News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by btilly on Monday July 29, 2013 @12:52PM (#6122259)
Pinch to zoom absolutely should have been rejected.

Watch the 2002 movie Minority Report for what I consider prior art on the 2007 patent filing at http://www.google.com/patents/US7844915.

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by throwawaykf on Monday July 29, 2013 @05:26PM (#6124014)
And here I am again to provide a friendly reminder that before discussing any patent, you must read the claims! If you did so, in this case, you would see that this is not a "pinch-to-zoom patent", but rather a "pinch-to-zoom-if-the-event-object-created-from-touch-input-has-two-or-more-points-else-scroll-the-view-instead" patent.

Yes, it literally covers something as specific as creating "event objects" out of touch inputs and interpreting them as either zooming or scrolling gestures.

Minority Report is not sufficient prior art because:

1) It does not include a touch-sensitive display,

2) its user input is not "points applied to the touch-sensitive display" that it does not have,

3) it is wholly non-enabled (at least in the movie) which is why it does not teach, as far as we can tell, create "event objects" in response to user input,

4) and though it may depict scrolling gestures and pinching gestures in various scenes, it does not teach how to determine whether an input is a scroll or a pinch (which this patent proposes doing by differentiating the number of points in the touch input).

But why even worry about fictional, non-enabled prior art when people have found specific prior art to (temporarily) invalidate these claims?

[deleted]
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by WildUtah on Monday July 29, 2013 @06:48PM (#6124363)
[Edit: deleted parent asked: "May I ask why you include the word \"temporarily\" regarding prior art? ... Am I wrong? Does prior art now somehow not invalidate a claim/patent?"]

Usually a patent applicant can claim a narrow distinction between his claim and existing prior art. Consider gp's list of available distinctions from the Minority Report zoom feature; it's a litany of distinctions without any actual difference as far as the actual nature of the 'invention.'

It's a standard technique in patent law to apply for a series of patents around the invention of a competitor. The patent office can be persuaded to issue new monopolies over every kind of meaningless distinction. You can make it impossible for that competitor to make his invention by blocking every kind of trivial and obvious change and improvement in design, technique, and build. Then he will have to cross license in order to continue in business and you gain access to his patents. It's one of the ways big businesses continue to operate in the face of a broken patent system.

Apple recently overcame a post-grant rejection of their bounce-back patent on appeal. They argued that the prior art showed the technique to re-center the center of a fixed-size document so that it fit on the screen while their technique was completely distinct. Apple instead aligned the edge of a fixed size document to the edge of the screen so that it fit. The logical and geometric and mathematical and programming equivalency of those two did not overcome the PTO's affection for rhetorical distinctions and the patent was re-issued.

http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20130509083407920

(Note that Samsung is very unlikely to get the re-trial in the story; the PTO's position on distinctions is widely approved in the bar.)

So, no. Prior art does not invalidate a claim in most circumstances.

In the most recent "When Patents Attack" episode, This American Life found 5,000 patents that covered the exact same 'invention.' That invention was online backup. The one 1990s patent under litigation could not be invalidated by the five thousand others between it and IBM's first implementations in the 1950s. (They eventually invalidated it another way, after trolls collected hundreds of millions of dollars.)

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by throwawaykf on Monday July 29, 2013 @09:47PM (#6124983)
In addition to your response to the deleted parent, I just wanted to clarify the procedural reasons why this rejection is temporary: Basically this rejection was a result of an "ex parte" re-examination. The catch is that not only does a 3rd party (typically the alleged infringer) get a shot at invalidating the claims, the patent owner also gets to argue back, and if unsuccessful, even to redraft them to be valid again in light of the new prior art. Typically they will be redrafted to sidestep prior art, yet still cover the allegedly infringing products.
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by throwawaykf on Monday July 29, 2013 @07:57PM (#6124627)
> it's a litany of distinctions without any actual difference as far as the actual nature of the 'invention.'

So then, what, in your opinion, is "the actual nature of the invention"? Could you provide some legal reasoning behind what you consider "the actual nature of the invention"?

> In the most recent "When Patents Attack" episode, This American Life found 5,000 patents that covered the exact same 'invention.'

Oh lord, was that American Life episode a bad piece of reporting about patent-related things! In the entire show, the word "claims" appeared not once! Amongst the worst reporting I've seen, and I say this having read stuff on techdirt!

But since you bring up the "5000 patents on the same thing" claim, allow me to talk about that.

The guy who made that claim works for a firm called M-CAM, who provide a service to find similar patents based on content similarity. I looked through all of the "similar" patents they mentioned in that episode. Each and everyone one covered specific implementations of various aspects of cloud backup such as load-balancing, availability, de-duping, I/O performance for high-latency connections, etc. They were "on the same thing" inasmuch that they related to the broad area of online backup, but none had any claims that overlapped. If M-CAM had any good examples of patents covering "the same thing", they didn't mention a single one on that show.

