News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by acheron on Sunday July 28, 2013 @02:32PM (#6117567)
I wish them good luck in overcoming the anti-scientific hysteria. But I fear relying on scientific literacy is going to end in failure.

How many other advances in agriculture are we going to sacrifice to appease these superstitions? (Not to mention similar superstitions of anti-vaccine activists, who are probably the same people in many cases.)

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by x0x0 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:01PM (#6118089)
you say anti-scientific hysteria, I say reasonable fears regularly ignored by industry and whitewashed by an industry captured fda. example 1: bpa

from the wiki article [1]:

   In 2006, the US Government sponsored an assessment of the scientific 
   literature on BPA. Thirty-eight experts in fields involved with bisphenol A 
   gathered in Chapel Hill, North Carolina to review several hundred studies on 
   BPA, many conducted by members of the group. At the end of the meeting, the 
   group issued the Chapel Hill Consensus Statement,[100] which stated BPA at 
   concentrations found in the human body is associated with organizational 
   changes in the prostate, breast, testis, mammary glands, body size, brain 
   structure and chemistry, and behavior of laboratory animals.[101]

   The Chapel Hill Consensus Statement found that average levels in people are 
   above those that cause harm to many animals in laboratory experiments. They 
   noted that while BPA is not persistent in the environment or in humans, 
   biomonitoring surveys indicate that exposure is continuous, which is 
   problematic because acute animal exposure studies are used to estimate daily 
   human exposure to BPA, and no studies that had examined BPA pharmacokinetics 
   in animal models had followed continuous low-level exposures. They added 
   that measurement of BPA levels in serum and other body fluids suggests the 
   possibilities that BPA intake is much higher than accounted for, and/or that 
   BPA can bioaccumulate in some conditions (such as pregnancy).[100]
   
   A 2008 report by the Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human 
   Reproduction within the U.S. National Toxicology Program (NTP), which is 
   within the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, reported the 
   results of its exhaustive review of the literature. Its conclusions, 
   expressed relative to current estimates of general population exposure 
   levels in the U.S., were the following:
and yet bpa is still used. So when we hear that monsanto pinky-swears their experiments, even when they contaminate neighboring fields, are super duper safe, or orange growers promise up and down that, well, their genetic modifications they introduced to prevent their business from being destroyed are absolutely positively safe (we promise!)... forgive me for being skeptical.

Not to mention the freakout about labeling foods; if they weren't knowingly poisoning us, why exactly would corporations be so very afraid of properly labeling foods? Any reasonable adult should have his or her bullshit detector going off when they are told gmo is absolutely safe, but it's the end of the world if we tell people which foods have gmo ingredients so that they can choose what to eat.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bisphenol_A

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by eli on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:38PM (#6118183)
You cut off the quote just before it details the experts' estimate that, extrapolating from animal studies, the threat of BPA ranges from "some concern" for fetuses (the FDA banned the use of BPA in baby bottles) to "negligible concern" for adults. From a much more recent meta-analysis of existing data: "The analysis showed that BPA levels were often so low that it was below the ability of current toxicological methods to detect it, raising the possibility that most instances of high BPA dose might have been the result of contamination from tubes and plastics in hospitals." http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2013/feb/15/no-toxic-effec...

Anyway, I agree it's hard to argue with "label the product and let the consumer decide." But I think the case could be made that it plays on people's unscientific views of what is and isn't healthy. As with "organic" or "locally sourced" there's nothing stopping companies that don't use GMOs from putting a "No GMO" label on their food. Some already do.

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by x0x0 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @10:32PM (#6119051)
No I didn't and you misquoted the paragraph and accidentally (I hope ?) changed the meaning.

What was actually said was:

   For adults, the Expert Panel has negligible concern for adverse reproductive 
   effects following exposures in the general population to Bisphenol A
you'll note that does not say "negligible concern" for adults, it says "negligible concern for adverse reproductive effects".

And you know what was never studied? General safety for adults under actual dosing as experienced in reality. Further on down the same wiki article, just one of many concerns:

    The authors found that higher bisphenol A levels were significantly 
   associated with heart disease, diabetes, and abnormally high levels of 
   certain liver enzymes
Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by eli on Monday July 29, 2013 @09:19PM (#6124897)
I think this thread is increasingly unlikely to be productive, but I'm puzzled why you think I've changed the meaning. I think it is accurate to say that the expert panel concluded the threat of BPA ranges from "some concern" to the most vulnerable groups to "negligible concern" for most healthy adults. Are you suggesting the expert panel found that BPA posed more than a "minimal" threat to adults in regards to something besides reproductive harm? I don't see that in the report...

