News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by arrrg on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:12PM (#6118680)
It’s a magazine article about a science topic, a.k.a. the most normal thing in the world. Only in bizarro-HN-world would that even begin to raise any eyebrows.

Yes, journalists are in fact allowed to write about science topics and there is nothing wrong with that in itself. No, not everything that’s written about science has to have been published in a peer-reviewed science journal. Good science journalism is awesome and there should be much more of it.

It’s this honestly bizarre cynical and twisted worldview that’s wrong with HN, most certainly not that someone posted this article.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by beedogs on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:15PM (#6118868)
It's an infection it acquired from an incestuous relationship with Reddit, where anything that isn't peer-reviewed or watermarked is the object of karma-whoring wannabe-internet-detectives.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by ams6110 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:06PM (#6119136)
The eyebrow-raiser is that Rolling Stone is hardly a non-biased source, I don't think they even try to pretend otherwise. Therefore by default you should view anything you read there with skepticism.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by brazzy on Monday July 29, 2013 @04:23AM (#6119916)
You should read everything you read anywhere with skepticism. The big problem is that people vary their skepticism more according to how much they want to believe something than the credibility of the source.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by tripzilch on Monday July 29, 2013 @08:23AM (#6120572)
> You should read everything you read anywhere with skepticism.

Care to back that up with some data?

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mbell on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:17PM (#6118698)
I don't honestly know how I could disagree with you more. Your definition of a 'bizarre' world equates to my version of an ideal world.

How dare people question media?

How dare people think for themselves instead of accepting what media tells them?

How dare they?

You have vilified everything that goes wrong with a democratic society.

Your mentality is the problem.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by beedogs on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:16PM (#6118871)
Yeah, that's great, but for fuck's sake, you don't "question media" by simply launching into an ad-hominem attack against the Rolling Stone. Stop trying to defend your little tantrum up above by having another little tantrum.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by enraged_camel on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:41PM (#6118946)
His tantrum is so childish it is embarrassing. He responds to himself complaining about the response his whiny ad hominem comment received. The ironic icing on the cake is that he is complaining about how far HN has fallen!
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by arrrg on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:21PM (#6118711)
You are completely free to question the media and think for yourself. The linked article provides more than enough information to actually get you started.

No one ever claimed you have to accept what the article says.

Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by cpleppert on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:20PM (#6118879)
0% of what you claim to be responding to is what he actually said. For someone that claims to be want to carefully evaluate the information presented to him you might want to figure out what he actually said.
Re:Greenland’s ice sheets are disappearing faster than anyon... by mikeash on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:30PM (#6118748)
Baseless complaints about the source does not qualify as "question media". Your comment is mindless contrarianism, not the intelligent skepticism you think it is.

You're free to question media. Welcome, in fact. I would love nothing more. But you didn't do it, and to act as though you did when someone calls you out is dishonest.