Moreover, while all police have, in theory, the ability to enforce the complete city code, most departments have specialized departments: vice, homicide, burglary, etc., because it's simply more efficient to have a police officer who knows their section of enforcement really well (as well as being able to develop sources specific to that beat)
Cutting out a campus police force means that the people who respond to campus infractions would be police force accustomed to dealing with city crime. This isn't such a bad thing when the crime is something like homicide, serious assault, or rape...but assuming that the majority of incidents involve noise/party infractions, curfew violations, and trespassing, I think it's doubtful that the city police would be the ideal officials to take on these calls. If anything, the city police would just end up having another department specialize in campus crime, and these cops would probably be lower tier cops...which, again, is probably not going to make campus life particularly fun.
MIT police seem to have become a lot more "police-like", especially with respect to creative forms of trespassing, during the previous administration.
I'd also argue that having campus police is not mutually exclusive of fostering the creative mischief that you mention...in fact, I'd argue that having campus police is the best way to maintain that creative mischief. Again, a police close to its constituents learns (ideally) the give and take and the pulse of the people it serves. A well-managed MIT police force could handle all the calls that are made by well-intentioned people, but come in knowing a likelihood of how much caution to take...whereas if you leave it to the Boston police force, who knows how familiar that officer is with said kind of call in that particular part of campus. An effectively managed campus police force can help keep things de-escalated.
Whether that's happening at MIT is beyond the scope of this argument, but I'm just pointing out that it's not necessarily either-or
Part of what happened at MIT was Susan Hockfield, who was by far the worst President MIT has ever had (2004-2012) -- pushing a lot of these developments (expansion of bureaucracy/deans, more "conventional" police responses to issues, ...). Vest (1990-2004) was better, and Reif (2012-now) seems pretty good, but I mostly stopped caring.
In the off-case you do need to arrest someone on campus you need sworn police, and while it's possible to detain someone for a "real" cop to come arrest them, you end up that way with situations where someone who just needs to be separated from the campus population for a bit, instead ends up in city lockup with all that implies.
Cops are allowed to use their best judgment when handling civil and criminal complaints (this is, after all, one of the things Arizona was trying to "fix" with their anti-immigration laws, was to make enforcement of those law mandatory on their cops).
You have no evidence of that; you just made it up out of thin air.
Odds would be that it was a MIT student scraping
Every large network, and there's no reason to exclude MIT, gets attacked by non-students on a regular basis. They can't just assume every portscan is innocuous.
It's actually addressed in the report:
"Ultimately, MIT concluded that the communication from the IP address located in China was a — not unusual — “pinging” attempt by someone or some entity in China to determine what computer systems at MIT were available and accessible, and unrelated to the activity of this laptop."
Said like someone who has never been to Hyde Park: http://chicagomaroon.com/2012/05/25/a-brief-history-of-the-u....
The times I've wandered down there, I wouldn't have minded if U Chicago had a private army...
Oh come on what kind of statement is that to make?
Universities pay for their own police. The goal of the university is to avoid incidents which would deter parents from sending their children to the school. Rape, particularly date rape/incidents involving alcohol are quite common on campus, if only due to demographics (young, socially connected, etc.)
There are three ways to solve it -- either actually addressing the underlying issues, or full prosecution of every incident, or sweeping it under the rug to the extent possible.
#1 is obviously ideal, but difficult. #2 would end up with both scary stats and large numbers of other students with felony convictions. #3 is the standard university police outcome.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bennett-l-gershman/campus-cult... is one article.
Anyone who is a victim of a serious crime in a place with "internal" police should almost certainly report directly to the territorial police instead, or at least in addition to, since they have much fewer conflicts of interest, and probably more expertise in dealing with serious crimes.
("Real" police departments are also (theoretically) much more accountable to voters and the public, too. This is particularly an issue with weird transit or internal-to-agency police like the BART Police (who are tied with East Palo Alto PD as the worst department in the region).)
Then I would expect over time with the Internet that that would not be as effective as it was in years past before the Internet.
