News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mbell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:33PM (#6118371)
Why would I even read a science article from 'The Rolling Stone' and presume there is any validity to it?

That isn't to say it isn't true, it may well be, but seriously, find a better source.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by rdl on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:46PM (#6118411)
They're a surprisingly good source for major articles. If you had important information for a mass audience and wanted to reach that audience, it would be a good choice of publication.

I mean, they got rid of GEN McChrystal, among other things.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by tsotha on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:53PM (#6118814)
Accidentally.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by rdl on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:01PM (#6118834)
Michael Hastings and Matt Taibbi between them cover a lot.

The 2009 "The Great Vampire Squid" was a good article, although it probably went too far. http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/the-great-american...

The Operators was a great book; it grew out of the article in RS, and was excerpted there. http://www.amazon.com/Operators-Terrifying-Americas-Afghanis...

I liked their Billy Corgan article, although that's music.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by Amadou on Monday July 29, 2013 @09:28AM (#6120929)
Hastings died in a fiery one-car crash one recent morning in Los Angeles.

FWIW, My personal worldview is very much aligned with Taibbi's but I can never get more than a handful of paragraphs into anything he writes because the invective is so overwhelming.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by rayiner on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:49PM (#6118800)
Uh, Rolling Stone has some serious journalists. I find him a bit shrill, but Matt Taibbi had some pretty good coverage of the financial coverage in Rolling Stone over the last few years.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by snowwrestler on Monday July 29, 2013 @12:40PM (#6122163)
Matt Taibi is an excellent writer who rarely lets nuance, detail, or chronological sequence get in the way of a great rant.

He's very entertaining to read, but not someone I would hold up as a good example of serious journalism.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by drewblaisdell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:05PM (#6118471)
> Why would I even read a science article from 'The Rolling Stone' and presume there is any validity to it?

You can read the article (which you clearly haven't done) and answer this question yourself.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mbell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:12PM (#6118494)
Yes, I read it. How exactly do you expect me to determine the validity of the words in the article? Please tell me you don't simply believe them to be factual based on their articulate organization. If you do, there is no hope for this conversation.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by dasil003 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:54PM (#6118610)
I see, so appeal to authority is your primary means of a qualifying truthiness?
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mbell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:59PM (#6118631)
I expect an appeal to data to qualify my determination of truthiness, which the article lacks. That is, after all, the way of science.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by woah on Monday July 29, 2013 @03:00AM (#6119713)
Then how does the authority even come into it? Why didn't you make this your first comment?
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by snowwrestler on Monday July 29, 2013 @12:38PM (#6122154)
Appeal to authority is only a fallacy when the authority is fallacious.

Let's ask Linus Torvalds and me a question about the architecture of git. Whose answer would you trust more?

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by moocowduckquack on Monday July 29, 2013 @01:19AM (#6119491)
To start with, you could look up the scientist mentioned, read their work and then cross reference it against other published research.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mbell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:25PM (#6118528)
The response to this is a great example of how far Hacker News has fallen. The readership here appears to be in a state of believing what The Rolling Stone says in place of actual scientific research.

If you want an example of how intellectual forums die, this thread is it.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by arrrg on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:12PM (#6118680)
It’s a magazine article about a science topic, a.k.a. the most normal thing in the world. Only in bizarro-HN-world would that even begin to raise any eyebrows.

Yes, journalists are in fact allowed to write about science topics and there is nothing wrong with that in itself. No, not everything that’s written about science has to have been published in a peer-reviewed science journal. Good science journalism is awesome and there should be much more of it.

It’s this honestly bizarre cynical and twisted worldview that’s wrong with HN, most certainly not that someone posted this article.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by beedogs on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:15PM (#6118868)
It's an infection it acquired from an incestuous relationship with Reddit, where anything that isn't peer-reviewed or watermarked is the object of karma-whoring wannabe-internet-detectives.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by ams6110 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:06PM (#6119136)
The eyebrow-raiser is that Rolling Stone is hardly a non-biased source, I don't think they even try to pretend otherwise. Therefore by default you should view anything you read there with skepticism.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by brazzy on Monday July 29, 2013 @04:23AM (#6119916)
You should read everything you read anywhere with skepticism. The big problem is that people vary their skepticism more according to how much they want to believe something than the credibility of the source.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by tripzilch on Monday July 29, 2013 @08:23AM (#6120572)
> You should read everything you read anywhere with skepticism.

Care to back that up with some data?

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mbell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:17PM (#6118698)
I don't honestly know how I could disagree with you more. Your definition of a 'bizarre' world equates to my version of an ideal world.

How dare people question media?

How dare people think for themselves instead of accepting what media tells them?

How dare they?

You have vilified everything that goes wrong with a democratic society.

