26PM (#6130170)
First off, he was exposed by someone else. Unlike Snowden who stepped forward on his own.

Not that it matters, though. Manning is still a hero in my book!

Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ... by gadders on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:38PM (#6128591)
Does this apply to Aaron Schwartz as well?