Do we have any data on how this has changed now that anyone can broadcast anything and get attention? I would expect that if the primary reason for existence of the police force was to control the information flow as I think you suggest (which it could do quite easily pre internet) that we should see much more of this negative information has come out because it has a path.
Has that been the case? (Serious question).
I'm not saying the only thing the police do is hide rapes, it's that their essential differentiation vs. other LEOs would be to protect their employers from embarrassment which would be detrimental to the organization's mission, which rape would be. So the reason it exists as a distinct force is that, whereas they still spend a large percentage of their effort in duties totally in common with a city police force.
Perhaps it would be better to look for a solution where universities are less motivated to compete for student head count, so that their police forces are less motivated to cover up incidents that would reduce it.
https://www.google.com/search?q=downgrade+crime
I'm not saying that we don't need checks on the system, but to say that university police don't provide any valuable service is ridiculous.
One of the things which was mentioned in the report as a potential policy question to be considered is whether random visitors to the campus should be given some level of consideration as extended members of the MIT community. (If Aaron had been an MIT student or some other member of the MIT community, the situation would have probably been handled quite differently, and it might have gotten escalated to someone higher level inside MIT --- i.e., one of MIT's Deans ---- much more quickly, instead of having the Cambridge police get involved, who then brought in a Secret Service buddy of his, at which point things escalated down a very different path, one which was largely out of MIT's control.)
One important thing to remember is that when people talk about "MIT decided", it's really not MIT as the entire organization, but individuals who happen to be MIT employees making various decisions on the spot. So from the perspective of the institution, if someone makes a decision which is within their scope of their responsibility, and that decision was consistent with the policy in force at that particular point in time, and that person was acting in good faith, MIT the organization has to really protect that person, and not offer that person up as a sacrificial lamb to hordes of ravening Internet denizens screaming for revenge. It might have been the case that if someone like Hal Abelson had been brought in that fateful night, he would have made a different choice at multiple points in the timeline. But until Aaron committed suicide, it seems pretty clear that this whole affair wasn't considered something that required the attention of senior MIT administration officials, or the consideration of senior faculty members such as Prof. Abelson.
In some ways, the way some folks have been complaining about MIT is very similar to how the Republicans have been certain that decisions made by lower level staffers in the IRS must be something where direct blame must be laid at the feet of someone senior in the White House.
Can you explain this more? INLINE EDIT: I take it you are saying that IS&T would have not gone to the Cambridge Police Department at all if there were no Campus Police. I'm not sure this follows. They wanted to get this person to stop, and they surely could have just confiscated this laptop, but that may have actually been illegal since it wasn't theirs.
Edit: Need some explanation on this, too:
> I love how MIT tries to pin blame on their budgetary cutbacks and staff furloughs, too.
I assume you are referring to page 20, when MIT employees didn't respond until January 3rd to a JSTOR email sent on December 26/27th. How are they "pinning blame" on anything there? It reads as a very straightforward description of the timeline.
I don't believe universities should have police departments (or really that any private organizations should have police departments, or even quasi-government organizations like transit agencies). University police essentially exist to cover up rapes on campus. In general they're underresourced and get used in a weird "quasi insider" role.
I don't think a competent IS&T would have gone directly to the Cambridge police if there were no MIT police. The "oh no, China!" thing is BS; traffic analysis would show that the china logins were (presumably) ssh portscans and not real connections. Basic network monitoring would show that this was just a badly written scraper and not anything more malicious. Odds would be that it was a MIT student scraping, and calling the cops on a MIT student for scraping a resource like that would have been bogus, too.
I love how MIT tries to pin blame on their budgetary cutbacks and staff furloughs, too.
I also think aaronsw was a moron in several ways (not rate limiting, not treating the box as a throwaway encrypted box, general behavior, and ultimately killing himself), but I'm more willing to cut a 24 year old slack than a multi-billion dollar endowment university which claims to be at the forefront of science.
Today I'm kind of sad I dropped out of MIT to do a startup, because it means I can't burn my diploma and promise to never donate to MIT. Oh well.