News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by eli on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:38PM (#6118183)
You cut off the quote just before it details the experts' estimate that, extrapolating from animal studies, the threat of BPA ranges from "some concern" for fetuses (the FDA banned the use of BPA in baby bottles) to "negligible concern" for adults. From a much more recent meta-analysis of existing data: "The analysis showed that BPA levels were often so low that it was below the ability of current toxicological methods to detect it, raising the possibility that most instances of high BPA dose might have been the result of contamination from tubes and plastics in hospitals." http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2013/feb/15/no-toxic-effec...

Anyway, I agree it's hard to argue with "label the product and let the consumer decide." But I think the case could be made that it plays on people's unscientific views of what is and isn't healthy. As with "organic" or "locally sourced" there's nothing stopping companies that don't use GMOs from putting a "No GMO" label on their food. Some already do.

Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by x0x0 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @10:32PM (#6119051)
No I didn't and you misquoted the paragraph and accidentally (I hope ?) changed the meaning.

What was actually said was:

   For adults, the Expert Panel has negligible concern for adverse reproductive 
   effects following exposures in the general population to Bisphenol A
you'll note that does not say "negligible concern" for adults, it says "negligible concern for adverse reproductive effects".

And you know what was never studied? General safety for adults under actual dosing as experienced in reality. Further on down the same wiki article, just one of many concerns:

    The authors found that higher bisphenol A levels were significantly 
   associated with heart disease, diabetes, and abnormally high levels of 
   certain liver enzymes
Re:A Race to Save the Orange by Altering Its DNA by eli on Monday July 29, 2013 @09:19PM (#6124897)
I think this thread is increasingly unlikely to be productive, but I'm puzzled why you think I've changed the meaning. I think it is accurate to say that the expert panel concluded the threat of BPA ranges from "some concern" to the most vulnerable groups to "negligible concern" for most healthy adults. Are you suggesting the expert panel found that BPA posed more than a "minimal" threat to adults in regards to something besides reproductive harm? I don't see that in the report...

Anyway, I think you nail the exact point I was trying to make: no studies have shown BPA to be dangerous in adults at the levels that are actually encountered in the environment. (There's little doubt that BPA is bad for you at doses orders of magnitude higher than those normally encountered, but that's true of a great many things.)