Your mentality is the problem.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by beedogs on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:16PM (#6118871)
Yeah, that's great, but for fuck's sake, you don't "question media" by simply launching into an ad-hominem attack against the Rolling Stone. Stop trying to defend your little tantrum up above by having another little tantrum.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by enraged_camel on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:41PM (#6118946)
His tantrum is so childish it is embarrassing. He responds to himself complaining about the response his whiny ad hominem comment received. The ironic icing on the cake is that he is complaining about how far HN has fallen!
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by arrrg on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:21PM (#6118711)
You are completely free to question the media and think for yourself. The linked article provides more than enough information to actually get you started.

No one ever claimed you have to accept what the article says.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by cpleppert on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:20PM (#6118879)
0% of what you claim to be responding to is what he actually said. For someone that claims to be want to carefully evaluate the information presented to him you might want to figure out what he actually said.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mikeash on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:30PM (#6118748)
Baseless complaints about the source does not qualify as "question media". Your comment is mindless contrarianism, not the intelligent skepticism you think it is.

You're free to question media. Welcome, in fact. I would love nothing more. But you didn't do it, and to act as though you did when someone calls you out is dishonest.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by jussij on Monday July 29, 2013 @02:47AM (#6119681)
> If you want an example of how intellectual forums die, this thread is it.

Ok, let’s try to apply some intellectual thinking to the article.

Firstly, The Rolling Stone is not a scientific journal, but rather a magazine catering to the general public.

Secondly, I read the article, not as a scientific paper on climate change, but rather an article about a particular climate change scientist, Jason Box.

The article presents Box's opinions on climate change and his latest prediction that black snow could have a big impact on the rate of ice melt.

How is that any different, to say, an article asking Bjarne Stroustrup's his opinions of the C++11 standard?

It's an opinion piece, from someone whose opinion should be worth reading, if only because they have expertise in that field.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mikeash on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:14PM (#6118686)
A metric assload of popular articles without sources or citations make the front page every day. But the only one anyone complains about is one related to global warming. Because it's somehow worse? No. Because many people are incapable of examining that particular issue without emotion.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by ams6110 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:04PM (#6119133)
Because many people are incapable of examining that particular issue without emotion

I hope you mean that as directed to both sides of the argument, because it's certainly true.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mikeash on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:23PM (#6119187)
Certainly, and they feed on each other in a crazy feedback cycle. However, that doesn't and shouldn't diminish the fact that the actual science solidly favors one side.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by jussij on Monday July 29, 2013 @02:59AM (#6119712)
> However, that doesn't and shouldn't diminish the fact that the actual science solidly favors one side.

Despite the alarmist title, I found this a good video on the topic of climate change:

"The Alarming Science Behind Climate Change's Increasingly Wild Weather"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-RDE7z2T0k

I'd recommend the second portion of the video, as it’s a good old fashion, boring, highly scientific and un-emotive description of one particular view of how higher arctic temperatures can affect the climate.

I also found the second portion worked well as a tutorial on the basics of how the world’s climate actually works.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by drewblaisdell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:27PM (#6118735)
> The readership here appears to be in a state of believing what The Rolling Stone says in place of actual scientific research.

You're clearly concerned with citations, so I'll ask for one: where did anyone here say, even implicitly, that they valued a Rolling Stone article in place of actual scientific research?

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by gruseom on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:55PM (#6118613)
HN has always featured sciencey articles from the popular press (as well as complaints about the decline of HN, for that matter), so your claim is at first glance untrue. It does seem testable, though. Do you have any data to support it?
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by DanBC on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:44PM (#6118578)
It seems odd to criticise this article for not being intellectually rigorous enough, when there is so much dross posted every hour.

The article gives plenty of caveats.

Is there anything factually wrong in the article? Or is it that you disagree with his hypothesis? Or is it simply the lack of cites?

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by snowwrestler on Monday July 29, 2013 @12:48PM (#6122232)
I agree with you that Rolling Stone is not a great forum for learning about scientific topics. But I disagree that it's proof of a new problem with HN.

Climate change, like much cutting-edge scientific research, rarely gets informed or rational treatment on programmer forums. Just look back through the history of climate change articles on Slashdot, for instance. They are chock full of objections or concerns that would be answered with an hour or two on Wikipedia or the IPCC website.

The reason is that programmers and engineers think that they think like scientists, when the reality is that most think exactly the opposite of scientists. Programmers and engineers seek to use knowledge to eliminate uncertainty; scientists seek uncertainty in the hope of discovering new knowledge.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mzr on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:21PM (#6118710)
I'll expect you to make the same comment on posts that claim to want to "change the world". This is an actual world changing event, not some marketing bullshit.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by foobarbazqux on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:36PM (#6118558)
What scientific claims does the article make that you think we believe?
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by michaelwww on Monday July 29, 2013 @03:13PM (#6123202)
People like you complaining is a sign of health. When complaints of falling quality stop it's because the people who seek better quality have left.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by woah on Monday July 29, 2013 @03:00AM (#6119717)
Wait... I thought this was a thread about a JS-intensive magazine site layout?
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by tterrace on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:50PM (#6118424)
This is nonsense. You should judge the article on its own merit.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mbell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:55PM (#6118444)
Your statement is ridiculous. I could say anything and argue it should be judged on it's own merit, where are the sources? There were zero citations in this article.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by TillE on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:02PM (#6118460)
It directly quotes a number of scientists. What more do you want? It's not an academic paper, of course there are no "citations".
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by jasonlotito on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:15PM (#6118504)
> What more do you want?

