News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On why removing features makes people unhappy by noptic on Monday July 29, 2013 @09:38AM (#6120990)
This will burn all my carma:

Can we please talk about what he says?

Is the topic in any way related to good blog design?

There are quite a few blogs without capitalization and if it is really so important to you feel free to write about it.

IMHO All those comments on design/grammar/font/... in every discussion on HN are mere distractions and add no value.

Re:On why removing features makes people unhappy by notacoward on Monday July 29, 2013 @09:55AM (#6121094)
In general I have the same reaction as you, but in this specific case I think there's a connection. Both the cummings-esque lack of capitals and the general GNOME decision-making process seem to have their roots in a mindset that values "style" over respect for others - users, quoted authors, whoever is deemed "outside" with respect to the post author's own small circle. While comments that focus only on the unfortunate orthography without making that connection might be a waste of time, I think using the visual representation as a symbol of the underlying problem has some validity. Maybe if we all talked about gNOme (as in "NO" to every user request) it would make the point more clearly.
Re:On why removing features makes people unhappy by chris_wot on Monday July 29, 2013 @10:18AM (#6121232)
I really think it shows a disconnect between what the author thinks is good design and what IS good design.

But speaking of substance, there wasn't really much there. He talked about users like they were an inconvenience and were unreasonable, and that they had some odd psychological issue that needed correcting. Yet he never addressed the genuinely useful features that were removed, or the feeling by users that if they used features in Gnome they might one day lose them, even if the need them.

Re:On why removing features makes people unhappy by PhasmaFelis on Monday July 29, 2013 @11:49AM (#6121831)
Sure! What he says is essentially "I used to be confused and hurt by users' complaints and desires. Then I devised a pop-psych theory for why users have desires, and having done that, I can confidently tell them to go to hell."

This is terrible, terrible design philosophy and no one should ever listen to it. The end.

Re:On why removing features makes people unhappy by emhart on Monday July 29, 2013 @10:06AM (#6121162)
I rarely join in the sideline / distracting conversations on HN comment threads, but I do genuinely believe in this case it acts as a mirror to the content. Absolutely not going to downvote you for pointing out the disconnect, though, hopefully no one else did, either.
Re:On why removing features makes people unhappy by RyanMcGreal on Monday July 29, 2013 @11:29AM (#6121680)
I voted you up because I think your comment is honest and written in good faith.

The author's lack of capitalization is not important enough to me to write an article about it and post it to HN, but it was important enough to me to point it out in a comment on the forum page discussing the article.

It seems to me to exemplify exactly what is wrong with the author's approach to features... and by extension, with the GNOME development team's approach to the same.

Re:On why removing features makes people unhappy by TylerE on Monday July 29, 2013 @09:53AM (#6121087)
Nonsense! They create social pressure to not make a web page that looks like hot trash.