Furthermore, M-CAM issue reports about the strength of various patent portfolios. I looked through some of the "reports". They were absolutely worthless. They considered two patents to "cover the same invention" if they had some keywords in common. To them, "Alice is taller than Bob" and "Alice is less tall than Bob" would be a claim on the "same thing".

Oh, but look! M-CAM also sell a "patent-risk management service" [1]! Strange that their claims on that show would lead some to think the patent system as something that is overly "risky", no?

(BTW, I am not the only one who thought M-CAM was full of crap [2].)

> They eventually invalidated it another way, after trolls collected hundreds of millions of dollars.

Interestingly, as described in the second episode, that patent was found invalid only because the inventor did not name all his co-inventors on it. He sneakily filed the patent alone, sold it to IV, and raked in millions of dollars as a cut of the royalties.

Leaving aside the fact that the inventor was a sleazebag, that throws the whole "patent trolls pay actual inventors very little" narrative -- one that the previous American Life episode played up -- right out the window. Oddly, nobody seems to report that.

[1] http://www.m-cam.com/sherwood-patent-risk-management-service...

[2] http://gametimeip.com/2012/04/13/q-why-was-mdb-capital-right...

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by WildUtah on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @12:29AM (#6125385)
So then, what, in your opinion, is "the actual nature of the invention"?

There is no invention. Bounce back and pinch to zoom are creative interaction designs, not inventions at all. They are not processes, machines, or compositions of matter. It's purely harmful to the industry and innovation to assign monopolies on them.

Not that that will stop the PTO.

In the entire show, the word "claims" appeared not once!

From the transcript[1]:

"prove that he has this idea and here's how the idea works and to draw the figures for the patent and to come up with the claims."

[1] http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/496/t...

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by throwawaykf on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:41AM (#6125641)
Are you saying bounce back and pinch to zoom solve no practical problem? Are you absolutely sure? If so, you could:

1. Look at the Background section of the patents for a hint. Pretty much all patents have them.

2. If you don't trust the patents (and I won't blame you), ponder why Apple put those interactions in there. Or, even if they weren't just copying it, why Android had it too.

3. Or you could try to use a mobile device without those features to find the value in them. Would you want to use a smartphone on which you have to manually distinguish between scrolls and pinches every time? Or one without bounceback? Let me tell you, I have a Galaxy S2 without bounceback, obviously due to Apple's enforcement. It has that blue glow workaround. Personally I find it pretty inferior.

Heck, even Windows Phone has a better workaround, the "elastic" over-scroll, one that does not seem to infringe Apple's claims. Look at that! Forced innovation through workarounds! And of course, MS went ahead and patented that too, so Android was out of luck for a while.

Furthermore: are you sure that their implementation does not count as a process? And are you sure those implementations can do anything without machines?

I'm curious, because these are questions the Supreme Court itself struggles with. (Not to mention the perennial flame wars on patentlyo.)

BTW, that quote is from the second episode. Can you find a single mention of the word "claims" in the original episode, the one I was talking about in the context of "5000 patents on the same thing"?

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by Samuel_Michon on Monday July 29, 2013 @02:52PM (#6123064)
I don’t understand that reasoning. If that’s valid prior art, then patents for functioning time machines won’t hold up either.

I think you’d have a point if it pertained to a design patent. If some movie used a tablet that looked exactly like an iPad, 10 years before Apple produced it, then surely Apple’s design patent for it would be worth zilch. However, the pinch-to-zoom patent describes an implementation in minute detail.

IANAL though, perhaps someone with proper credentials will be so kind to enlighten us.

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by Dylan16807 on Monday July 29, 2013 @03:18PM (#6123236)
Patents are supposed to be on mechanisms, not effects. If you figure out a way to travel through time, your patent only applies to that particular way. Pinch to zoom is something with almost no behind-the-scenes mechanism to it, and what mechanism might be valid for a patent existed in the movie.
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by btilly on Monday July 29, 2013 @04:09PM (#6123550)
I could post my own explanation of why I said what I said, but it would merely be this one, more poorly worded. :-)
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by tvtime15 on Monday July 29, 2013 @11:18PM (#6125224)
But for subject matter to be patentable, the patent must be sufficient to reduce to practice. In the movie it was just special effects, which is not sufficient to meet the reduce to practice threshold.
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by throwawaykf on Monday July 29, 2013 @09:57PM (#6125003)
As an exercise, should you get a chance, could you read claim 1 and explain how it differs from a mechanism?
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by srik on Monday July 29, 2013 @02:56PM (#6123085)
Minority report's UI was functional - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6YTQJVzwlI
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by dragonwriter on Monday July 29, 2013 @06:24PM (#6124267)
> I don’t understand that reasoning. If that’s valid prior art, then patents for functioning time machines won’t hold up either.