Anyway, I think you nail the exact point I was trying to make: no studies have shown BPA to be dangerous in adults at the levels that are actually encountered in the environment. (There's little doubt that BPA is bad for you at doses orders of magnitude higher than those normally encountered, but that's true of a great many things.)

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by crusso on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:28PM (#6118151)
if they weren't knowingly poisoning us, why exactly would corporations be so very afraid of properly labeling foods

For the same reason that measles infections are on the rise? Because the public is largely ignorant and doesn't understand much about Science or genetic engineering and thus is easily influenced by Hollywood and celebrities who in their ignorance push their favorite environmental/medical causes (Jenny McCarthy).

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by x0x0 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @10:37PM (#6119067)
Please. Jenny McCarthy is a fucking idiot.

See the wiki article for evidence published in medical journals that bpa harms human beings. There's plenty of evidence to say it should be banned, at bare minimum until long term studies at actual dosing levels have been performed.

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by jrkelly on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:23PM (#6118717)
"if they weren't knowingly poisoning us, why exactly would corporations be so very afraid of properly labeling foods?"

Because when you label something consumers assume it is bad for them. That's why we don't force companies to label things that aren't actually dangerous. See study from MIT on GMO labels: http://courantblogs.com/capitol-watch/gmo-labels-send-a-mess...

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by x0x0 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @10:38PM (#6119068)
I don't need you to decide for me what I'm allowed to know about what I eat.
Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by ims on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:25PM (#6118137)
There's a difference between chemicals and genetically modified foods.

We know that human health can be damaged by all sorts of different chemicals. That being established, the task at hand is identifying which are harmful (or usually in what quantities do they become harmful).

Meanwhile there is no persuasive evidence that any foods become harmful simple because they have been genetically modified. Completely different.

> if they weren't knowingly poisoning us, why exactly would corporations be so very afraid of properly labeling foods?

Perhaps precisely because of this hysteria surrounding GMO?

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by rogerbinns on Sunday July 28, 2013 @04:57PM (#6118080)
I don't think the hysteria is anti-scientific. It is more a suspicion of agricultural corporations, of secrecy and of American companies. The perception of Monsanto is an excellent example. Corporate paternalism is not appreciated. Consider why companies lobbied so hard for GMO to not be labelled as such.

If almost every product was labelled as GMO then after a while consumers would not care. They would be able to make their own choices about "regular" versus GMO. Instead the fight has been to "trust us" and to keep GMO secret.

"Known to the State of California to cause cancer" is everywhere. No one bats an eyelid any more.

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by crusso on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:33PM (#6118170)
The poster didn't mean that the hysteria was against Science itself, rather that it wasn't based upon any type of Scientific analysis or investigation.

The fact that people will become apathetic to GMO labeling eventually doesn't mean that the industry won't fight to avoid the unwanted (and undeserved) stigma for now.

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by rogerbinns on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:51PM (#6118426)
> ... avoid the unwanted (and undeserved) stigma for now

There is that paternalism again. It is not up to the producers of any product to decide if attention is undeserved. Consumers get to decide that. And yes some will be wrong etc. Shining a light and being truthful is the right way of doing things.

The hysteria is not against science - it is against paternalism hiding itself as "trust us because science". Science requires being open and honest.

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by jrkelly on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:26PM (#6118726)
I actually think it is more fair for it to be up to the FDA to decide. The reason companies don't want labels is that people then assume the product is unsafe. Here is an MIT study finding exactly that for GMO labels: http://courantblogs.com/capitol-watch/gmo-labels-send-a-mess...
Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by rogerbinns on Sunday July 28, 2013 @10:37PM (#6119064)
The FDA decides if a product can even be sold. So what if truthfully labelled products are considered unsafe by some? Why shouldn't people be able to make up their own minds? The freedom that allows them to do that also also means sometimes they will be wrong. Again, so what? Sweeping it under the rug ("trust us") is not adequate.

You do not foster understanding, science, progress or freedom by hiding things.

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by olouv on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:37PM (#6118389)
That's clearly wrong. You just have to actually read studies to find clear warnings about the toxicity of GMO. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0278691512...
Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by zsombor on Sunday July 28, 2013 @07:49PM (#6118599)
Expect a lot more: the banana for example that had it's reportedly most tasty variant (Gros Michel) gone extinct in the last century. The variant you are buying today (Cavendish) is under great strain and is likely to go down the same route.

Species have been disappearing long before humans existed, there is nothing new here. We have always developed close cultural ties to what we eat, this made changes expensive. Hard to imagine a world without orange juice, bananas, plum fruit or a tasty tomato. Our ancestors lacked the tools to prevent losses. We have it and this only makes the loss more painful.