He wants things handed to him. Rather than follow up via the multiple sources they provided, along with a link to the project itself, he'd prefer we do that work for him.

Which is sad, really. That people don't want to take the time to research things on their own, and simply expect things handed to them.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by tterrace on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:05PM (#6118468)
What source are you looking for exactly? The piece was about the Dark Snow Project, and the journalist trekked around Greenland with the guy that founded it.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mbell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:03PM (#6118647)
I want data, and analysis of data, and the initial conditions required to produce said data. If you don't provide that, you are not providing scientific value. Rather, you're writing an opinion piece that can only ever be as accurate as the author's knowledge, and well, The Rolling Stone doesn't produce scientifically educated authors.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by moocowduckquack on Monday July 29, 2013 @01:32AM (#6119518)
If you want data on public research and don't go looking for it yourself, then you are just lazy. You know the name of the scientist and the project from the article which is all you need if you then want to look deeper. Stop winging.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by arrrg on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:18PM (#6118702)
It’s not a scientific paper (nor does it claim to be).

You are expecting this to be something it is not. And not even trying to be.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by JamisonM on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:26PM (#6118730)
I want data and analysis of data to support your assertion that The Rolling Stone does not produce scientifically educated authors!
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by foobarbazqux on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:13PM (#6118496)
Where is your scientific evidence that there is only merit in scientific evidence?
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by foobarbazqux on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:04PM (#6118466)
You wouldn't, but that's because it's not a science article. It's a pop culture magazine article portraying a climate change researcher as a rock star. There's very little discussion of the falsifiable hypotheses he wants to test - some bits about models, reflectivity, and black microbes is all you get. But biographies are okay, they can help to put a face on things. That said, I didn't find it the most compelling read but the picture of the waterslide was worth it.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by jasonlotito on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:17PM (#6118511)
> But biographies are okay, they can help to put a face on things.

Damn right. They do far more for science than people realize. You make science fun and exciting, and it draws people in. Not everyone wants to start with all the technical data.

Hell, the best scientists understand this.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by tsotha on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:55PM (#6118822)
The problem with rock star scientists is the entire field takes a hit when someone turns out to be a fraud.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by meritt on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:51PM (#6118429)
This is the same Rolling Stone that placed the younger Tsarnaev on their front cover like some sort of rock icon. Fuck Rolling Stone and everything associated with it.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by bpatrianakos on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:45PM (#6118582)
If you're upset about Tsarnev then you either didn't read that article or get the point. The photo they used was a real one, it wasn't doctored, the point of which was to ask the question of how this seemingly intelligent, non-extreme, all-American looking boy could become radicalized and become involved in a terror plot. That article was an example of the kind of real journalism that's lacking in this country.

Rolling Stone has for years now been a great source for good journalism. It's not just a music magazine and hasn't been for a long time. They've been doing a lot of good investigative reporting for at least the past ten years that I know of and maybe more.

You may not like what you read but the fact that it came from Rolling Stone is totally irrelevant. You want sources? Read the article. They're in there. You want citations? Read an academic journal. What magazine or newspaper that you know of puts citations for every little thing in their articles? None. Because they're not publishing academic papers. If no source is valid without the citations you require then no magazine is a valid source by your logic - logic that's flawed.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by ams6110 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:01PM (#6119123)
Just wait until Tsarnaev is Time's "person of the year"
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mikeash on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:28PM (#6119206)
And what if he is? That title is about influence, good or bad. Hitler was PotY once, and it was not an endorsement, just an acknowledgment.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by IanDrake on Monday July 29, 2013 @08:04AM (#6120496)
The problem being that acknowledgement is what these crazy people are looking for and RS just gave it to them.

Keep in mind, the best form of censorship is a market based one. When a company does wrong, I'd rather a boycott than have some government do-gooder step in.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by hoggle on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:48PM (#6118418)
"National security officials worried by rapid loss of Arctic summer sea ice overlook threat of permanent global food shortages"

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/earth-insight/2013/may...

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mcgwiz on Monday July 29, 2013 @03:12PM (#6123198)
Setting aside the defense of RS by sibling comments, part of the reason this article is of interest is its presentation format.

Find a peer-reviewed science journal that also provides a rich multimedia experience and you can argue that there is a source that is "better" for the purposes recognized here (content and presentation format).

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by tlb on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:51PM (#6118810)
Yes please: submit a proper scientific article about this research.