Patents on functioning time machines are likely to be problematic, anyway, since the natural response to such a patent [1] is to copy the machine, go back in time to before the patent was filed, and file a patent on it. It doesn't take many repetitions of this loop before the original patent on the device is expiring just about the time the device was actually invented.

[1] Ignoring all the other problems with causality and paradox inherent in time travel.

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by baddox on Monday July 29, 2013 @03:04PM (#6123142)
> If that’s valid prior art, then patents for functioning time machines won’t hold up either.

Good.

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by Samuel_Michon on Monday July 29, 2013 @03:22PM (#6123260)
Point taken, but won’t that mean that if someone figures out how to make a time machine, they will simply not apply for a patent and try to keep the design to themselves? (They could for instance sell time travel as a service, but not sell the machines or license the tech to other companies)

In theory, patents grant the inventor exclusivity for a limited time so that they can recoup their investment, in exchange for sharing the secret with the world.

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by baddox on Monday July 29, 2013 @04:24PM (#6123651)
I have no problem with a time machine inventor choosing to keep the design to themselves. I also have no problem with him/her releasing the design for free, or even licensing the technology contractually. I have a problem with the government, funded partially by money I earned but have no control over, protecting any sort of intellectual property.
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by snom380 on Monday July 29, 2013 @06:18PM (#6124239)
Wouldn't that just give even more power to big corporations? Or do you think things would work themselves out without government interference?
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by baddox on Monday July 29, 2013 @06:48PM (#6124365)
I think the patent system, and indeed all intellectual property laws, give more power to big corporations.
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by mrpdaemon on Monday July 29, 2013 @04:16PM (#6123598)
If you had a functioning time machine you could travel back in time and file the patent before any prior art was created.
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by btilly on Monday July 29, 2013 @06:46PM (#6124362)
Not necessarily.

I have, in fact, seen a potential design for a time machine which violates no known laws of physics and could take you back in time only as far as the point where the machine itself was built. This would prevent the "patent filing leapfrog" that you are talking about.

Before anyone wonders why this machine has not been built, it requires a rapidly rotating rod, several light years long, about the diameter of the Sun. To travel in time you need to orbit the rod at extremely high speed, and your direction relative to the spin of the rod determines which direction you travel through time.

In theory it should work. But reducing theory to practice is somewhat beyond our current means. :-)

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by maskedinvader on Monday July 29, 2013 @10:11PM (#6125033)
I am not an expert but I believe this is BS, would you care to cite any references or paper that talks about this so called potential design ?
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by btilly on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @12:26AM (#6125380)
It was a paper I was shown by a professor over 20 years ago. Said professor is now long-retired and I do not have the paper.

As he described it to me then, the paper presented an exact solution with an infinite bar, and then heuristic arguments that a very long but finite bar would demonstrate the same effects. The underlying mechanism is, of course, the result of a form of frame dragging.

The professor who showed it to me said that he was convinced that the math in the infinite model was correct, and was still deciding if he was convinced by the heuristic argument.

Googling quickly, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronald_Mallett describes a similar scheme, which might even be the same one. Whether or not it is the same, the 1992 paper from Hawking that was discussed would show that the heuristic argument is wrong. However since I was shown this paper while I was in undergrad, Hawking's paper would not have come out yet, and the professor who showed it to me can not be faulted for not having found the necessary flaw.

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by wnoise on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:03AM (#6125446)
Tipler, "Rotating cylinders and the possibility of global causality violation" Physical Review D, vol. 9, Issue 8, pp. 2203-2206

http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1974PhRvD...9.2203T

Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by Selfcommit on Monday July 29, 2013 @07:56PM (#6124622)
This is probably the most interesting comment I've read on this entire article.
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by dragonwriter on Monday July 29, 2013 @06:25PM (#6124272)
Yeah, but so would any infringer, thus making the infringement prior art for the invention.
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by didgeoridoo on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @07:42AM (#6126316)
Samsung tried to cite a scene in 1968's "2001: A Space Odyssey" in their patent defense against Apple: http://abcnews.go.com/m/story?id=14387499&ref=https%3A%2F%2F...
Re:US patent office rejects claims of Apple 'pinch to zoom' ... by hnriot on Monday July 29, 2013 @08:35PM (#6124763)
Wouldn't you simply go back and file the patent before the movies? If you've invested a time machine, then regardless of the patent status you'll instantly become extremely wealthy and capable of pretty much anything. worrying about the USPO would be very low on your list of things to worry about.